s********8
发帖数: 619 | 1 真郁闷,PNAS原来有6页的page limit.快要投了才发现文章太长了,关键是图多,有七个
图,而且都很大.
到底是换个journal还是试试featured article或者plus呢?这两个都可以有十页.但不
知道是不是很难中?还有plus是online only的,有人投过这个吗,感觉怪怪的. | H*g
发帖数: 2333 | 2 If I understand correctly, the submission policy to PNAS is that you could
only submit your manuscript to only one category, either report, or feature
article or Plus. And with every feature article, there would be one
commentary with it in the same issue. So, if you are not super confident
with the potential impacts of your manuscript, go directly to feature may
not be wise, since you couldn't go back to re-submit as a Plus.
PNAS Plus is still PNAS, just another way to publish on-line instead of in
print. The review process is all the same as the one for the 6-page report. | s********8
发帖数: 619 | 3 Thank you very much for your advice. Yes I understand that I have to chose
one of these as I submit.
I am not super confident about the feature article so I would like to try
the plus since I don't want to squeeze my paper into 6 pages.
My PI is just not very certain about the visibility of PNAS plus.
What do you think? Many thanks!
feature
【在 H*g 的大作中提到】
: If I understand correctly, the submission policy to PNAS is that you could
: only submit your manuscript to only one category, either report, or feature
: article or Plus. And with every feature article, there would be one
: commentary with it in the same issue. So, if you are not super confident
: with the potential impacts of your manuscript, go directly to feature may
: not be wise, since you couldn't go back to re-submit as a Plus.
: PNAS Plus is still PNAS, just another way to publish on-line instead of in
: print. The review process is all the same as the one for the 6-page report.
| H*g
发帖数: 2333 | 4 I suspect your PI is not a junior researcher, but instead a senior, or an
even older senior researcher.
when was the last time you want to retrieve a certain article, you opened
Pubmed and began to search, then downloaded the pdf and printed it out?
Something sounds like happened today?
And when was the last time you have to go to the library and browse over the
shelves to retrieve one article? Something maybe have never happened for
our generation.
PNAS Plus is still PNAS, which could be accessed on-line as all other PNAS
paper. For the visibility issue, I don't think that is a problem at all.
【在 s********8 的大作中提到】
: Thank you very much for your advice. Yes I understand that I have to chose
: one of these as I submit.
: I am not super confident about the feature article so I would like to try
: the plus since I don't want to squeeze my paper into 6 pages.
: My PI is just not very certain about the visibility of PNAS plus.
: What do you think? Many thanks!
:
: feature
| s********8
发帖数: 619 | 5 Thank you for the reassurance! Will go ahead to try PNAS. My PI is a senior
person indeed:)
the
【在 H*g 的大作中提到】
: I suspect your PI is not a junior researcher, but instead a senior, or an
: even older senior researcher.
: when was the last time you want to retrieve a certain article, you opened
: Pubmed and began to search, then downloaded the pdf and printed it out?
: Something sounds like happened today?
: And when was the last time you have to go to the library and browse over the
: shelves to retrieve one article? Something maybe have never happened for
: our generation.
: PNAS Plus is still PNAS, which could be accessed on-line as all other PNAS
: paper. For the visibility issue, I don't think that is a problem at all.
| s********8
发帖数: 619 | 6 真郁闷,PNAS原来有6页的page limit.快要投了才发现文章太长了,关键是图多,有七个
图,而且都很大.
到底是换个journal还是试试featured article或者plus呢?这两个都可以有十页.但不
知道是不是很难中?还有plus是online only的,有人投过这个吗,感觉怪怪的. | H*g
发帖数: 2333 | 7 If I understand correctly, the submission policy to PNAS is that you could
only submit your manuscript to only one category, either report, or feature
article or Plus. And with every feature article, there would be one
commentary with it in the same issue. So, if you are not super confident
with the potential impacts of your manuscript, go directly to feature may
not be wise, since you couldn't go back to re-submit as a Plus.
PNAS Plus is still PNAS, just another way to publish on-line instead of in
print. The review process is all the same as the one for the 6-page report. | s********8
发帖数: 619 | 8 Thank you very much for your advice. Yes I understand that I have to chose
one of these as I submit.
I am not super confident about the feature article so I would like to try
the plus since I don't want to squeeze my paper into 6 pages.
My PI is just not very certain about the visibility of PNAS plus.
What do you think? Many thanks!
feature
【在 H*g 的大作中提到】
: If I understand correctly, the submission policy to PNAS is that you could
: only submit your manuscript to only one category, either report, or feature
: article or Plus. And with every feature article, there would be one
: commentary with it in the same issue. So, if you are not super confident
: with the potential impacts of your manuscript, go directly to feature may
: not be wise, since you couldn't go back to re-submit as a Plus.
: PNAS Plus is still PNAS, just another way to publish on-line instead of in
: print. The review process is all the same as the one for the 6-page report.
| H*g
发帖数: 2333 | 9 I suspect your PI is not a junior researcher, but instead a senior, or an
even older senior researcher.
when was the last time you want to retrieve a certain article, you opened
Pubmed and began to search, then downloaded the pdf and printed it out?
Something sounds like happened today?
And when was the last time you have to go to the library and browse over the
shelves to retrieve one article? Something maybe have never happened for
our generation.
PNAS Plus is still PNAS, which could be accessed on-line as all other PNAS
paper. For the visibility issue, I don't think that is a problem at all.
【在 s********8 的大作中提到】
: Thank you very much for your advice. Yes I understand that I have to chose
: one of these as I submit.
: I am not super confident about the feature article so I would like to try
: the plus since I don't want to squeeze my paper into 6 pages.
: My PI is just not very certain about the visibility of PNAS plus.
: What do you think? Many thanks!
:
: feature
| s********8
发帖数: 619 | 10 Thank you for the reassurance! Will go ahead to try PNAS. My PI is a senior
person indeed:)
the
【在 H*g 的大作中提到】
: I suspect your PI is not a junior researcher, but instead a senior, or an
: even older senior researcher.
: when was the last time you want to retrieve a certain article, you opened
: Pubmed and began to search, then downloaded the pdf and printed it out?
: Something sounds like happened today?
: And when was the last time you have to go to the library and browse over the
: shelves to retrieve one article? Something maybe have never happened for
: our generation.
: PNAS Plus is still PNAS, which could be accessed on-line as all other PNAS
: paper. For the visibility issue, I don't think that is a problem at all.
| s*******h
发帖数: 23 | 11 这个貌似很慢。。。我同学有一回投了，等了3个月过去没音，结果后来还是被拒了 |
|
