k*****o
发帖数: 1486 | 1 JBC is good enough for a lot of fields. I think Nat. series is 70% about
editor, 30% about reviewer. Besides, I really think novelty is just a lame
excuse.
On the contrary to your case, I saw many "follow-up" studies published on
CNS, but the original one was on some more specific journals. The reason is
probably that your research has not been tested enough, and those reviewers
are just too conservative to take your NEW ideas. Especially
when you want to publish something working against the pa... 阅读全帖 |
|
m**h
发帖数: 381 | 2 做了好几年的工作，virus infection and host immune system的领域，攒出来一大堆
date，故事也说圆了，老板也认为不错，觉得我得工作是目前关于这个问题最完整最有说服力的研究工作，可惜老板一直觉得新意不够。
刚投了immunity，审稿一个月后，一个reviewer说很好没有任何意见，另一个说没有新意，结果editor以”没有新意“为由给毫不留情的据了。
和老板商量了准备换个杂志投，老板还是觉得novelty是个问题，不反对试别的好杂志但他个人建议赶快投个容易接受的杂志。可是俺实在不忍心看着这么多工作好几年的心血就去投个小
杂志。所以还想试试好一点的杂志，找了找，觉得cell host and microbe 和 PloS
Biology从IF上看都还很不错的。不过不知道这两个杂志是不是都很难投啊？有知道的
大侠给说说吧？例如是不是对novelty要求很高？
另外，如果immunity据了以后，投同是cell press的cell host and microbe 杂志，
editor是不是会知道原来投immunity被据的事？那是不是会很吃亏啊？
谢... 阅读全帖 |
|
i*e
发帖数: 352 | 3 没明白你怎么会理解到“对图的质量要求高”去的
你去PLoS ONE主页去看他们的goal和reviewer审稿的指南
他们看重的是experimental technically sound，不是impact和novelty
他们挑战的就是impact和novelty
是驴是马拉出来溜溜，让reader而不是editor和reviewer觉得文章工作本身的价值 |
|
c********b
发帖数: 363 | 4 植物的microRNA和epigenetics都很热,但是你要考虑好,因为现在job market上已经很
多人了,每个山头也都被占满了,所以真的再跳就算火坑了.
我老板总说NSF强调的是novelty,一堆人做的时候只会给top的几个组钱,这也是为什么
Weigel在美国很难混,因为做花的太多,他想做mechanism,但是又不符合novelty.
很难说植物做什么以后会不错,只能做一些你可以做别人做不了的才能生存. |
|
F*Q
发帖数: 3259 | 5 【 以下文字转载自 Faculty 讨论区 】
发信人: FAQ (飞龙在天), 信区: Faculty
标 题: 没有CNS历史的单一作者的文章真的不能发CNS?！
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Mar 29 10:37:44 2012, 美东)
投CNS不到两个礼拜被编辑退稿，虽然说了我的分析很interesting，但没有点明具体的
退搞理由，只是说了他们挑选稿件的标准是基于displine, novelty and general
significance。
我的东西的 significance 以及 novelty 是每个听过或看过我东西的人都能能感觉到
的！给我口头报告的会议的组委会成员，好几个（包括我们领域的专业期刊的主编）在
我给报告之前就跟我说很期待我的报告，那东西听起来很有意思。我在报告后专门找到
我们领域专业杂志的主编咨询他的态度，他没有直接对我报告的东西作评论，只是点出
了几个专门作那个方面的实验室，好奇为什么他们没有go further。我跟他解
释他们用的传统技术没法go further。同时我给他指出来有一个实验室用我这种新技术
几年前发了一篇... 阅读全帖 |
|
f*******o
发帖数: 150 | 6 Impacting our young
Much has been written about impact factors, how they are calculated, and what they do and do not
measure. Briefly, the Institute for Scientific Information (ISI) impact factor is calculated for each
journal as the number of citations per paper published in that journal in the prior 2 years. When
