f*****x
发帖数: 545 | 1 Vul vs not, sitting south you hold:
S: A
H: K98XX
D: QX
C: AKQXX
W N E S
1C(16+)
3D 3S P ?
with pick-up pd, agrees to play precision. what do you bid now? | w****n
发帖数: 241 | 2 probably i would try 4H,
if pd has 3 hearts, then it's very doable,
if pd has 6 or more spades, he still has chance to bid 4S.
3NT is too risky. since west could have AKJTxx
then u down ugly.
or maybe 4D to show ur both H and C suites, and
pd could determine trump.
btw, this is not the problem of precision.
it's common after any sacrifice bid.
【在 f*****x 的大作中提到】
: Vul vs not, sitting south you hold:
: S: A
: H: K98XX
: D: QX
: C: AKQXX
: W N E S
: 1C(16+)
: 3D 3S P ?
: with pick-up pd, agrees to play precision. what do you bid now?
| f*****x
发帖数: 545 | 3 yes, not only to precision, but much more severe for precision. isnot it? if
play nature, we would open 1h, then after pd's 3s, u will bid 4c without
problem.【 在 Watson (福尔摩斯的癞皮狗) 的大作中提到: 】 | c****u
发帖数: 3277 | 4 this is tough, usually it's not easy to handle two suiters if you open
1C, perhaps precision players should have the agreement that 4D cuebid show
this hand type.
If you bid 4H, you may miss cold 5C if partner holds something like this:
SKQxxx HQx DKx CJxxx, 5C would be cold, 4H may go down 1 if H 4-2 splits.
However, if you play 4D to show this kind of two suiters, you wouldn't be
able to show slam interest in spades. That's also a huge drawback.
If your overall strength is strong, I believe it
【在 f*****x 的大作中提到】
: yes, not only to precision, but much more severe for precision. isnot it? if
: play nature, we would open 1h, then after pd's 3s, u will bid 4c without
: problem.【 在 Watson (福尔摩斯的癞皮狗) 的大作中提到: 】
| f*****x
发帖数: 545 | 5 Yes, 4c is much safer. h suit is just too broke. But 4H is game contract while
4c is not. It is really hard.
Perhaps what to bid depends on what 3s means. Is it gf? in old version
precision. this is not gf, right? 3s shows 5-8hcp. if this is the case, then
maybe better to pass.
if 3s is gf, how about 3N? as watson suggested. u may go donw a lot, but u may
go down a lot too in other game contract.
【在 c****u 的大作中提到】
: this is tough, usually it's not easy to handle two suiters if you open
: 1C, perhaps precision players should have the agreement that 4D cuebid show
: this hand type.
: If you bid 4H, you may miss cold 5C if partner holds something like this:
: SKQxxx HQx DKx CJxxx, 5C would be cold, 4H may go down 1 if H 4-2 splits.
: However, if you play 4D to show this kind of two suiters, you wouldn't be
: able to show slam interest in spades. That's also a huge drawback.
: If your overall strength is strong, I believe it
| h******q
发帖数: 34 | 6 partnership plays a big role for this kind of bid.
first I question the 3S bid, which is not so good unless his spade is very
solid. He should dbl in stead of 3S with a good hand. your 1c told him you are
the main man for this board. he should let you bid first at higher level when
opp preemt in minors and try to fit your suit. now his 3s ate up all 3 level
bid space and force you to bid in 4 level in first natural bid. If he have
good spade, he should expect you have good heart otherwise 3nt if
【在 f*****x 的大作中提到】
: Yes, 4c is much safer. h suit is just too broke. But 4H is game contract while
: 4c is not. It is really hard.
: Perhaps what to bid depends on what 3s means. Is it gf? in old version
: precision. this is not gf, right? 3s shows 5-8hcp. if this is the case, then
: maybe better to pass.
: if 3s is gf, how about 3N? as watson suggested. u may go donw a lot, but u may
: go down a lot too in other game contract.
|
|
