l**t
发帖数: 10440 | 1 --Thank Kai Zhu and his legal team for this great job, SVCA
--Thank Sam Li for his quick job on video compiling, SVCA
QUOTA - UC Admissions Director Michael Trevino revealed the REAL motives
behind SCA 5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPT3NmGrTdk
I obtained the video of the 7/3/2013 Senate Education Committee's hearing on
SCA 5, at which Senator Hernandez testified.
Senator Hernandez invited Michael Trevino, the Director of Undergraduate
Admissions at UC http://www.linkedin.com/pub/michael-trevino/8/4b1/226, to testify - purportedly to support Hernandez's own testimony. What Mr. Trevino actually revealed, however, was very disturbing.
Senator Hernandez stated that SCA 5 was not about a quota system, which
would be unconstitutional under Gratz v. Bollinger, 539 U.S. 244 (2003), but
Mr. Trevino's testimony clearly showed that the UC had already tried to
implement a quota-like system, but could not do so exactly because of Prop.
209, and the real goal of SCA 5 is to make such implementation easier.
With the help of some great people, I added annotations to the YouTube clip.
Hernandez's key testimony is at 1:40 - 4:55, while Trevino's is at 20:38 -
23:37.
Please help make this viral at YouTube and Facebook. Thank you. | r******8
发帖数: 926 | | Y***o
发帖数: 4135 | 3 ding..
on
but
【在 l**t 的大作中提到】
: --Thank Kai Zhu and his legal team for this great job, SVCA
: --Thank Sam Li for his quick job on video compiling, SVCA
: QUOTA - UC Admissions Director Michael Trevino revealed the REAL motives
: behind SCA 5
: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPT3NmGrTdk
: I obtained the video of the 7/3/2013 Senate Education Committee's hearing on
: SCA 5, at which Senator Hernandez testified.
: Senator Hernandez invited Michael Trevino, the Director of Undergraduate
: Admissions at UC http://www.linkedin.com/pub/michael-trevino/8/4b1/226, to testify - purportedly to support Hernandez's own testimony. What Mr. Trevino actually revealed, however, was very disturbing.
: Senator Hernandez stated that SCA 5 was not about a quota system, which
| d*******d
发帖数: 3382 | 4 ding!
on
but
【在 l**t 的大作中提到】
: --Thank Kai Zhu and his legal team for this great job, SVCA
: --Thank Sam Li for his quick job on video compiling, SVCA
: QUOTA - UC Admissions Director Michael Trevino revealed the REAL motives
: behind SCA 5
: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPT3NmGrTdk
: I obtained the video of the 7/3/2013 Senate Education Committee's hearing on
: SCA 5, at which Senator Hernandez testified.
: Senator Hernandez invited Michael Trevino, the Director of Undergraduate
: Admissions at UC http://www.linkedin.com/pub/michael-trevino/8/4b1/226, to testify - purportedly to support Hernandez's own testimony. What Mr. Trevino actually revealed, however, was very disturbing.
: Senator Hernandez stated that SCA 5 was not about a quota system, which
| c**a
发帖数: 434 | 5 赞
on
but
【在 l**t 的大作中提到】
: --Thank Kai Zhu and his legal team for this great job, SVCA
: --Thank Sam Li for his quick job on video compiling, SVCA
: QUOTA - UC Admissions Director Michael Trevino revealed the REAL motives
: behind SCA 5
: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPT3NmGrTdk
: I obtained the video of the 7/3/2013 Senate Education Committee's hearing on
: SCA 5, at which Senator Hernandez testified.
: Senator Hernandez invited Michael Trevino, the Director of Undergraduate
: Admissions at UC http://www.linkedin.com/pub/michael-trevino/8/4b1/226, to testify - purportedly to support Hernandez's own testimony. What Mr. Trevino actually revealed, however, was very disturbing.
: Senator Hernandez stated that SCA 5 was not about a quota system, which
| c****i
发帖数: 625 | 6 太可怕了。
on
but
【在 l**t 的大作中提到】
: --Thank Kai Zhu and his legal team for this great job, SVCA
: --Thank Sam Li for his quick job on video compiling, SVCA
: QUOTA - UC Admissions Director Michael Trevino revealed the REAL motives
: behind SCA 5
: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPT3NmGrTdk
: I obtained the video of the 7/3/2013 Senate Education Committee's hearing on
: SCA 5, at which Senator Hernandez testified.
: Senator Hernandez invited Michael Trevino, the Director of Undergraduate
: Admissions at UC http://www.linkedin.com/pub/michael-trevino/8/4b1/226, to testify - purportedly to support Hernandez's own testimony. What Mr. Trevino actually revealed, however, was very disturbing.
