g***l
发帖数: 352 | 1 If a professor is a conference chair or co-chair, his/her students can not
subimit paper to the conference? |
y***u
发帖数: 101 | 2 如果不加chair的名字就应该可以
【在 g***l 的大作中提到】
: If a professor is a conference chair or co-chair, his/her students can not
: subimit paper to the conference?
|
x*b
发帖数: 253 | 3 Depends on the conference.
【在 g***l 的大作中提到】
: If a professor is a conference chair or co-chair, his/her students can not
: subimit paper to the conference?
|
R****r
发帖数: 227 | 4 it will look very wierd...
【在 g***l 的大作中提到】
: If a professor is a conference chair or co-chair, his/her students can not
: subimit paper to the conference?
|
w***f
发帖数: 75 | 5 I know the students CAN in many top conferences. Although
the chair/co-chair can not act as paper reviewers or associate chair for
a paper any longer.
【在 g***l 的大作中提到】
: If a professor is a conference chair or co-chair, his/her students can not
: subimit paper to the conference?
|
w***f
发帖数: 75 | 6 no, it might be a rule of your advisor only.
please look at the conference proceedings, many co-chairs also
coauthor papers. |
r*****y
发帖数: 507 | 7 probably.
Recently I am working on a paper with a outside researcher. We had planed to
submit it to a conference, but since later he found one of the two paper
co-chairs is his good friend, he disagree to submit it there. I am considering
to submit it to a journal directly.
a
not
【在 w***f 的大作中提到】
: no, it might be a rule of your advisor only.
: please look at the conference proceedings, many co-chairs also
: coauthor papers.
|
w***f
发帖数: 75 | 8 I just lookedat one conference proceeding at hand here is
one example -
Victoria Bellotti - Paper co-chair of ACM CHI 2003
W. Keith Edwards, Victoria Bellotti, et al, Stuck in the Middle:
The Challenges of User-Centered Design and Evaluation for
Middleware, in Proc of ACM CHI 2003
【在 r*****y 的大作中提到】
: probably.
: Recently I am working on a paper with a outside researcher. We had planed to
: submit it to a conference, but since later he found one of the two paper
: co-chairs is his good friend, he disagree to submit it there. I am considering
: to submit it to a journal directly.
:
: a
: not
|
w*******g
发帖数: 9932 | 9 it is politically incorrect to submit a paper when there is a conflict of
interests.
So better make sure that the submitted paper is damn good one.
【在 w***f 的大作中提到】
: I just lookedat one conference proceeding at hand here is
: one example -
: Victoria Bellotti - Paper co-chair of ACM CHI 2003
: W. Keith Edwards, Victoria Bellotti, et al, Stuck in the Middle:
: The Challenges of User-Centered Design and Evaluation for
: Middleware, in Proc of ACM CHI 2003
|
w***f
发帖数: 75 | 10 ??
I believe it's not proper, but a lot of co-chairs did that, I couldn't
find a written rule that prohibits that.
One more example,
Dan Olsen - Paper co-chair of ACM CHI 2004
Dan Olsen and Stephen Wood, Fan-out: Measuring Human Control of Multiple
Robots , in proc of ACM CHI 2004.
I only looked at two proceedings at hand, the success rate is
100% till now.
【在 w*******g 的大作中提到】
: it is politically incorrect to submit a paper when there is a conflict of
: interests.
: So better make sure that the submitted paper is damn good one.
|
|
|
w*******g
发帖数: 9932 | 11 didn't say you couldn't. just not very easy to get in this way.
【在 w***f 的大作中提到】
: ??
: I believe it's not proper, but a lot of co-chairs did that, I couldn't
: find a written rule that prohibits that.
: One more example,
: Dan Olsen - Paper co-chair of ACM CHI 2004
: Dan Olsen and Stephen Wood, Fan-out: Measuring Human Control of Multiple
: Robots , in proc of ACM CHI 2004.
: I only looked at two proceedings at hand, the success rate is
: 100% till now.
|
w***f
发帖数: 75 | 12 Can not understand your English :-(
【在 w*******g 的大作中提到】
: didn't say you couldn't. just not very easy to get in this way.
|
w*******g
发帖数: 9932 | 13 I didn't say you couldn't
(meaning: of course, you can submit a paper
when there is a coauthor in the program committee).
just not very easy to get in
(meaning: with a co-author in the committee,
your paper will be reviewed by possibly more reviewers than usual and under
greater scrutiny, so that it is harder to get accepted).
【在 w***f 的大作中提到】
: Can not understand your English :-(
|
r*****y
发帖数: 507 | 14 are you kidding?
More easy to get in!
some really respected researchers will void it by not submitting their papers
to the conferences where they or their good friends co-chaired. BECAUSE they
don't want to take adavantage of it, at least outside people may think it is
an advantage.
PC member is not a big deal. No need to pay special attention in this case.
【在 w*******g 的大作中提到】
: I didn't say you couldn't
: (meaning: of course, you can submit a paper
: when there is a coauthor in the program committee).
: just not very easy to get in
: (meaning: with a co-author in the committee,
: your paper will be reviewed by possibly more reviewers than usual and under
: greater scrutiny, so that it is harder to get accepted).
|
w*******g
发帖数: 9932 | 15 well. Maybe I am over-generializing.
I think that if it is easier to get in because of the position of a co-author,
then the conference's quality is dubious at best.
【在 r*****y 的大作中提到】
: are you kidding?
: More easy to get in!
: some really respected researchers will void it by not submitting their papers
: to the conferences where they or their good friends co-chaired. BECAUSE they
: don't want to take adavantage of it, at least outside people may think it is
: an advantage.
: PC member is not a big deal. No need to pay special attention in this case.
|
s*m
发帖数: 34 | 16 应该这样
【在 g***l 的大作中提到】
: If a professor is a conference chair or co-chair, his/her students can not
: subimit paper to the conference?
|