the 2-year impact factor was designed, it was intended to be an aid to librarians making decisions
about which journals to purchase so that they could get a rough sense of a journal's... 阅读全帖 |
|
A*******e
发帖数: 284 | 7 cns的选文标准是novelty和general sense。另外人家还会考虑你文章被引用率。全新
表型和全新基因，novelty足够了。你到任何的cns上找一篇从mutant做起克隆基因的
paper，那个基因没有个motif domain之类的。你在基因组上可以找到很多没有注视的
基因，但是这些基因的功能做起来谈何容易，从0开始。你任何在这个基因上的工作都
是开创性的。也可以顺着你的说法说，是因为这方面的研究难以开展。别人难以开展的
东西你开展了，是不是说明你的工作意义了。个人觉得新基因新表型这是最大的卖点。
搁往年，这些就足够上ns了。但现在不行了，你得做下游，解释表型。 还是那句话，
表型重要与否，直接决定文章大小。
若我市楼主的话，既然你互补成功了，我会尽力做下游，找到它调控那条pathway，而
不是focus在那个氨基酸重要，这些或许是下一篇文章，你的核定位既然做出了，已经
没有什么太大问题了，不要纠缠于GFP fusion是不是足够好，cns上大把的用这方法定
位的。expression profiling是必须的，RNA seq或microarray，或许找到targ... 阅读全帖 |
|
s****9
发帖数: 932 | 8 也跟风说说自己的两个经历。
一个是Nature，两个组的合作，对方是大company，贡献了80％的data，大部分是前期
的screen和in vitro的东西，我们20％data，给了一些in vivo的验证。因为我们验证
的base也是基于他们的screen结果，所以算他们的文章，我们也就是打酱油的。Nature
回来之后3个reviewer，一个reviewer说好，一个说还行，但是要补vivo的实验，最后
一个reviewer说了2页纸的试验，要补一堆vivo实验。对方的company的corresponding
author显然没有什么投稿经验，磨了3个月截至日期快到了，没有东西也没搞出来。我
老板一看，就把我自己project的东西加到里面，帮着回了response。只回答了第二个
reviewer的问题，把第三个reviewer说了一通。最后contribution大约60－40 （他们
60％，我们40％）。老板人很好，自己什么也没要，帮我争取了一个co－first。文章
最后接受了。我当时很高兴，一个figure就搞了个Nature co-first。后来发现这个排... 阅读全帖 |
|
s******9
发帖数: 283 | 9 The peer review process at Science
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmselect/cmsc
1.Peer-reviewed scientific publications represent the primary useful archive
of scientific progress. Scientific publications have served other main
functions as well: They are a primary means of evaluating scientists and
institutions, and they have become a main pathway for informing the general
public about science, through coverage in the media and press releases (new
results are news). Peer-revi... 阅读全帖 |
|
N******n
发帖数: 3003 | 10 For synthesis of drugs see www.drugsyn.org.
Dear Huajun,
First I would like to congratulate you for the same on the other hand I
would like to make you cautious about it.
Go for a patent if you have made a novel compound that is active. But you
have to follow some precautions:-
1. Dont disclose your invention in open foram like this, it will distroy the
novelty of your invention.
2. Collect as many data as you can and keep it secret from every one, dont
even disclose it in your friends.
