n****t
发帖数: 27 | 1 EB1A/pp delivered to NSC on June 26.
Receipt notice received on June 30.
Status changed to "request for evidence" this morning (July 2).
I have not received the official notice, so don't know what it's about.
Here is my background for your reference,
Postdoc in Physics,
1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
140 citations,
22 reviews for 8 journals,
No news report, no awards.
REF details:
Authorship and review work have met the criteria.
"Contribution of major significance" has not been met.
It seems like a standard RFE.
A small problem is that I had several citing papers in Chinese (printed out
from google scholar), they asked for the translation of those.
BTW, how do I know which IO worked on the case? There is something under the
signature of the direction saying "NSC/BWB EX0002", is that the IO number? | A******n
发帖数: 2976 | 2 bless!!
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: EB1A/pp delivered to NSC on June 26.
: Receipt notice received on June 30.
: Status changed to "request for evidence" this morning (July 2).
: I have not received the official notice, so don't know what it's about.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
| p*z
发帖数: 731 | | b*******H
发帖数: 830 | | f*********s
发帖数: 838 | | m******z
发帖数: 608 | | a***n
发帖数: 3951 | | K*N
发帖数: 7494 | | c*******t
发帖数: 5182 | 9 bless
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: EB1A/pp delivered to NSC on June 26.
: Receipt notice received on June 30.
: Status changed to "request for evidence" this morning (July 2).
: I have not received the official notice, so don't know what it's about.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
| u**********0
发帖数: 248 | 10 bless. I submited my I-140 to NSC too, waiting, | | | b*******H
发帖数: 830 | | F**********0
发帖数: 442 | | c*********o
发帖数: 1469 | 13 Bless! What is your background?
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: EB1A/pp delivered to NSC on June 26.
: Receipt notice received on June 30.
: Status changed to "request for evidence" this morning (July 2).
: I have not received the official notice, so don't know what it's about.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
| n****t
发帖数: 27 | 14 Thank you all.
Here is my background for your reference,
Postdoc in Physics,
1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
140 citations,
22 reviews for 8 journals,
No news report, no awards.
I will report more information once I receive the office notice.
Good luck to everyone.
【在 c*********o 的大作中提到】
: Bless! What is your background?
| b*******e
发帖数: 24532 | 15 please do, bless
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: Thank you all.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
: I will report more information once I receive the office notice.
: Good luck to everyone.
| S*******8
发帖数: 301 | 16 Bless
Background please.
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: EB1A/pp delivered to NSC on June 26.
: Receipt notice received on June 30.
: Status changed to "request for evidence" this morning (July 2).
: I have not received the official notice, so don't know what it's about.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
| y******5
发帖数: 858 | | r******e
发帖数: 418 | 18 Bless
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: EB1A/pp delivered to NSC on June 26.
: Receipt notice received on June 30.
: Status changed to "request for evidence" this morning (July 2).
: I have not received the official notice, so don't know what it's about.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
| A******n
发帖数: 2976 | 19 you should be able to get it approved after the RFE, good luck
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: Thank you all.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
: I will report more information once I receive the office notice.
: Good luck to everyone.
| j****t
发帖数: 1663 | 20 big bless!
Let's fight for RFE together! | | | s***7
发帖数: 506 | 21 bless!
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: Thank you all.
: Here is my background for your reference,
: Postdoc in Physics,
: 1 book chapter and 25 papers (no Nature or Science, best was PRL),
: 140 citations,
: 22 reviews for 8 journals,
: No news report, no awards.
: I will report more information once I receive the office notice.
: Good luck to everyone.
| g****d
发帖数: 420 | | n****t
发帖数: 27 | 23 Updated with the RFE details. | b*******e
发帖数: 24532 | 24 yes, 0002 is the IO. And RFE, though standard response, indicates you need
some work to improve your presentation.
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: Updated with the RFE details.
| y******5
发帖数: 858 | | b*****d
发帖数: 7166 | 26 'Contribution of major significance'指的是什么啊？你都有那么多引用了，难道还
不说明major significance吗？ | n****t
发帖数: 27 | 27 Good point!
I think that the IO didn't consider my citation report as eligible evidence
since it has several lines of Chinese that were not translated.
In the RFE, he only listed reference letters as the evidence for the
contribution claim.
希望用google scholar的同学不要犯这样的错误。
【在 b*****d 的大作中提到】
: 'Contribution of major significance'指的是什么啊？你都有那么多引用了，难道还
: 不说明major significance吗？
| n****t
发帖数: 27 | 28 悲情啊，板上著名律师之作阿！
【在 b*******e 的大作中提到】
: yes, 0002 is the IO. And RFE, though standard response, indicates you need
: some work to improve your presentation.
| b*******e
发帖数: 24532 | 29 谁啊？
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: 悲情啊，板上著名律师之作阿！
| b*********r
发帖数: 7139 | 30 CO-ASK
【在 b*******e 的大作中提到】
: 谁啊？
| | | b******g
发帖数: 1721 | 31 should be good enough. you will pass after rfe. good luck | b**********d
发帖数: 419 | | j****t
发帖数: 1663 | 33 lz的 average citation per paper 是140/25=5.6，对于物理专业来说有点低（根据
ESI物理的average citation rate is about 8.19）.
另外，RL的确是一个重要的（软）证据来说明你的 contribution to the field, 但你
还需要拿出一些硬证据来，比如媒体报道，别人文章里大段的讨论，还有就是你的工作
得到了广泛的应用。
evidence
【在 n****t 的大作中提到】
: Good point!
: I think that the IO didn't consider my citation report as eligible evidence
: since it has several lines of Chinese that were not translated.
: In the RFE, he only listed reference letters as the evidence for the
: contribution claim.
: 希望用google scholar的同学不要犯这样的错误。
|
|
