q*******g
发帖数: 52 | 1 ２月份提交的proposal，现在NSF网上已经出现了很多９月分开始的资助项目。估计我
的已经没有希望，但奇怪的是既然不FUND我的project，为什么不告诉我他们的决定呢
，这样我还可以继续投其他的地方啊。写信给那个program director也没有任何的回复。
有经验的朋友说说这是怎么回事，谢谢。 |
c**********0
发帖数: 836 | 2 我12月的proposal都还pending. Program manager也不回email. 不少人都说发email给
PM
石沉大海.
复。
【在 q*******g 的大作中提到】
: ２月份提交的proposal，现在NSF网上已经出现了很多９月分开始的资助项目。估计我
: 的已经没有希望，但奇怪的是既然不FUND我的project，为什么不告诉我他们的决定呢
: ，这样我还可以继续投其他的地方啊。写信给那个program director也没有任何的回复。
: 有经验的朋友说说这是怎么回事，谢谢。
|
j****e
发帖数: 20 | 3 最近NSF挺忙的， 可能是因为recovery money吧。 上次听一个PD抱怨说， 这么多年来
NSF的员工都没增加多少， 工作都增加了几倍，不回信很正常。
复。
【在 q*******g 的大作中提到】
: ２月份提交的proposal，现在NSF网上已经出现了很多９月分开始的资助项目。估计我
: 的已经没有希望，但奇怪的是既然不FUND我的project，为什么不告诉我他们的决定呢
: ，这样我还可以继续投其他的地方啊。写信给那个program director也没有任何的回复。
: 有经验的朋友说说这是怎么回事，谢谢。
|
q*******g
发帖数: 52 | 4 我能理解他们很忙。我的问题是既然他们已经决定了FUNDED的项目，为什么不通知我们
呢？现在FASTLANE里还是PENDING，没有任何更新。 |
m*******e
发帖数: 68 | 5 "我能理解他们很忙。我的问题是既然他们已经决定了FUNDED的项目，为什么不通知我
们呢？现在FASTLANE里还是PENDING，没有任何更新。"
I guess the rationale is that NSF program directors purposely delay issues
decisions to those unfunded PIs. NSF simply do not want to see that those
PIs quickly revise unfunded proposals by stating that they have incoprorated
reviewers' comments. Otherwise, NSF would be piled up with revised proposals
from last submission season...
So the strategy is that NSF tells the bad news after or very close to Fall submission deadl |
s********4
发帖数: 10 | |
c**********0
发帖数: 836 | 7 今年是比较怪. 以往被拒都4-6个月通知. 我12月的proposal status date半个月前就
变了. 所
以我等着被拒了, 结果到现在还是pending. 看来NSF在delay拒绝的通知.
issues
those
incoprorated
proposals
Fall submission deadline, those unfunded PIs will have no time to
resubmit during this year's window, that is, they are forced to spend the
next 6 months to rethink the
【在 m*******e 的大作中提到】
: "我能理解他们很忙。我的问题是既然他们已经决定了FUNDED的项目，为什么不通知我
: 们呢？现在FASTLANE里还是PENDING，没有任何更新。"
: I guess the rationale is that NSF program directors purposely delay issues
: decisions to those unfunded PIs. NSF simply do not want to see that those
: PIs quickly revise unfunded proposals by stating that they have incoprorated
: reviewers' comments. Otherwise, NSF would be piled up with revised proposals
: from last submission season...
: So the strategy is that NSF tells the bad news after or very close to Fall submission deadl
|
t**********t
发帖数: 12071 | 8 我都打听到我们的一个2月的被拒了，可是就是不给我们发据信。
【在 c**********0 的大作中提到】
: 今年是比较怪. 以往被拒都4-6个月通知. 我12月的proposal status date半个月前就
: 变了. 所
: 以我等着被拒了, 结果到现在还是pending. 看来NSF在delay拒绝的通知.
:
: issues
: those
: incoprorated
: proposals
: Fall submission deadline, those unfunded PIs will have no time to
: resubmit during this year's window, that is, they are forced to spend the
|
d***r
发帖数: 106 | 9 it seems that no news is bad news.
my proposal is still pending, and definitely declined again.
frustrated.
【在 t**********t 的大作中提到】
: 我都打听到我们的一个2月的被拒了，可是就是不给我们发据信。
|
t**********t
发帖数: 12071 | 10 的确如此。
ANYWAY，咱们MOVE ON。
【在 d***r 的大作中提到】
: it seems that no news is bad news.
