b*******1
发帖数: 94 | 1 国内做设计的用到pcacolumn吗，或者有什么类似的软件吗？
还有国内设计要用到moment curvature analysis 吗，一般用什么软件做。
谢谢 |
j***h
发帖数: 4412 | 2
Did you never use PKPM in your undergraduate course works? In addition, the
Chinese code for concrete structure design is not ACI 318, it is 《混凝土结
构设计规范》GB50010-2002.
Usually they don't care what envision moment curvature analysis can provide
for them. All they care is the section capacity. Some old guys who got
their BS in 1950s or 1960s, e.g., a senior member of China Engineering
Academy,believe in the funny results of FEM analysis, not the innovation or
conceptual design of structural engineers.
The knowledge construction industry was based on the experience passed by
the former soviet union experts in 1950s. The seismic resisting design
philosophy was based on a few visiting scholars' one-year study/research in UC Berkley in 1980s.
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 国内做设计的用到pcacolumn吗，或者有什么类似的软件吗？
: 还有国内设计要用到moment curvature analysis 吗，一般用什么软件做。
: 谢谢
|
Z****g
发帖数: 13731 | 3 嗯，俺本科时就用的它， pmpk 占了大部分市场？
the
provide
or
【在 j***h 的大作中提到】
:
: Did you never use PKPM in your undergraduate course works? In addition, the
: Chinese code for concrete structure design is not ACI 318, it is 《混凝土结
: 构设计规范》GB50010-2002.
: Usually they don't care what envision moment curvature analysis can provide
: for them. All they care is the section capacity. Some old guys who got
: their BS in 1950s or 1960s, e.g., a senior member of China Engineering
: Academy,believe in the funny results of FEM analysis, not the innovation or
: conceptual design of structural engineers.
: The knowledge construction industry was based on the experience passed by
|
j***h
发帖数: 4412 | 4 Yes. In early 1990s, there was a structural software called TBSA (Tall
Building Structural Analysis) dominated the market. After 2000, the market
was taken over by PKPM. Those key staffs work for PKPM became millionaires
in early 1990s, long before they became No.1 in the market. However, their
software is still as simple as it was in the 1990s.
【在 Z****g 的大作中提到】
: 嗯，俺本科时就用的它， pmpk 占了大部分市场？
:
: the
: provide
: or
|
Z****g
发帖数: 13731 | 5 I used TBSA too. Is PKPM mainly used for analyze moment frame?
market
millionaires
their
【在 j***h 的大作中提到】
: Yes. In early 1990s, there was a structural software called TBSA (Tall
: Building Structural Analysis) dominated the market. After 2000, the market
: was taken over by PKPM. Those key staffs work for PKPM became millionaires
: in early 1990s, long before they became No.1 in the market. However, their
: software is still as simple as it was in the 1990s.
|
j***h
发帖数: 4412 | 6 PK is used for RC MRF analysis and design only. They have another product
called SATWE for RC shear wall or dual system analysis and design. Here is
an advertisement the guy published on an ASCE proceeding:
Proceedings / TALL BUILDING ANALYSIS AND DESIGN
A CAD Program for Tall Buildings—SATWE
ASCE Conf. Proc. doi:10.1061/40513(279)33
Computing in Civil and Building Engineering (2000)
Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Computing in Civil and
Building Engineering
Yungui Li
Professor, China Academy of Building Research, P.O. Box 752, Beijing, 100013
, P R China
Abstract
SATWE is specially developed for analysis and design of tall buildings. By
introducing two kinds of sup‐elements—generalized‐wall‐element and
elastic‐floor‐slab‐element, the problem of rational modeling of shear
walls and floor slabs in tall buildings is solved better with high precision
, efficiency, and practicability. The two super‐elements and some special
features of SATWE are introduced in this paper.
【在 Z****g 的大作中提到】
: I used TBSA too. Is PKPM mainly used for analyze moment frame?
:
: market
: millionaires
: their
|
y******r
发帖数: 2986 | 7 很郁闷
在国内都读了硕士，也只是知道PKPM，并没有使用过
【在 Z****g 的大作中提到】
: I used TBSA too. Is PKPM mainly used for analyze moment frame?
:
: market
: millionaires
: their
|
z******i
发帖数: 5114 | 8 97年暑假实习就已经用，pkpm了 那时候就已经普及了
现在想来国内设计有点让我担心啊 |
y******r
发帖数: 2986 | 9 都是大牛，我现在还不知道怎么用PKPM
【在 z******i 的大作中提到】
: 97年暑假实习就已经用，pkpm了 那时候就已经普及了
: 现在想来国内设计有点让我担心啊
|
s******e
发帖数: 30 | 10 这个pkpm只是做building的，其他路桥啊什么的都有专用软件，很多还是各大设计院自
己研发的in house软件。不过在难也难不过在米国混土木的学位难吧。 |
r*****j
发帖数: 7481 | 11 晕，我只会sap2000。。美国读得本科和master，完全不了解中国的code。只知道
aci318，asce7,aisc provision,fema 250,256.是不是回国工作就没戏了？ |
Z****g
发帖数: 13731 | 12 一个软件有什么值得大惊小怪的。
摸个一个星期就熟了。
你真想回去，熟悉国内的规范倒是真的
【在 r*****j 的大作中提到】
: 晕，我只会sap2000。。美国读得本科和master，完全不了解中国的code。只知道
: aci318，asce7,aisc provision,fema 250,256.是不是回国工作就没戏了？
|
