y*********e 发帖数: 140 | 1 还是PHD学生,从来也没有REVIEW过,也还没有PAPER发出来,收到要REVIEW的JOURNAL
是我前两个月投的一个把我据了的JOURNAL.
一来自己从来没REVIEW过,根本就不知道什么样的文章该接受什么文章该据,也不知道
写多少REVIEW,怎么写,所以不想硬上.可是又担心拒绝REVIEW会得罪JOURNAL.
麻烦各位老师说说应该接受REVIEW要求吗,谢了 |
v*******y 发帖数: 5530 | 2 应该
迟早要review
JOURNAL
【在 y*********e 的大作中提到】 : 还是PHD学生,从来也没有REVIEW过,也还没有PAPER发出来,收到要REVIEW的JOURNAL : 是我前两个月投的一个把我据了的JOURNAL. : 一来自己从来没REVIEW过,根本就不知道什么样的文章该接受什么文章该据,也不知道 : 写多少REVIEW,怎么写,所以不想硬上.可是又担心拒绝REVIEW会得罪JOURNAL. : 麻烦各位老师说说应该接受REVIEW要求吗,谢了
|
m******g 发帖数: 3924 | |
Q******g 发帖数: 607 | 4 by default, all papers should be rejected unless
there is a good reason to accepted it.
JOURNAL
【在 y*********e 的大作中提到】 : 还是PHD学生,从来也没有REVIEW过,也还没有PAPER发出来,收到要REVIEW的JOURNAL : 是我前两个月投的一个把我据了的JOURNAL. : 一来自己从来没REVIEW过,根本就不知道什么样的文章该接受什么文章该据,也不知道 : 写多少REVIEW,怎么写,所以不想硬上.可是又担心拒绝REVIEW会得罪JOURNAL. : 麻烦各位老师说说应该接受REVIEW要求吗,谢了
|
s***g 发帖数: 820 | 5 Go for it. They will send you simple guideline on the criteria... |
S******e 发帖数: 299 | 6 Good for your resume.
Ask your advisor to give you some samples (of review comments). |
y******l 发帖数: 900 | 7 A good reviewer should be constructive in giving feedback to the authors. If
you like the paper, say why you like it. If you don't like somewhere, say
you why you don't like it and (suggest at least) how it can be corrected.
Nobody likes to be rejected without knowing why.
Be professional. Be constructive.
【在 Q******g 的大作中提到】 : by default, all papers should be rejected unless : there is a good reason to accepted it. : : JOURNAL
|
Q******g 发帖数: 607 | 8 of course, all rejection need a solid reason.
but not all rejected papers can be fixed.
If
【在 y******l 的大作中提到】 : A good reviewer should be constructive in giving feedback to the authors. If : you like the paper, say why you like it. If you don't like somewhere, say : you why you don't like it and (suggest at least) how it can be corrected. : Nobody likes to be rejected without knowing why. : Be professional. Be constructive.
|
y*********e 发帖数: 140 | |