b********9
发帖数: 749 | 1 今天收到期刊主编的信。
I now have the referee's and the co-editor's reports on your paper.The the
co-editor have strong concerns regarding the overall structure of your
paper. The referee is more positive than the co-editor......In the
presence of these objections, I regret that we cannot publish your paper.
But if you can address all these concerns, you are welcome to submit it as
a new submission.
但是co-editor并没有提供 report。这个算是怎么回事？是R&R还是会送到新的referee
?回答了
referee的意见后, 成功机率多大？大家有无类似经历？ | m****m
发帖数: 2211 | 2 没有report就是完全不给你argue的机会啊
referee
【在 b********9 的大作中提到】
: 今天收到期刊主编的信。
: I now have the referee's and the co-editor's reports on your paper.The the
: co-editor have strong concerns regarding the overall structure of your
: paper. The referee is more positive than the co-editor......In the
: presence of these objections, I regret that we cannot publish your paper.
: But if you can address all these concerns, you are welcome to submit it as
: a new submission.
: 但是co-editor并没有提供 report。这个算是怎么回事？是R&R还是会送到新的referee
: ?回答了
: referee的意见后, 成功机率多大？大家有无类似经历？
| h*****t
发帖数: 1478 | 3 忘了ATTACH吧？
既然要你ADDRESS ALL THESE CONCERNS，当然是要告诉你CONCERNS是什么。你不如写信
问问看。
referee
【在 b********9 的大作中提到】
: 今天收到期刊主编的信。
: I now have the referee's and the co-editor's reports on your paper.The the
: co-editor have strong concerns regarding the overall structure of your
: paper. The referee is more positive than the co-editor......In the
: presence of these objections, I regret that we cannot publish your paper.
: But if you can address all these concerns, you are welcome to submit it as
: a new submission.
: 但是co-editor并没有提供 report。这个算是怎么回事？是R&R还是会送到新的referee
: ?回答了
: referee的意见后, 成功机率多大？大家有无类似经历？
| v******d
发帖数: 1322 | 4 对, 问主编要co-editor的report
【在 h*****t 的大作中提到】
: 忘了ATTACH吧？
: 既然要你ADDRESS ALL THESE CONCERNS，当然是要告诉你CONCERNS是什么。你不如写信
: 问问看。
:
: referee
|
|
