s*********7
发帖数: 22 | 1 An invited paper of my advisor, senior in this area.
the two reviewers list three papers, one appear in both reviewers' reports.
since our idea is different from their papers. we didn't cite their work.
they recommend major revision.
I plan to add their paper to my references, and make other changes.
Any other suggestions? | z**s
发帖数: 12 | 2 To cite a paper with different opinion is a professional way -- especially
for your case. If you believe that the paper is wrong, it is a good
opportunity to pint it out for the community awareness. | p**m
发帖数: 11571 | 3 you are doing the right thing.
.
【在 s*********7 的大作中提到】
: An invited paper of my advisor, senior in this area.
: the two reviewers list three papers, one appear in both reviewers' reports.
: since our idea is different from their papers. we didn't cite their work.
: they recommend major revision.
: I plan to add their paper to my references, and make other changes.
: Any other suggestions?
| s*********7
发帖数: 22 | |
|
