f***r
发帖数: 344 | 1 I submitted a manuscript to PNAS a few days ago, the editor(s) feeded back
that I should add in more verification and allowing me a re-submit. Now I'm
going to re-submit, but how should I re-submit? Just submit as normal like a
new submission? There is no link to a 're-submission' on the paper status
interface.
Please help! Thanks a lot! |
D*a
发帖数: 6830 | 2 你能不能把信贴上来？
现在大家都故意弄得模糊不清，其实是为了数据好看
没有弄过pnas，不过我看见的其他杂志的几封信都是“if you want to re-submit a new manuscript”这种，杂志认为这是一个“new manuscript” |
f***r
发帖数: 344 | 3 thanks for your reply.
the editor clearly said that they accept a re-submission if i follow their
comments, and the manuscript will go to the original editor. but problem is
that they don't give re-submission link...
new manuscript”这种，杂志认为这是一个“new manuscript”
【在 D*a 的大作中提到】
: 你能不能把信贴上来？
: 现在大家都故意弄得模糊不清，其实是为了数据好看
: 没有弄过pnas，不过我看见的其他杂志的几封信都是“if you want to re-submit a new manuscript”这种，杂志认为这是一个“new manuscript”
|
s********s
发帖数: 3945 | 4 If the editor said so, why won't you email him/her?
is
【在 f***r 的大作中提到】
: thanks for your reply.
: the editor clearly said that they accept a re-submission if i follow their
: comments, and the manuscript will go to the original editor. but problem is
: that they don't give re-submission link...
:
: new manuscript”这种，杂志认为这是一个“new manuscript”
|
s***e
发帖数: 911 | 5 Re-submission as a new manuscript. Include your communications with the
editor in the cover letter.
is
【在 f***r 的大作中提到】
: thanks for your reply.
: the editor clearly said that they accept a re-submission if i follow their
: comments, and the manuscript will go to the original editor. but problem is
: that they don't give re-submission link...
:
: new manuscript”这种，杂志认为这是一个“new manuscript”
|
f***r
发帖数: 344 | 6 yes you are right. i have emailed them.
【在 s********s 的大作中提到】
: If the editor said so, why won't you email him/her?
:
: is
|
f***r
发帖数: 344 | 7 thanks for your suggestion. i think i have to go that way.
【在 s***e 的大作中提到】
: Re-submission as a new manuscript. Include your communications with the
: editor in the cover letter.
:
: is
|
g*****p
发帖数: 451 | 8 resubmission不享受修改过程中被人家抢发而仍然保留稿件的service
你文章收受了以后也会显示新的submission的日期
投稿的时候用新的entry
但是在cover letter里把你的旧投稿号写清楚
并表明是resubmission
不过怎么感觉你这文章是投稿程序出了问题？并不是peer review以后的稿件，那怎么
投都无所谓了吧
m
a
【在 f***r 的大作中提到】
: I submitted a manuscript to PNAS a few days ago, the editor(s) feeded back
: that I should add in more verification and allowing me a re-submit. Now I'm
: going to re-submit, but how should I re-submit? Just submit as normal like a
: new submission? There is no link to a 're-submission' on the paper status
: interface.
: Please help! Thanks a lot!
|
f***r
发帖数: 344 | 9 不是投稿程序问题，我也很奇怪，还没送审呢，编辑提了一堆意见让我改。PNAS 风格
就这样吗？
【在 g*****p 的大作中提到】
: resubmission不享受修改过程中被人家抢发而仍然保留稿件的service
: 你文章收受了以后也会显示新的submission的日期
: 投稿的时候用新的entry
: 但是在cover letter里把你的旧投稿号写清楚
: 并表明是resubmission
: 不过怎么感觉你这文章是投稿程序出了问题？并不是peer review以后的稿件，那怎么
: 投都无所谓了吧
:
: m
: a
|
d***y
发帖数: 8536 | 10 就是重新开始投。投得时候把你上次投得号 也给编辑。 |
f***r
发帖数: 344 | 11 thanks
【在 d***y 的大作中提到】
: 就是重新开始投。投得时候把你上次投得号 也给编辑。
|
