T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 1 I got a very detailed review of my paper, and I like his/her comments a lot.
S/he provided very reasonable suggestions and raised good questions. I
really want to thank him/her personally and to clarify some questions s/he
asked. I feel that with two-way communication, this paper can be further
improved.
I have a vague idea on who s/he might be, but I am not sure.
I know that it is not professional to ask the editor who this reviewer is
and to contact the reviewer. Yet I really want to talk to t | t***t
发帖数: 139 | 2 if your advisor allows it, ask the editor to forward your email to the
reviewer. | m*******y
发帖数: 21 | 3 I suggest that you would better not do this thing.
Even you asked the editor, he/she would hardly tell you the info.
lot.
【在 T*******y 的大作中提到】
: I got a very detailed review of my paper, and I like his/her comments a lot.
: S/he provided very reasonable suggestions and raised good questions. I
: really want to thank him/her personally and to clarify some questions s/he
: asked. I feel that with two-way communication, this paper can be further
: improved.
: I have a vague idea on who s/he might be, but I am not sure.
: I know that it is not professional to ask the editor who this reviewer is
: and to contact the reviewer. Yet I really want to talk to t
| a****l
发帖数: 8211 | 4 do you really mean "good questions"? I am under the impression that when
people said so, it usually implies "stupid question". If this is the case, I
doubt editor will help. Asking adviser for rebuttal would be more normal.
lot.
【在 T*******y 的大作中提到】
: I got a very detailed review of my paper, and I like his/her comments a lot.
: S/he provided very reasonable suggestions and raised good questions. I
: really want to thank him/her personally and to clarify some questions s/he
: asked. I feel that with two-way communication, this paper can be further
: improved.
: I have a vague idea on who s/he might be, but I am not sure.
: I know that it is not professional to ask the editor who this reviewer is
: and to contact the reviewer. Yet I really want to talk to t
|
|
