F******1
发帖数: 228 | 1 I heard from someone before but did not believe that then.
But it seems true.
I asked APS/ACS for RL when preparing for 140 and did not get any response.
Then I moved on and got 2 RL from Europe journals.
It has been 3 months and I did not receive any more APS/ACS review requests
since then. Normally, it should have been 5-6 requests in the time span. |
G**********n
发帖数: 754 | 2 Yes, it's true! Same experience. |
s*********u
发帖数: 2535 | 3 这个没有碰到过，倒是有一个杂志，本来审过三四次了，结果有一次一篇稿子被我据了
，结果再也不发稿给我审了。 |
S*M
发帖数: 104 | 4 我申请140的时候，没有问editor要推荐信。觉得不是必须的。 |
F******1
发帖数: 228 | 5 European journals are nicer. Got their response emails within a day and
received hard copy from oversea later too.
ACS/APS, although I reviewed over 15 papers for them, they just ignored my
email requests and did not respond at all...
The most miserable thing is that I still had 2 papers published on/submitted
to
them since then....poor me:) |
C********7
发帖数: 1035 | 6 外来的和尚好念经。欧洲journal的当然希望丰富自己reviewer pool的variety。 |
t*****m
发帖数: 73 | 7 个别情况还是好几个ACS journal都这样？
requests
【在 F******1 的大作中提到】
: I heard from someone before but did not believe that then.
: But it seems true.
: I asked APS/ACS for RL when preparing for 140 and did not get any response.
: Then I moved on and got 2 RL from Europe journals.
: It has been 3 months and I did not receive any more APS/ACS review requests
: since then. Normally, it should have been 5-6 requests in the time span.
|
F******1
发帖数: 228 | 8 it must be true, at least for ACS and APS.
I did not receive any more review requests from them since Sep 2012, though
I did not want any more either, aha... |
F**********0
发帖数: 442 | 9 I can't believe this. There must be something wrong with the communication.
APS is very very responsible and quick. They have people working on this. I
don't know about ACS. |
