q********n
发帖数: 3248 | 1 看之前总听人说怎么好怎么经典，其实就这么回事吧。 |
d*********n
发帖数: 818 | 2 I agree. It is more bitter, shallower, less hopeful.
【在 q********n 的大作中提到】
: 看之前总听人说怎么好怎么经典，其实就这么回事吧。
|
s3
发帖数: 2270 | 3 回顾中国几千年来的普通人生活，不就是如此么
活着不象笑深刻一样给人以个人可以改变社会的错觉
也没有象阿甘一样可以过得那么潇洒
不过说活着shallow得人未免有些太过肤浅了点
活着得主题就是表现普通人在社会变革中的随波逐流，正所谓兴百姓苦，亡百姓苦。这
种比较写实的东西才是真正让人震撼的。
我不否认阿甘是部好作品，但活着的地位也不差
【在 d*********n 的大作中提到】
: I agree. It is more bitter, shallower, less hopeful.
|
d*********n
发帖数: 818 | 4 We are talking about art of movie not the real history, aren't we?
It is not the subject but mainly how the director directs and actors acts makes a movie great.
I never deny the depth of Chinese history or tremendous suffering of Chinese people in the social turmoils (actually the common people are still suffering)
, but I am talking about the MOVIE! Movie, as any arts, need originity and creativity. This is like the history of Nanking Massacre. What a human tragedy! But we do not have a great movie about it, at least no one close to schindler's list.
【在 s3 的大作中提到】
: 回顾中国几千年来的普通人生活，不就是如此么
: 活着不象笑深刻一样给人以个人可以改变社会的错觉
: 也没有象阿甘一样可以过得那么潇洒
: 不过说活着shallow得人未免有些太过肤浅了点
: 活着得主题就是表现普通人在社会变革中的随波逐流，正所谓兴百姓苦，亡百姓苦。这
: 种比较写实的东西才是真正让人震撼的。
: 我不否认阿甘是部好作品，但活着的地位也不差
|
s3
发帖数: 2270 | 5 当然是谈电影啊
我认为活着很好的诠释了旧中国悲惨生活，所以才会产生共鸣的。这方面活着比前些时
候上映的南京大屠杀要好很多。
活着当然有originity和creativity，你是从哪里得出活着这方面差的结论了？如果你
指内容的话，我所知道的几乎看过活着小说的人都赞不绝口。电影改编了一些，但大的
框架还是一样的，这也是电影评价高的原因。
你说导演不好，活着演员演的不好，没有问题，不过要讲的再具体一点，否则不能让人
信服。当然就不要拿不拿奥斯卡来说事了。
makes a movie great.
Chinese people in the social turmoils (actually the common people are still
suffering)
creativity. This is like the history of Nanking Massacre. What a human
tragedy! But we do not have a great movie about it, at least no one close to
schindler's list.
【在 d*********n 的大作中提到】
: We are talking about art of movie not the real history, aren't we?
: It is not the subject but mainly how the director directs and actors acts makes a movie great.
: I never deny the depth of Chinese history or tremendous suffering of Chinese people in the social turmoils (actually the common people are still suffering)
: , but I am talking about the MOVIE! Movie, as any arts, need originity and creativity. This is like the history of Nanking Massacre. What a human tragedy! But we do not have a great movie about it, at least no one close to schindler's list.
|
d*********n
发帖数: 818 | 6 A true art touches your heart and soul sometimes in a hard-described way.A
great movie is whole package, like a great painting.If you know how to
appreciate a great paintings, a pieces of classic music, I am sure you can
tell which movie is artistically superior.
You do not have to agree with me. However, you have to agree that time and
only time is the ultimate judgment on the greatness of an art, including
movies.
Remember my word and check it again when you retire.
still
【在 s3 的大作中提到】
: 当然是谈电影啊
: 我认为活着很好的诠释了旧中国悲惨生活，所以才会产生共鸣的。这方面活着比前些时
: 候上映的南京大屠杀要好很多。
: 活着当然有originity和creativity，你是从哪里得出活着这方面差的结论了？如果你
: 指内容的话，我所知道的几乎看过活着小说的人都赞不绝口。电影改编了一些，但大的
: 框架还是一样的，这也是电影评价高的原因。
: 你说导演不好，活着演员演的不好，没有问题，不过要讲的再具体一点，否则不能让人
: 信服。当然就不要拿不拿奥斯卡来说事了。
:
: makes a movie great.
|
s*****j
发帖数: 6435 | 7 什么乱七八糟的?
【在 d*********n 的大作中提到】
: A true art touches your heart and soul sometimes in a hard-described way.A
: great movie is whole package, like a great painting.If you know how to
: appreciate a great paintings, a pieces of classic music, I am sure you can
: tell which movie is artistically superior.
: You do not have to agree with me. However, you have to agree that time and
: only time is the ultimate judgment on the greatness of an art, including
: movies.
: Remember my word and check it again when you retire.
:
: still
|
s******p
发帖数: 4962 | 8 扯了一堆废话
根本没讲出来道理
【在 d*********n 的大作中提到】
: A true art touches your heart and soul sometimes in a hard-described way.A
: great movie is whole package, like a great painting.If you know how to
: appreciate a great paintings, a pieces of classic music, I am sure you can
: tell which movie is artistically superior.
: You do not have to agree with me. However, you have to agree that time and
: only time is the ultimate judgment on the greatness of an art, including
: movies.
: Remember my word and check it again when you retire.
:
: still
|
s3
发帖数: 2270 | 9 哈哈
人家是说：等你老了就明白了
【在 s******p 的大作中提到】
: 扯了一堆废话
: 根本没讲出来道理
|
g*****i
发帖数: 1236 | 10 4楼说的太绝对了。
没有哪一部影视作品能够脱离她的时代背景独立存在的。 |
q********n
发帖数: 3248 | 11 旧中国人民生活没那么悲苦，新中国没几年就悲苦了。
still
【在 s3 的大作中提到】
: 当然是谈电影啊
: 我认为活着很好的诠释了旧中国悲惨生活，所以才会产生共鸣的。这方面活着比前些时
: 候上映的南京大屠杀要好很多。
: 活着当然有originity和creativity，你是从哪里得出活着这方面差的结论了？如果你
: 指内容的话，我所知道的几乎看过活着小说的人都赞不绝口。电影改编了一些，但大的
: 框架还是一样的，这也是电影评价高的原因。
: 你说导演不好，活着演员演的不好，没有问题，不过要讲的再具体一点，否则不能让人
: 信服。当然就不要拿不拿奥斯卡来说事了。
:
: makes a movie great.
|
n*****T
发帖数: 1109 | |
k**********i
发帖数: 8706 | |
