c**********w
发帖数: 1746 | 1 we found an error with a high-impact journal paper. the "exciting finding"
is but a mathematical coincidence. Assuming we are right, can this be
published in that same high-impact journal? (PNAS) |
z*****8
发帖数: 1051 | 2 you can write a comment and publish that. someone will like it and some will
hate it. my former advisor wrote a piece about a highly cited Science paper
for a similar reason.
【在 c**********w 的大作中提到】
: we found an error with a high-impact journal paper. the "exciting finding"
: is but a mathematical coincidence. Assuming we are right, can this be
: published in that same high-impact journal? (PNAS)
|
c**********w
发帖数: 1746 | 3 haha, but a comment does not count as a paper
will
paper
【在 z*****8 的大作中提到】
: you can write a comment and publish that. someone will like it and some will
: hate it. my former advisor wrote a piece about a highly cited Science paper
: for a similar reason.
|
d*******h
发帖数: 2146 | 4 a detailed comment does count as publication.
【在 c**********w 的大作中提到】
: haha, but a comment does not count as a paper
:
: will
: paper
|
