m******4 发帖数: 108 | 1 很多项呀,7分算好的吗?
----------------------- REVIEW 1 ---------------------
Significance of the Contribution: 7 (++)
Soundness and Positioning with Respect to Related Work: 7 (++)
Depth of Theoretical and/or Experimental Analysis (as appropriate): 7 (++)
Quality of Presentation: 4 (--)
SUMMARY RATING: 1 (+ (slightly positive)) |
L********d 发帖数: 3820 | 2 看SUMMARY RATING,有希望
【在 m******4 的大作中提到】 : 很多项呀,7分算好的吗? : ----------------------- REVIEW 1 --------------------- : Significance of the Contribution: 7 (++) : Soundness and Positioning with Respect to Related Work: 7 (++) : Depth of Theoretical and/or Experimental Analysis (as appropriate): 7 (++) : Quality of Presentation: 4 (--) : SUMMARY RATING: 1 (+ (slightly positive))
|
a*****i 发帖数: 19 | 3 SUMMARY RATING 似乎有希望 不知道有多少 4 或者5的
其他几个reviewer如何啊 |
f******5 发帖数: 104 | 4 LZ summary rating 分别是多少呢? 今年2000多submission,不知道aaai是按accept
ratio接受,还是按照大概固定的篇数接受。
我的今年的是1,2,3;有点小担心 |