c*********8 发帖数: 64 | 1 有人知道这个0443吗?
RFE主要说领域内其他人引用thousands..
分享下背景和RFE内容,给大家参考。大家也帮忙提提意见。
机械工程
论文20+,大部分一作;
引用260;
审稿90+;
IO RFE中说:
“The petitioner has provided sufficient documentation, to meet the plain
language of the regulation under the following regulatory areas:
1. Evidence of the alien's participation, either individually or on a
panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field of
specialization for which classification is sought.
2. Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the
field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media.
You submitted letters of opinion and a record of your citation history, yet
the evidence, while demonstrating original contributions, does not
substantiate original contributions of "major significance" in a field whose
leading scientists (according to Google Scholar) have garnered citations
numbered well in the thousands.”
是不是就是说论文和审稿满足条件了,就是引用不够。这种RFE该怎么回复呢?
多谢大家!祝大家顺利! |
a*****u 发帖数: 72 | 2 请问你的rfe里面有具体提到领域里的谁是上千引用么还是范范说“in a field whose
leading scientists having garnered citations numbered well inthe thousands”
我的rfe就是这个内容
我个人感觉从语气上看倒是没说必须要上千才能过,他还是说需要其他证据
【在 c*********8 的大作中提到】 : 有人知道这个0443吗? : RFE主要说领域内其他人引用thousands.. : 分享下背景和RFE内容,给大家参考。大家也帮忙提提意见。 : 机械工程 : 论文20+,大部分一作; : 引用260; : 审稿90+; : IO RFE中说: : “The petitioner has provided sufficient documentation, to meet the plain : language of the regulation under the following regulatory areas:
|
c*********8 发帖数: 64 | 3 aihaiyu,跟你的一摸一样啊!!
我的加了个“google scholar”:
“in a field whose leading scientists (according to Google Scholar) having
garnered citations numbered well in the thousands”
我估计IO可能google了下关键字,跳出来几个人成千上万引用的。
whose
thousands”
【在 a*****u 的大作中提到】 : 请问你的rfe里面有具体提到领域里的谁是上千引用么还是范范说“in a field whose : leading scientists having garnered citations numbered well inthe thousands” : 我的rfe就是这个内容 : 我个人感觉从语气上看倒是没说必须要上千才能过,他还是说需要其他证据
|
c*********8 发帖数: 64 | 4 有没有了解 IO 0443 的进来说说啊。。
到底是撤了再提交,还是好好回答一些RFE呢。。
就怕这个IO也是油盐不进,一定要1000引用。。 |
d*******u 发帖数: 5337 | |
C*******4 发帖数: 58 | |
g*****i 发帖数: 46 | 7 请问下这个tracker是 EB1a 的还是EB1b的?或者两者一块的。
【在 C*******4 的大作中提到】 : http://www.mycasetracker.org/index.php?dest=home : 你看看这个,最近都是RFE,估计都是PP的,小心啊
|
c*********8 发帖数: 64 | 8 有人知道这个0443吗?
RFE主要说领域内其他人引用thousands..
分享下背景和RFE内容,给大家参考。大家也帮忙提提意见。
机械工程
论文20+,大部分一作;
引用260;
审稿90+;
IO RFE中说:
“The petitioner has provided sufficient documentation, to meet the plain
language of the regulation under the following regulatory areas:
1. Evidence of the alien's participation, either individually or on a
panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field of
specialization for which classification is sought.
2. Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the
field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media.
You submitted letters of opinion and a record of your citation history, yet
the evidence, while demonstrating original contributions, does not
substantiate original contributions of "major significance" in a field whose
leading scientists (according to Google Scholar) have garnered citations
numbered well in the thousands.”
是不是就是说论文和审稿满足条件了,就是引用不够。这种RFE该怎么回复呢?
多谢大家!祝大家顺利! |
a*****u 发帖数: 72 | 9 请问你的rfe里面有具体提到领域里的谁是上千引用么还是范范说“in a field whose
leading scientists having garnered citations numbered well inthe thousands”
我的rfe就是这个内容
我个人感觉从语气上看倒是没说必须要上千才能过,他还是说需要其他证据
【在 c*********8 的大作中提到】 : 有人知道这个0443吗? : RFE主要说领域内其他人引用thousands.. : 分享下背景和RFE内容,给大家参考。大家也帮忙提提意见。 : 机械工程 : 论文20+,大部分一作; : 引用260; : 审稿90+; : IO RFE中说: : “The petitioner has provided sufficient documentation, to meet the plain : language of the regulation under the following regulatory areas:
|
c*********8 发帖数: 64 | 10 aihaiyu,跟你的一摸一样啊!!
我的加了个“google scholar”:
“in a field whose leading scientists (according to Google Scholar) having
garnered citations numbered well in the thousands”
我估计IO可能google了下关键字,跳出来几个人成千上万引用的。
whose
thousands”
【在 a*****u 的大作中提到】 : 请问你的rfe里面有具体提到领域里的谁是上千引用么还是范范说“in a field whose : leading scientists having garnered citations numbered well inthe thousands” : 我的rfe就是这个内容 : 我个人感觉从语气上看倒是没说必须要上千才能过,他还是说需要其他证据
|
|
|
c*********8 发帖数: 64 | 11 有没有了解 IO 0443 的进来说说啊。。
到底是撤了再提交,还是好好回答一些RFE呢。。
就怕这个IO也是油盐不进,一定要1000引用。。 |
d*******u 发帖数: 5337 | |
C*******4 发帖数: 58 | |
g*****i 发帖数: 46 | 14 请问下这个tracker是 EB1a 的还是EB1b的?或者两者一块的。
【在 C*******4 的大作中提到】 : http://www.mycasetracker.org/index.php?dest=home : 你看看这个,最近都是RFE,估计都是PP的,小心啊
|
w******n 发帖数: 18 | 15 请问您的case RFE 回复结果怎么样了? 我也被0443 RFE 谢谢 |