3. Deriv... 阅读全帖 |
|
w***r
发帖数: 709 | 11 好多文章都是被scoop了很长时间了以后才发的，novelty严重不足！
-----
这才是真正的悲哀，你做四年，人家比你快三四个月，你就狗屎了，大家看笑话（
novelty严重不足！），人生就飞流直下三千尺。其实大家都知道重要的结论是需要独
立验证的。 |
|
w***r
发帖数: 709 | 12 好多文章都是被scoop了很长时间了以后才发的，novelty严重不足！
-----
这才是真正的悲哀，你做四年，人家比你快三四个月，你就狗屎了，大家看笑话（
novelty严重不足！），人生就飞流直下三千尺。其实大家都知道重要的结论是需要独
立验证的。 |
|
D**A
发帖数: 311 | 13 要尽快，文章novelty还不错的话，就elife。
文章做的实验很多，novelty不够，就embo j。
nat comm. 无经验 |
|
y***n
发帖数: 109 | 14 我花了半年时间摸索开发了一个novel technique，这个领域还没有人在做。成型之后
实验室很多人都可以用到。我也还在往下做，做下来肯定是一篇很好的一坐文章。
同lab的一个同事的paper悲剧了，其中一个原因是缺少novelty。然后跟老板说想用我
的这个technique做点东西加上去。
问题来了。这个文章大部分都成型了。用我这个技术也就一个figure，甚至suppl
figure，那么我也就一个middle author。我可不想就这样就把我好不容易开发的技术
出卖了，回头我投文章的时候不就少了一个novelty了吗？
老板还没有跟我谈，不知道该怎么跟老板argue呢？如果老板坚持用，是不是可以争取
共同一坐？因为我花了很大精力来开发这个技术？
多谢啦！ |
|
B*********e
发帖数: 86 | 15 怎么判断一篇文章是“没啥novelty的”啊？~~
我早两天也收到篇。。。。咋一看还不知道是本还没正式出刊的杂志，rsc总体定位不
错，没啥novelty的就直接据了把
在给RSC Advances审一篇稿子，不好也不坏，创新性不足，就是Routine work，估计投
个IF2~3的杂志比较合适，但不了解RSC Advances 定位是个什么档次的杂志啊？有没有
了解情况的，给点意见吧。 |
|
B*********e
发帖数: 86 | 16 怎么判断一篇文章是“没啥novelty的”啊？~~
我早两天也收到篇。。。。咋一看还不知道是本还没正式出刊的杂志，rsc总体定位不
错，没啥novelty的就直接据了把
在给RSC Advances审一篇稿子，不好也不坏，创新性不足，就是Routine work，估计投
个IF2~3的杂志比较合适，但不了解RSC Advances 定位是个什么档次的杂志啊？有没有
了解情况的，给点意见吧。 |
|
m***j
发帖数: 1215 | 17 遇到这样的审稿意见，简直无语。编辑直接给据了。哎，感觉rebutal的机会很渺茫阿
。求建议！怎么和编辑argue。
Reviewer: 1
Recommendation: Publish in a different journal.
Comments:
This manuscript by Cheng et al describes the nonequlibrium molecular
dynamics for thermal conductivity XXX. The work is carried out carefully and
includes an interesting result related with a thermal conductivity of two
nanomaterials. Although the authors explained the size dependence of
conductivity using non-equilibrium MD, theoretical and experimental studies
about ... 阅读全帖 |
|
a**********m
发帖数: 2098 | 18 yes, you can. you don't have to cite any legal precedent. that's the most ba
sic patent law principle--once the independent claim has novelty, all depend
ent claims depending on it have novelty as well
such |
|
|
p**********d
发帖数: 7918 | 20 分別是德國的奧西耶茲基（被禁止領獎），波蘭的瓦文薩（波蘭政府曾經禁止播放挪威
音樂），和美國的馬丁路德金（曾被美國右派斥責掀動種族衝突）。
尤其是美國的馬丁路德金，當初在美國是毀（右派）譽（其他人）參半，現在卻是公認
的英雄。我想劉曉波的足跡大概也會如此吧。
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-wasserstrom/liu-xiaobo-and-3-past-nob_b_795183.html
Jeffrey Wasserstrom
Jeffrey Wasserstrom
Professor of History, UC Irvine
Posted: December 10, 2010 04:12 PM
BIO Become a Fan
Get Email Alerts Bloggers' Index
Liu Xiaobo and 3 Noble Nobel Winners
digg
facebook Twitter stumble reddit del.ico.us
Read More: China , Germany , Liu Xiaob... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
t****l
发帖数: 454 | 22 just goole, at least three times:
http://womenincongress.house.gov/member-profiles/profile.html?intID=202
here is the link:
"When Rankin decided in 1916 to run for a House seat from Montana, she had
two key advantages: her reputation as a suffragist and her politically well-
connected brother, Wellington, who financed her campaign. Some national
woman suffrage leaders feared she would lose and hurt the cause. The novelty
of a woman running for Congress, however, helped Rankin secure a GOP
nomina... 阅读全帖 |
|
M**d
发帖数: 4418 | 23 http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20100124.htm
The Corporate Takeover of U.S. Democracy
Noam Chomsky
chomsky.info, January 24, 2010
