h*********y
发帖数: 360 | 1 文章投了一个杂志，editor的decision letter说：we would be willing to publish
your manuscript if you are able to make the revisions according to the
comments given by the reviewers.
这是accept with major revision还是revise& resubmit？ |
T*********r
发帖数: 11175 | 2 这有区别吗？
你反正都得revise再resubmit
publish
【在 h*********y 的大作中提到】
: 文章投了一个杂志，editor的decision letter说：we would be willing to publish
: your manuscript if you are able to make the revisions according to the
: comments given by the reviewers.
: 这是accept with major revision还是revise& resubmit？
|
l********n
发帖数: 804 | 3 1st
publish
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.8
【在 h*********y 的大作中提到】
: 文章投了一个杂志，editor的decision letter说：we would be willing to publish
: your manuscript if you are able to make the revisions according to the
: comments given by the reviewers.
: 这是accept with major revision还是revise& resubmit？
|
m********n
发帖数: 3558 | 4 我觉得一样。。。。。你要是revise的不好 人家当然也可以说你没有 revise
according to comments . 当然看起来editor 语气是相当positive 的。不过我没听过
"accept with major revision" 这种说法。一般都是 accept with minor revision |
h*********y
发帖数: 360 | 5 谢谢！
revision
【在 m********n 的大作中提到】
: 我觉得一样。。。。。你要是revise的不好 人家当然也可以说你没有 revise
: according to comments . 当然看起来editor 语气是相当positive 的。不过我没听过
: "accept with major revision" 这种说法。一般都是 accept with minor revision
|
l***y
发帖数: 4671 | 6 莫非是 editors 的新模板？这个措辞听着悦耳多了，而且适用面更广了。大意就是没
据，也没说收，而且没区分是 major 还是 minor revision，那个取决于 reviewers'
comments。
换句话说，唯一有用信息就是这次没据，还有机会。
publish
【在 h*********y 的大作中提到】
: 文章投了一个杂志，editor的decision letter说：we would be willing to publish
: your manuscript if you are able to make the revisions according to the
: comments given by the reviewers.
: 这是accept with major revision还是revise& resubmit？
|
T*******g
发帖数: 2322 | 7 这个很积极了。不过其实编辑积极也并不是一定是好事。每个杂志的口吻不一样。
我遇到过有一个杂志这么说（不是原话，意思是这个）
We are not able to publish your paper in its current form. However, we are
happy to reconsider the decision if you can address all the issues raised by
the reviewers. At the current stage we cannot give any promise of the final
decision for publication.
结果进去一看reviewr只有一些minor comments/typos
人家只是用这个模板而已 |
m****b
发帖数: 32 | |
a**********d
发帖数: 2293 | 9 就是conditional acceptance。 |
