l****7
发帖数: 975 | 1 This letter is to confirm that Dr. XXX offered his valuable services as a
reviewer for the scientific peer-review journal “XXX” on two manuscripts
with reference numbers XXX, 04-Aug-2009 and XXX, 01-Apr-2010. The
manuscript details are kept confidential in order to protect the
reviewer’s identity. The editorial board is deeply appreciative of the
voluntary yet professional work of our reviewers, who keep the review
process at a high level of fair judgment and scientific quality.
这样的信可以么？ |
p***z
发帖数: 94 | 2 sounds fine.Not strong, but sufficient. |
l****7
发帖数: 975 | 3 IO ask for reviewer selection criteria, but this letter doesn't read like
a criteria but just a proof?
【在 p***z 的大作中提到】
: sounds fine.Not strong, but sufficient.
|
l*****y
发帖数: 186 | 4 I got something like this, and my lawyer choose not to used it. |
l*****7
发帖数: 2844 | 5 没啥用对eb1a
理论上应该是吹他们选reviewer很严，国际top的专家才会备选，因为你很牛，所以被
选了 |
n*****t
发帖数: 279 | 6 I think it looks fine, although I am not expert on this.
My lawyer's letter template is very "humber". He neve used strong words,
such as "strongly support" and etc. He said the Service officers are tired
of the big words. Not sue. Now all my reference letter are in the tone of
objectively assess (of course positivley) my work. |
r****6
发帖数: 57 | 7 My editor gave me letters like this. I am not sure, either. :-( |
T*****E
发帖数: 1785 | 8 no use at all.
ask the editor write as follows:
xxx journal is an international peer-viewed journal, we select the reviewers
across the world, only those who has outstanding contribution to xxx and
international reputation are qualified, bababa |
l*****7
发帖数: 2844 | 9 推荐信和这个是两回事， 推荐信现在几乎没啥用了，所以你说得再牛x，也没啥用，所
以你律师是对的，很多人把几年前niw的信复印一遍又交了，也没事
但是这个editor的信是用来证明judge，review这一条的。cis明确说了，需要selction
criteria，也就是你很牛x，所以你能被选为reviewer
还要frequently，大量的review
这样才能把这条弄的比较solid
【在 n*****t 的大作中提到】
: I think it looks fine, although I am not expert on this.
: My lawyer's letter template is very "humber". He neve used strong words,
: such as "strongly support" and etc. He said the Service officers are tired
: of the big words. Not sue. Now all my reference letter are in the tone of
: objectively assess (of course positivley) my work.
|
l****7
发帖数: 975 | 10 我又给这个编辑写了封信，问他能不能加些selection criteria的话，而且跟他说他把
我的性别搞错了。结果他回信给我说，很抱歉没有看到我给他写的draft，然后用了我
的draft -- 真是万幸啊！！ |
l*****y
发帖数: 186 | |