: my proposal is still pending, and definitely declined again.
: frustrated.
|
|
|
w********d
发帖数: 270 | 11 I feel that if the PI proposer is not contacted within 6 months by the NSF
PO, then most likely the proposal is dead (I know several exceptions - most
probably borderline proposals).
Actually, I know several cases that if a proposal is to be funded, its
proposer was contacted by PO around one month after the panel review date (
you can check it online).
【在 t**********t 的大作中提到】
: 的确如此。
: ANYWAY，咱们MOVE ON。
|
c**********0
发帖数: 836 | 12 This is mostly true for earlier years (I know some exceptions though), but
not
this year. One of my proposals was recommended after more than 9 months (and
more than 7 months after the review) - apparently, the PM did not make
decision until that time. Earlier, all of my unfunded NSF proposals were
rejected in 6 months (2 was rejected a couple of days before 6 months), but
this year NSF is extremely slow.
most
【在 w********d 的大作中提到】
: I feel that if the PI proposer is not contacted within 6 months by the NSF
: PO, then most likely the proposal is dead (I know several exceptions - most
: probably borderline proposals).
: Actually, I know several cases that if a proposal is to be funded, its
: proposer was contacted by PO around one month after the panel review date (
: you can check it online).
|
b*****d
发帖数: 61690 | 13 今年有stimulus money,NSF那里收的proposal太多了，忙不过来
and
but
【在 c**********0 的大作中提到】
: This is mostly true for earlier years (I know some exceptions though), but
: not
: this year. One of my proposals was recommended after more than 9 months (and
: more than 7 months after the review) - apparently, the PM did not make
: decision until that time. Earlier, all of my unfunded NSF proposals were
: rejected in 6 months (2 was rejected a couple of days before 6 months), but
: this year NSF is extremely slow.
:
: most
|
s****r
发帖数: 146 | 14 In the case of your funded proposal this year, the PO made later decisions
to only your proposal or to all the proposal in the program?
months (and more than 7 months after the review) - apparently, the PM did
not make decision until that time. Earlier, all of my unfunded NSF
proposals were rejected in 6 months (2 was rejected a couple of days before
6 months), but
【在 c**********0 的大作中提到】
: This is mostly true for earlier years (I know some exceptions though), but
: not
: this year. One of my proposals was recommended after more than 9 months (and
: more than 7 months after the review) - apparently, the PM did not make
: decision until that time. Earlier, all of my unfunded NSF proposals were
: rejected in 6 months (2 was rejected a couple of days before 6 months), but
: this year NSF is extremely slow.
:
: most
|
j****s
发帖数: 156 | 15 插问一句，各位 rejected propsoal怎么处理了？扔了还是改改重投？重投到同一个地
方还是换个地方？ |
c**********0
发帖数: 836 | 16 He made decision on all proposals funded together. I called him earlier
and he said that he has not made decision on any proposal and will make
decision in around 1 month. After 1 month, I got his email. I dont know
if this PO sends notification to unfunded proposals though. but I know
that some proposal in the same program that is handled by another PO is
still pending, but the status of the fastlane has changed. dont know why
they delay the notification of unfunded proposals - wait for more m
【在 s****r 的大作中提到】
: In the case of your funded proposal this year, the PO made later decisions
: to only your proposal or to all the proposal in the program?
:
: months (and more than 7 months after the review) - apparently, the PM did
: not make decision until that time. Earlier, all of my unfunded NSF
: proposals were rejected in 6 months (2 was rejected a couple of days before
: 6 months), but
|
s****r
发帖数: 146 | 17 I called my PO tens of times and he never pick up the phone. (The reception
lady told me he is in his office). Has anybody had the same situation?
【在 c**********0 的大作中提到】
: He made decision on all proposals funded together. I called him earlier
: and he said that he has not made decision on any proposal and will make
: decision in around 1 month. After 1 month, I got his email. I dont know
: if this PO sends notification to unfunded proposals though. but I know
: that some proposal in the same program that is handled by another PO is
: still pending, but the status of the fastlane has changed. dont know why
: they delay the notification of unfunded proposals - wait for more m
|
c**********0
发帖数: 836 | 18 It seems that such a situation is common this year. I did the same thing
for another proposal and the PO never picked up the phone. She also did
not reply to emails.
reception
【在 s****r 的大作中提到】
: I called my PO tens of times and he never pick up the phone. (The reception
: lady told me he is in his office). Has anybody had the same situation?
|