(abridged version published in In These Times, February 2, 2010)
January 21, 2010 will go down as a dark day in the history of American
democracy, and its decline. The editors of the New York Times did not
exaggerate when they wrote that the Supreme Court decision that day "strikes
at the heart of democracy" by having "paved the way for corporations to use
their vast... 阅读全帖 |
|
s**********d
发帖数: 36899 | 24
partial list of US unions，给翻译一下绝大部分是多少
AFL-CIO
(The American Federation of Labor - Congress of Industrial
Organizations)
Air Line Pilots Association ALPA
Amalgamated Transit Union ATU
American Federation of Government Employees AFGE
American Federation of Musicians of the United States and Canada AFM
American Federation of School Administrators AFSA
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees AFSCME
American Federation of Teachers AFT
American Federation of Television and Radio... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
c**i
发帖数: 6973 | 26 Andrew E Kramer, Aloft, a Russian Image Problem. New York Times, Aug 30,
2011.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/30/business/global
/russia-hits-headwinds-in-selling-airliners-to-the-west.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=
superjet&st=cse
Note:
(a) Aeroflot
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeroflot
(Aeroflot, English translation: "air fleet"; the flag carrier and largest
airline of the Russian Federation; Founded 1923; Headquarters Moscow; The
airline is owned (as of March 2007) by the Russian Government)
(b) The a... 阅读全帖 |
|
x****u
发帖数: 12955 | 27
People simply got out of the phase of treating computer as a novelty. So
they no longer find machine's hardware specs interesting, but instead what
you do with the machine interesting. |
|
w*********g
发帖数: 30882 | 28 中国基本上已经做好了击溃美元的战略准备了
来源: nWAY 于 2011-12-31 16:27:40 [档案] [博客] 旧帖] [转至博客] [给我悄悄话
] 本文已被阅读：221次 字体：调大/调小/重置 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加
跟贴 | 查看当前最热讨论主题 http://alt-market.com/articles/462-new-asian-union-means-the-fall-of-the-dollar
New Asian Union Means The Fall Of The Dollar
Brandon Smith, Alt-Market.com, 31 December 2011
One of the most frustrating issues to haunt the halls of alternative
economic analysis is the threat of misrepresentative terminology. For
instance, when the U.S. government decided ... 阅读全帖 |
|
n*********l
发帖数: 365 | 29 青黴素殺菌根本就是生物
利用生物的某些特性，才有殺菌功效的
發現這一物質的存在，才是novelty
提純啥的，只是technique
——答案都有了，guaranteed to succeed，出結果快慢而已 |
|
n*********l
发帖数: 365 | 30 核心是命題（或設計主題）的novelty
和實現的細節。
中國早年實行資訊封鎖，電視、報紙、網絡等
讓國民盡量少接觸海外的事物，加上宣傳和教育的單一性，
人們的思維不夠開闊，沒有創意是很自然的——
世界上沒有一個共產主義國家是有創意的
不過近年已改善很多。 |
|
u*********r
发帖数: 7835 | 31 The following statistics, from both secular and religious sources reveal
that p*orn is now as American as Apple Pie, and has found a place in every
corner of our society, including the church. The statistics on prn use among
Christians are near the end.
At 13.3 billion, the 2006 revenues of the sex and p*orn industry in the U.S.
are bigger than the NFL, NBA and Major League baseball combined. Worldwide
sex industry sales for 2006 are reported to be 97 billion. To put this in
perspective, Microso... 阅读全帖 |
|
s*****r
发帖数: 11545 | 32 This guy used "then" twice.
To some extent I agree with him. Education is not wisdom.
