由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Faculty版 - 怎么回复很空泛的审稿意见
相关主题
about manuscript submission能不能给editor一些非comments的评论
这主编是不是太客气了....Will editor notify me before sending manuscript out for review?
连续两篇ms悲剧how to rebute such kind of decision letter from editor
看了上学期的course evaluation,心情很复杂,大家是怎么对待这些evaluations的?请问有人清过professional copy editor改文章吗?social science类的
问个关于 authorship 的问题single-author的文章,给editor的response letter,用I 还是We?
大家最后总分给A的比例大概怎样?关于manuscript中的unpublished work
【请问】这种面试问题的回答请教发文章在ACS journal的 Request for NIH Policy addendum
帮解读下这个talk 要求请教一个审稿的问题
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: paper话题: xx话题: xxx话题: reviewer
进入Faculty版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
a******u
发帖数: 239
1
看这个reviewer的审稿意见:
This paper presents a XX technique, .... Its a nice field of research and
the paper is well organized. The authors should add comparison and improve
the quality of their paper. The field is image processing. So the paper
should include more images from the database as well.
请问我的回答得体吗?我觉得文章中的比较和图像已经足以支持结论。
RE: Thanks to the reviewer. XX is a new imaging technology to improve XXX,
which greatly fits the goal of this journal. This manuscript evaluated XXX.
Specifically, the measured factors in this study consisted of .... Based on
these qualitative and quantitative factors, it is convincible to make the
conclusions that .... The authors feel that the figures and images in the
manuscript have provided solid support for the results and conclusions.
M*P
发帖数: 6456
2
感觉你就没想回他。这个语气不好吧

.
on

【在 a******u 的大作中提到】
: 看这个reviewer的审稿意见:
: This paper presents a XX technique, .... Its a nice field of research and
: the paper is well organized. The authors should add comparison and improve
: the quality of their paper. The field is image processing. So the paper
: should include more images from the database as well.
: 请问我的回答得体吗?我觉得文章中的比较和图像已经足以支持结论。
: RE: Thanks to the reviewer. XX is a new imaging technology to improve XXX,
: which greatly fits the goal of this journal. This manuscript evaluated XXX.
: Specifically, the measured factors in this study consisted of .... Based on
: these qualitative and quantitative factors, it is convincible to make the

m****1
发帖数: 736
3
BSO! tjjtds!!!
s******y
发帖数: 28562
4
我看人家打算给你水过的。
你就不能至少做个样子多放几个图片么?

.
on

【在 a******u 的大作中提到】
: 看这个reviewer的审稿意见:
: This paper presents a XX technique, .... Its a nice field of research and
: the paper is well organized. The authors should add comparison and improve
: the quality of their paper. The field is image processing. So the paper
: should include more images from the database as well.
: 请问我的回答得体吗?我觉得文章中的比较和图像已经足以支持结论。
: RE: Thanks to the reviewer. XX is a new imaging technology to improve XXX,
: which greatly fits the goal of this journal. This manuscript evaluated XXX.
: Specifically, the measured factors in this study consisted of .... Based on
: these qualitative and quantitative factors, it is convincible to make the

a****t
发帖数: 1532
5
不麻烦的话,为啥不多加的图呢? 和reviewer对着干,貌似不明智。

.
on

【在 a******u 的大作中提到】
: 看这个reviewer的审稿意见:
: This paper presents a XX technique, .... Its a nice field of research and
: the paper is well organized. The authors should add comparison and improve
: the quality of their paper. The field is image processing. So the paper
: should include more images from the database as well.
: 请问我的回答得体吗?我觉得文章中的比较和图像已经足以支持结论。
: RE: Thanks to the reviewer. XX is a new imaging technology to improve XXX,
: which greatly fits the goal of this journal. This manuscript evaluated XXX.
: Specifically, the measured factors in this study consisted of .... Based on
: these qualitative and quantitative factors, it is convincible to make the

h********0
发帖数: 12056
6
这年头还有不空泛的审稿意见吗?

.
on

【在 a******u 的大作中提到】
: 看这个reviewer的审稿意见:
: This paper presents a XX technique, .... Its a nice field of research and
: the paper is well organized. The authors should add comparison and improve
: the quality of their paper. The field is image processing. So the paper
: should include more images from the database as well.
: 请问我的回答得体吗?我觉得文章中的比较和图像已经足以支持结论。
: RE: Thanks to the reviewer. XX is a new imaging technology to improve XXX,
: which greatly fits the goal of this journal. This manuscript evaluated XXX.
: Specifically, the measured factors in this study consisted of .... Based on
: these qualitative and quantitative factors, it is convincible to make the

a******u
发帖数: 239
7
明白了。我还是想办法加一些内容和图吧。
谢谢
1 (共1页)
进入Faculty版参与讨论
相关主题
请教一个审稿的问题问个关于 authorship 的问题
first author都是做80-90%的?大家最后总分给A的比例大概怎样?
Co-author是个拖拉的人怎么办【请问】这种面试问题的回答
two-body problem头疼啊帮解读下这个talk 要求
about manuscript submission能不能给editor一些非comments的评论
这主编是不是太客气了....Will editor notify me before sending manuscript out for review?
连续两篇ms悲剧how to rebute such kind of decision letter from editor
看了上学期的course evaluation,心情很复杂,大家是怎么对待这些evaluations的?请问有人清过professional copy editor改文章吗?social science类的
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: paper话题: xx话题: xxx话题: reviewer