y*******o
发帖数: 6632 | 1 教父 is worse than Matrix, 活着, 肖申克 and only 1 ticket more than 霸王别姬
Gump is about life, commitment, friendship, love and most important a
strenuous life.
Those who claim that Forrest is just a historical movie just do not
understand forrest at all.
Those who claim that Gump is just a comedy just do not understand how to
smile peacefully to bitterness, losing and even death. If you can not
understand "the king of comedy "(xijuzhiwang), you can not understand
Forrest Gump too. Because Forrest Gump hide the bitterness and tragedy of
living much deeper.
God of Father is good, but not so excellent to be in the final. It could be
defeated by Matrix, 活着, 肖申克, yangguangcanlan. The only reason it could
be in the final is just because its lucky. | M***y
发帖数: 2252 | 2 god of father...
【在 y*******o 的大作中提到】
: 教父 is worse than Matrix, 活着, 肖申克 and only 1 ticket more than 霸王别姬
: Gump is about life, commitment, friendship, love and most important a
: strenuous life.
: Those who claim that Forrest is just a historical movie just do not
: understand forrest at all.
: Those who claim that Gump is just a comedy just do not understand how to
: smile peacefully to bitterness, losing and even death. If you can not
: understand "the king of comedy "(xijuzhiwang), you can not understand
: Forrest Gump too. Because Forrest Gump hide the bitterness and tragedy of
: living much deeper.
| N*C
发帖数: 1987 | 3 lol。。。
【在 M***y 的大作中提到】
: god of father...
| J*******s
发帖数: 2708 | | a******e
发帖数: 396 | 5 如果导演真相让FG那么深刻，那你能解释一下为什么主角设定成一个智障呢？电影表达的阿甘成功的原因是因为人傻+运气壮。我没有看到任何表现阿甘豪情壮志不甘平庸，为了一个不平凡的理想而不断奋斗的企图。阿甘事业的成功得益于他的运气而不是理想。爱情上他唯一的爱人Jane只在人生的最后才回到她身边。而这也不是他争取来的。事实上因为他是智障，他从来没有有明确目的的做成任何事情。
阿甘整个故事编排都是为了一个噱头而已。故事本身定位就是离奇，把主角设计成一个
智障为的是增加这种离谱程度从而达到喜剧的效果。没有人会认为阿甘的整个故事是真
实的。在这种氛围下你能看出深度并且深受鼓舞实在不一般。我们作为凡人一般不能在
这种明显虚构的故事中体会出那么震撼人心的鼓舞。
教父则不同。教父1，2的故事背景接近真实，叙事张弛有序，而且逻辑丝丝入扣。全部
理解故事内容不仅需要看很多遍，而且常看常新。肖申克的叙事也是一流的，也能做到
百看不厌，但情节稍显简单，基本看一遍就看明白了。所以比教父要差一些。
另外一个让我决定投教父的原因是教父是70年代的电影，几乎没有特技，视觉效果也跟
阿甘有天壤之别。电影能做到40年后仍能让人百看不厌除了出色我不知道还能怎样评价
它。
【在 y*******o 的大作中提到】
: 教父 is worse than Matrix, 活着, 肖申克 and only 1 ticket more than 霸王别姬
: Gump is about life, commitment, friendship, love and most important a
: strenuous life.
: Those who claim that Forrest is just a historical movie just do not
: understand forrest at all.
: Those who claim that Gump is just a comedy just do not understand how to
: smile peacefully to bitterness, losing and even death. If you can not
: understand "the king of comedy "(xijuzhiwang), you can not understand
: Forrest Gump too. Because Forrest Gump hide the bitterness and tragedy of
: living much deeper.
| n*****r
发帖数: 1981 | | y*******o
发帖数: 6632 | 7 did you really pay attention to the scripts of Forrest.
为了一个不平凡的理想而不断奋斗的企图
In Gump, there is no such 理想. It is like life with no direction. What is
purpose of the life, Christian, Buddist, Indu, and monetarists all have
different perception of life, therefore 理想. In fact, most humans are not
sure about their directions at all. So there is no 理想 in the movie.
