f*********m
发帖数: 732 | 1 My first time to be a journal reviewer. Just want to hear your opinions.
Thanks. |
y******l
发帖数: 900 | 2 tell them your inclination to accept, conditional accept, revise, or reject
the paper. Also provide a justification of the decision.
【在 f*********m 的大作中提到】
: My first time to be a journal reviewer. Just want to hear your opinions.
: Thanks.
|
f*********m
发帖数: 732 | 3 But I already put these comments to the authors. Just simply repeat it again?
reject
【在 y******l 的大作中提到】
: tell them your inclination to accept, conditional accept, revise, or reject
: the paper. Also provide a justification of the decision.
|
f******s
发帖数: 140 | 4 通常给AE的那一栏是可以放一些敏感的东西，比如你不想让author知道的，但是你又希
望AE知道的东西，或者是会泄漏你自己身份的东西。如果你觉得没什么特别要说的，空
着也可以。 |
y******l
发帖数: 900 | 5 I will not put my decision on the notes to the authors. But it is up to you.
again?
【在 f*********m 的大作中提到】
: But I already put these comments to the authors. Just simply repeat it again?
:
: reject
|
x3
发帖数: 616 | 6 i always leave it blank
【在 f*********m 的大作中提到】
: My first time to be a journal reviewer. Just want to hear your opinions.
: Thanks.
|
G***y
发帖数: 1082 | 7 You can leave it blank if you don't have anything special to say.
【在 f*********m 的大作中提到】
: My first time to be a journal reviewer. Just want to hear your opinions.
: Thanks.
|
