l**t
发帖数: 6971 | 1 【 以下文字转载自 MedicalCareer 讨论区 】
发信人: pangns (pang), 信区: MedicalCareer
标 题: 捐款的目的和动机
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Fri Apr 30 14:36:51 2010, 美东)
如果捐钱的目的是扶弱救贫，救人于困顿之中，那么首先就要弄清楚谁现在正在困顿之
中。目前得到的消息是王的家人贫病交加，要面对这突如其来的打击和要面临昂贵的诉
讼。目前没有消息说被害人家属陷于经济上的困难，至少没有王家那么困难。不管两个
MD谁对谁错，两个家属都是无辜的，平等的。所以说哪怕你是彻底的国际主义者，捐钱
也应该捐给急需钱的人。如果你捐钱的目的是要彰显你博大的胸怀，彰显你已经早于大
多中国人脱离了狭隘的民族主义而得到普世价值的真传，那么你的目的就已经不再单纯
是扶弱救贫，说的好听点是有些矫情，说的难听点你是在消费这个对两家和对所有苦苦
挣扎的外来者来说都是莫大悲剧的事件。
我对这个事件的看法：
1 用暴力结束人的生命不为现代社会所容。
2 虽然都为杀人，但走投无路者的仇杀与滥杀无辜的疯子还是有些区别。
3 两家家人都是无辜受害 |
f**********l
发帖数: 1191 | |
M*******c
发帖数: 4371 | |
m*******i
发帖数: 8711 | |
y**i
发帖数: 1471 | 5
这个说法太不爱国爱同胞了。
【在 m*******i 的大作中提到】
: 有嘛道理。别人的钱，他/她愿给谁是自己的事。
|
M*******c
发帖数: 4371 | 6 别人的嘴巴，他、她愿怎么说是自己的事
【在 m*******i 的大作中提到】
: 有嘛道理。别人的钱，他/她愿给谁是自己的事。
|
w*t
发帖数: 591 | 7 I don't know if the families of the black youth who killed Mr Yu in Oakland
a few days ago are poor or not, I guess they most likely are.I didn't
remember seeing any one suggesting donation for them. Why I feel a lot of
people on the board sounds blatantly like racists? |
Z*****l
发帖数: 14069 | 8 那你去组织一下。
Oakland
【在 w*t 的大作中提到】
: I don't know if the families of the black youth who killed Mr Yu in Oakland
: a few days ago are poor or not, I guess they most likely are.I didn't
: remember seeing any one suggesting donation for them. Why I feel a lot of
: people on the board sounds blatantly like racists?
|
w*********r
发帖数: 2192 | 9 大家捐钱是因为同源同种，
FEEL RELATED TO 吧。
世界上本来就没有普世价值。
参见“SELFISH GENE”这本书。
Oakland
【在 w*t 的大作中提到】
: I don't know if the families of the black youth who killed Mr Yu in Oakland
: a few days ago are poor or not, I guess they most likely are.I didn't
: remember seeing any one suggesting donation for them. Why I feel a lot of
: people on the board sounds blatantly like racists?
|
M*******c
发帖数: 4371 | 10 The truth could be:
1, They are rich than Dr. Wang. They can get a lot of funding from the gov.
2, They don't have any kids to raise. If they do have at the age of 18. They
are much more irresponsible than Dr. Wang.
Oakland
【在 w*t 的大作中提到】
: I don't know if the families of the black youth who killed Mr Yu in Oakland
: a few days ago are poor or not, I guess they most likely are.I didn't
: remember seeing any one suggesting donation for them. Why I feel a lot of
: people on the board sounds blatantly like racists?
|