However, wisdom is not innovation either. What is more, education and wisdom
are not mutually excluded. Can you imagine a person with a lot of wisdom
can't even get the simplest calculation straight? On the other hand,
without enough education, how innovative can a person be? How can you create
a useful device without the basic math and physics or chemistry skill? You
might have wisdom for a big idea, but how... 阅读全帖 |
|
F*********u
发帖数: 12190 | 33 设计者的解释
The symbol was originally designed in 1912 by Baron Pierre de Coubertin, co-
founder of the modern Olympic Games. According to Coubertin, the ring
colours with the white background stand for those colors that appeared on
all the national flags that competed in the Olympic games at that time. Upon
its initial introduction, Coubertin stated the following in the August,
1912 edition of Olympique:
"...the six colors [including the flag’s white background] thus combined
reproduce the colors of... 阅读全帖 |
|
w*q
发帖数: 1544 | 34 from Purdue's math department homepage :
http://intranet.math.purdue.edu/news/2014/08/21/purdue-alumnus-
Zhang’s result stunned many in the mathematical community for the novelty
of its proof and for its source. After leaving Purdue, Zhang faced a
difficult set of circumstances that led him out of academia for a period of
nearly 10 years, during which time he worked a variety of jobs, including in
a Subway sandwich shop. In 1999 he was hired as a lecturer at the
University of New Hampshire. H... 阅读全帖 |
|
f**e
发帖数: 3343 | 35 关键就是你想说又没说的“持续打破”，这才是这篇文章的novelty吧
肯定不会是楼上那些人说的那么简单 |
|
l**********n
发帖数: 1742 | 36 傻逼，那用胶带纸撕石墨的叫什么？
你看你那贱逼德性
[发表自未名空间手机版 - m.mitbbs.com] |
|
S*******l
发帖数: 4637 | 37 我可没说是因为诗经啥的。表往我嘴里塞话。
别有用心的人很多的，我会洗不清的，哈哈。 |
|
|
|
|
t******g
发帖数: 183 | 41 要看时代背景
[在 samurairen (samurairen) 的大作中提到：]
：智商可悲
：青霉素的发现跟这差不多
：........... |
|
|
s******s
发帖数: 1793 | 43 NM!你能从你家后圆的植物里能提炼出治癌良方你就是大NB,谁在乎你有没有新意,实用
救人就是NB,狗P利润玄学是SB. |
|
|
t******g
发帖数: 183 | 45 你太把自己当回事了
[在 StMicheal (archangel) 的大作中提到：]
：我可没说是因为诗经啥的。表往我嘴里塞话。
：
：........... |
|
t******g
发帖数: 183 | 46 这不是已经肯定了其impact了吗
只是客观分析其science贡献不高而已
[在 stevejbs (牛熊互搏) 的大作中提到：]
：NM!你能从你家后圆的植物里能提炼出治癌良方你就是大NB,谁在乎你有没有新意,实用
：救人就是NB,狗P利润玄学是SB.
：........... |
|
H*********S
发帖数: 22772 | 47 生物类算软科学，就是靠无数人肉电池没日没夜熬数据 |
|
t******g
发帖数: 183 | 48 理论水平，tom zhang比youyou to高出几十条街
youyoutu的成功，说白了， 是在特殊历史条件下的产物
试问今天，你萃取某几个天然成分，就可以随便拿来试验在人身上吗？
就算你有一个天然成分candidate，也得经过漫长、严格的过程，才能进入临床试验
而在文革阶段，病急乱投医，有药吃比没有好，试死多少人，你知道吗？
tom zhang的理论水平，肯定高出yy2几十条街了，毫无置疑的
当然，impact嘛，yy2也高出tom几十条街 |
|
|
q*******n
发帖数: 20306 | 50 餐具是近代少数白人贵族装逼用的。
大便之后直接用脏手抓着吃不仅是人性，也是神性。 耶稣，真主，如来佛祖都异口同
声地诅咒使用餐具吃饭这种异端行为。 基督教徒都不敢用餐具吃饭，否则别想死后进
天堂。
Many British clergymen were vehemently opposed to forks; they believed that
only human fingers were worthy of touching God’s food. Often, when someone
died after having used a fork, these clergymen preached that it was God’s
way of showing His displeasure over the use of such a shocking novelty.
n 1630, Governor Winthrop of the Massachusetts Bay Colony had the first and
only fork in colonial Americ... 阅读全帖 |
|
