b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 1 EB1A TSC RFE求助兼教训之二- judgement
IO的意见:
You submitted evidence that you judged the work of others by having reviewed
manuscripts for such journal as xx etc. Submit evidence that sets the
petitioner apart from others in the field, such as evidence that he has
reviewed an unusually large number of articles, received independent
requests from a substantial number of journals, or served in an editorial
position for distinguished journals.
我的petition letter是这样claim的:
Dr. xx has served as reviewers for |
J********i
发帖数: 50662 | 2 我觉得量很大了，你提供editor的支持信了吗？
EB1A TSC RFE求助兼教训之二- judgement
IO的意见:
You submitted evidence that you judged the work of others by having reviewed
manuscripts for such journal as xx etc. Submit evidence that sets the
petitioner apart from others in the field, such as evidence that he has
reviewed an unusually large number of articles, received independent
requests from a substantial number of journals, or served in an editorial
position for distinguished journals.
我的petition letter是这样claim的:
Dr. xx ha
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: EB1A TSC RFE求助兼教训之二- judgement
: IO的意见:
: You submitted evidence that you judged the work of others by having reviewed
: manuscripts for such journal as xx etc. Submit evidence that sets the
: petitioner apart from others in the field, such as evidence that he has
: reviewed an unusually large number of articles, received independent
: requests from a substantial number of journals, or served in an editorial
: position for distinguished journals.
: 我的petition letter是这样claim的:
: Dr. xx has served as reviewers for
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 3 没有特别要editor关于review invitation的申明信。但有两个editor给我写了推荐信。
我和其中一个editor现在关系还不错，要不再请他写封申明，说明当Optics Letters的
reviewer很难之类的？
reviewed
【在 J********i 的大作中提到】
: 我觉得量很大了，你提供editor的支持信了吗？
:
: EB1A TSC RFE求助兼教训之二- judgement
: IO的意见:
: You submitted evidence that you judged the work of others by having reviewed
: manuscripts for such journal as xx etc. Submit evidence that sets the
: petitioner apart from others in the field, such as evidence that he has
: reviewed an unusually large number of articles, received independent
: requests from a substantial number of journals, or served in an editorial
: position for distinguished journals.
|
J********i
发帖数: 50662 | 4 我觉得可以让他写你在这个领域很杰出，对你的审稿很满意，因此多次邀请你审稿。难
不难就不用提了吧。其他的期刊你也可以问问看能不能要到支持信。IO太欺负人了
没有特别要editor关于review invitation的申明信。但有两个editor给我写了推荐信。
我和其中一个editor现在关系还不错，要不再请他写封申明，说明当Optics Letters的
reviewer很难之类的？
reviewed
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 没有特别要editor关于review invitation的申明信。但有两个editor给我写了推荐信。
: 我和其中一个editor现在关系还不错，要不再请他写封申明，说明当Optics Letters的
: reviewer很难之类的？
:
: reviewed
|
c********r
发帖数: 122 | 5 请问这个IO是几号？看来是故意刁难你，难道是100号？ |
J********i
发帖数: 50662 | 6 楼主前面说了，399
请问这个IO是几号？看来是故意刁难你，难道是100号？
【在 c********r 的大作中提到】
: 请问这个IO是几号？看来是故意刁难你，难道是100号？
|
c********r
发帖数: 122 | 7 对不住，没看前面的帖子，希望楼主好运
【在 J********i 的大作中提到】
: 楼主前面说了，399
:
: 请问这个IO是几号？看来是故意刁难你，难道是100号？
|
e**2
发帖数: 66 | 8 你这个实在太背了！没办法！
不过预祝你能过RFE！
reviewed
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: EB1A TSC RFE求助兼教训之二- judgement
: IO的意见:
: You submitted evidence that you judged the work of others by having reviewed
: manuscripts for such journal as xx etc. Submit evidence that sets the
: petitioner apart from others in the field, such as evidence that he has
: reviewed an unusually large number of articles, received independent
: requests from a substantial number of journals, or served in an editorial
: position for distinguished journals.
: 我的petition letter是这样claim的:
: Dr. xx has served as reviewers for
|
w***n
发帖数: 1162 | 9 我想好奇的是，有些垃圾网站ISTPress请我做associate editor，能不能算？会不会被
IO看穿.... |
s******t
发帖数: 3572 | 10 你的问题是你和一般的reviewer没有区别，所以体现不出extraodinary ability。我以
前说过多次，不要罗列数字。管你写了多少论文，有多少引用，审了多少稿，如果你只
是孤立地对待这些证据，不体现出自己的extraodinary ability，这些数字一点用都没
有。所以比如，这里你可以和杂志要推荐信，证明你是与其它审稿者是不同的，独一无
二的，不可或缺的。
reviewed
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: EB1A TSC RFE求助兼教训之二- judgement
: IO的意见:
: You submitted evidence that you judged the work of others by having reviewed
: manuscripts for such journal as xx etc. Submit evidence that sets the
: petitioner apart from others in the field, such as evidence that he has
: reviewed an unusually large number of articles, received independent
: requests from a substantial number of journals, or served in an editorial
: position for distinguished journals.
: 我的petition letter是这样claim的:
: Dr. xx has served as reviewers for
|
j****2
发帖数: 281 | 11 似乎要编辑的信很必要，重申选你是因为的那一小撮选秀的才选你当reviewer
我记得当时回答主要强调3方面;
1. 指导一个期刊网页上面review的过程明确指出了每篇文章将被送给这个主题的国际
知名专家审阅。你仔细查查你的杂志稿约上有没有这一条，有的mark出来。其实很多期
刊为了自吹自擂，会有这一条的，我找到那个还不是我这个领域公认最好的，但勉强算
是leading journals之一了。
2. 找主编或者杂志的相关工作人员出信说选你是因为你是那一小撮。。。
3. 在次数的问题上，比如你最近2年在此杂志上审过几次，而每年该杂志一共才发表多
少文章，如果太多就换个方式说，该杂志发表你研究的主题才多少篇。你审过的远远高
于平均水平。
总之eb1申请感觉这10条中3条论证有时候感觉就像是个悖论。
不是因为你满足3条，所以你是那一小撮。是因为你已经是那一小撮，所以你很满足3点。 |