奋斗, the whole movie is about 奋斗. The running itself is a representative
of 奋斗. The Lyrics of the song "running on empty" when Gump running,
Looking out at the road rushing under my wheels —
Looking back at the years gone by like so many summer fields.
In '65 I was seventeen and running up 101
I don't know where I'm running now, I'm just running on
Running on Empty
Running blind
It is a life attitude. Like when he assembles guns in the army, he do it
with all his heart as he does everything. The only reason you did not figure
out the 奋斗 in the movie is because his entire life is 奋斗. He took it
for granted and did not mentioned it out explicitly like the trash movie "
the pursuit of happiness". If you say I am working so hard, that means you
are not working hard enough. Because when you really working hard, working
hard would be naturally as a habit. You do not feel it anymore.
爱情上他唯一的爱人Jane只在人生的最后才回到她身边。而这也不是他争取来的
If he gives up, she gives up too. She will not only gives him up, but also
gives herself up. The only reason Jane coming back to Forrest is his zhizhuo.
Maybe you are so sure about your life, what you going to do and what you
going to achieve all time. But most normal people, like me, are not. Many
times we are skeptical about myself, skeptical of the things we are doing,
skeptical about the success of our future, as well as the purpose of our
lives. But the only thing we should not skeptical is keeping running.
I hungry, I eat, I tired, I slept, when I have to go, I run.
我们作为凡人一般不能在: 这种明显虚构的故事中体会出那么震撼人心的鼓舞。
How about "dahuaxiyou" "king of the comedy" (xijuzhiwang).
达的阿甘成功的原因是因为人傻+运气壮。我没有看到任何表现阿甘豪情壮志不甘平庸
，为了一个不平凡的理想而不断奋斗的企图。阿甘事业的成功得益于他的运气而不是理
想。爱情上他唯一的爱人Jane只在人生的最后才回到她身边。而这也不是他争取来的。
事实上因为他是智障，他从来没有有明确目的的做成任何事情。
【在 a******e 的大作中提到】
: 如果导演真相让FG那么深刻，那你能解释一下为什么主角设定成一个智障呢？电影表达的阿甘成功的原因是因为人傻+运气壮。我没有看到任何表现阿甘豪情壮志不甘平庸，为了一个不平凡的理想而不断奋斗的企图。阿甘事业的成功得益于他的运气而不是理想。爱情上他唯一的爱人Jane只在人生的最后才回到她身边。而这也不是他争取来的。事实上因为他是智障，他从来没有有明确目的的做成任何事情。
: 阿甘整个故事编排都是为了一个噱头而已。故事本身定位就是离奇，把主角设计成一个
: 智障为的是增加这种离谱程度从而达到喜剧的效果。没有人会认为阿甘的整个故事是真
: 实的。在这种氛围下你能看出深度并且深受鼓舞实在不一般。我们作为凡人一般不能在
: 这种明显虚构的故事中体会出那么震撼人心的鼓舞。
: 教父则不同。教父1，2的故事背景接近真实，叙事张弛有序，而且逻辑丝丝入扣。全部
: 理解故事内容不仅需要看很多遍，而且常看常新。肖申克的叙事也是一流的，也能做到
: 百看不厌，但情节稍显简单，基本看一遍就看明白了。所以比教父要差一些。
: 另外一个让我决定投教父的原因是教父是70年代的电影，几乎没有特技，视觉效果也跟
: 阿甘有天壤之别。电影能做到40年后仍能让人百看不厌除了出色我不知道还能怎样评价
| d*e
发帖数: 843 | 8 好牛的英文。。。
【在 y*******o 的大作中提到】
: 教父 is worse than Matrix, 活着, 肖申克 and only 1 ticket more than 霸王别姬
: Gump is about life, commitment, friendship, love and most important a
: strenuous life.
: Those who claim that Forrest is just a historical movie just do not
: understand forrest at all.
: Those who claim that Gump is just a comedy just do not understand how to
: smile peacefully to bitterness, losing and even death. If you can not
: understand "the king of comedy "(xijuzhiwang), you can not understand
: Forrest Gump too. Because Forrest Gump hide the bitterness and tragedy of
: living much deeper.
|
|