: Senator Hernandez stated that SCA 5 was not about a quota system, which
| s***i
发帖数: 181 | | d****z
发帖数: 1232 | 8 能不能编辑一下简短一些？或者把关键的部分注释出来，放在前面。
on
【在 l**t 的大作中提到】
: --Thank Kai Zhu and his legal team for this great job, SVCA
: --Thank Sam Li for his quick job on video compiling, SVCA
: QUOTA - UC Admissions Director Michael Trevino revealed the REAL motives
: behind SCA 5
: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPT3NmGrTdk
: I obtained the video of the 7/3/2013 Senate Education Committee's hearing on
: SCA 5, at which Senator Hernandez testified.
: Senator Hernandez invited Michael Trevino, the Director of Undergraduate
: Admissions at UC http://www.linkedin.com/pub/michael-trevino/8/4b1/226, to testify - purportedly to support Hernandez's own testimony. What Mr. Trevino actually revealed, however, was very disturbing.
: Senator Hernandez stated that SCA 5 was not about a quota system, which
| t*c
发帖数: 8291 | 9 UC director says: UC has been trying to close the gap. (gap between 人口比
例和录取比例).
关上这个gap, 意思就是人口百分比多少，就录取多少，这就是quota的实际解释。
这个director的意思，就是UC一直在努力close the gap, 但是一直没能实现
（我说：某些族分数是在是太低了！），
如果sca5通过，那么UC就可以堂而皇之得扩大招生分数的差别，据收高分亚裔，
而录取低分某些裔，使得录取比例符合人口比例。
【在 d****z 的大作中提到】
: 能不能编辑一下简短一些？或者把关键的部分注释出来，放在前面。
:
: on
| c****i
发帖数: 625 | 10 Mr. Trevinosaid they have not being able to use race, gender as admission
criteria as the private colleges do.
【在 t*c 的大作中提到】
: UC director says: UC has been trying to close the gap. (gap between 人口比
: 例和录取比例).
: 关上这个gap, 意思就是人口百分比多少，就录取多少，这就是quota的实际解释。
: 这个director的意思，就是UC一直在努力close the gap, 但是一直没能实现
: （我说：某些族分数是在是太低了！），
: 如果sca5通过，那么UC就可以堂而皇之得扩大招生分数的差别，据收高分亚裔，
: 而录取低分某些裔，使得录取比例符合人口比例。
| | | c****i
发帖数: 625 | 11 Isn't that sheer racism? Please spread this video and let more people know
about it.
【在 c****i 的大作中提到】
: Mr. Trevinosaid they have not being able to use race, gender as admission
: criteria as the private colleges do.
| t*c
发帖数: 8291 | 12 他的真实意思是not as much as the private colleges.
我知道UC的录取是看race的。只是不能把race放到有证据可寻的文字里。
但是在real practice里，是看race的。否则无论如何也解释不通
SAT1500的韩裔单亲癌症妈妈的儿子被UCLA拒绝，而同样情况的latino SAT低了500分却
被UCLA录取了。
【在 c****i 的大作中提到】
: Mr. Trevinosaid they have not being able to use race, gender as admission
: criteria as the private colleges do.
| u*****a
发帖数: 6276 | 13 曲解原意。
如果“close the gap” = “using quota”，这个美国世界用quota 的地方也太多了
一点。
【在 t*c 的大作中提到】
: UC director says: UC has been trying to close the gap. (gap between 人口比
: 例和录取比例).
: 关上这个gap, 意思就是人口百分比多少，就录取多少，这就是quota的实际解释。
: 这个director的意思，就是UC一直在努力close the gap, 但是一直没能实现
: （我说：某些族分数是在是太低了！），
: 如果sca5通过，那么UC就可以堂而皇之得扩大招生分数的差别，据收高分亚裔，
: 而录取低分某些裔，使得录取比例符合人口比例。
| k*9
发帖数: 471 | 14 一般情况两者不是一回事，可在这个语境下，你怎么解读？难道是achievement gap?
搞笑
【在 u*****a 的大作中提到】
: 曲解原意。
: 如果“close the gap” = “using quota”，这个美国世界用quota 的地方也太多了
: 一点。
| t*c
发帖数: 8291 | 15 他是极左liberal, 不用跟他争论浪费时间了。
【在 k*9 的大作中提到】
: 一般情况两者不是一回事，可在这个语境下，你怎么解读？难道是achievement gap?
: 搞笑
| T******g
发帖数: 21328 | 16 现在UC是偷偷摸摸的搞，SCA5过了就是名正言顺的搞了
现在给低收入的扶持很好了，再给肤色特招，那就是脑残了 | g**********g
发帖数: 18118 | |
|
