g**********y
发帖数: 14569 | 1 East open 3H, South hand ->
SAKQxx HKJ10xx DAx CJ
How does south bid?
A. X
B. 3S
C. 3NT
if I double, most likely, north will bid a minor suit and I will be forced to
4S if north has a hand like:
Sx Hxx DJxxx CQxxxxx
Considering this, I bid 3S. North raise to 4S. Sadly, north hand is
SJxxxx HQ DKxxx CAxx
Question is: is there any problem in this bidding? should South explore slam
with his hand? | w****b
发帖数: 623 | 2 Preempt works. After 3H, there's always some guessing. But overcalling S seems
to be the lesser of all evils. After north's raise, bidding again by S is
defefinitely wrong -- pd can have only 3 S support and your H holding becomes
highly questionable: long holding in opponent's suit is generally good asset
as dummy can overruff, but only in game, as you may have to lose a few trumps
if dummy has low trumps. In slam, you almost always need to set it up and your
holding is just unlikely to happen.
【在 g**********y 的大作中提到】
: East open 3H, South hand ->
: SAKQxx HKJ10xx DAx CJ
: How does south bid?
: A. X
: B. 3S
: C. 3NT
: if I double, most likely, north will bid a minor suit and I will be forced to
: 4S if north has a hand like:
: Sx Hxx DJxxx CQxxxxx
: Considering this, I bid 3S. North raise to 4S. Sadly, north hand is
| c****u
发帖数: 3277 | 3 I think 4C is still natural but forcing.
because sometimes, you may not have spade fit and H stopper,
for example, you may have SJ Hxxx DAxxx CAKxxx, the only bid that makes
sense here is 4C.
you may easily miss a cold 5C or 5D if partner
has SAKxxx Hx DKQxx CQxx, so looking for a fit is still the first priority.
This bidding sequence is different from
1H 3S 4C
I think 4C here should be fit showing. Since with S stopper, we can
bid 3NT, without S stopper, we can double, it doesn't make sense to
【在 w****b 的大作中提到】
: Preempt works. After 3H, there's always some guessing. But overcalling S seems
: to be the lesser of all evils. After north's raise, bidding again by S is
: defefinitely wrong -- pd can have only 3 S support and your H holding becomes
: highly questionable: long holding in opponent's suit is generally good asset
: as dummy can overruff, but only in game, as you may have to lose a few trumps
: if dummy has low trumps. In slam, you almost always need to set it up and your
: holding is just unlikely to happen.
| w****b
发帖数: 623 | 4 After a 3 level preempt, we should be playing for equal conversion so I think
the benefit of playing 4C for natural, seeking improvement of contract is
somewhat limited and less frequent.
With shortness in oppo's suit, I'm always inclined to double, even with 5 S.
Sometimes you can't stand a tap even with a 5-3 fit when the split of S tends
to be bad...
Anyway, as long as the 4C is not expected to be some garbage like x xxx xxx
KQT9xx, it won't be too disaster-prone, as the message of 4C has to
【在 c****u 的大作中提到】
: I think 4C is still natural but forcing.
: because sometimes, you may not have spade fit and H stopper,
: for example, you may have SJ Hxxx DAxxx CAKxxx, the only bid that makes
: sense here is 4C.
: you may easily miss a cold 5C or 5D if partner
: has SAKxxx Hx DKQxx CQxx, so looking for a fit is still the first priority.
: This bidding sequence is different from
: 1H 3S 4C
: I think 4C here should be fit showing. Since with S stopper, we can
: bid 3NT, without S stopper, we can double, it doesn't make sense to
| p*****e
发帖数: 989 | 5 you X to show your strength first, if pard bid a minor, you bid your S suit, after this
your pard knows you are really strong and with a suit. Then pard will start a
slam try, provided your pard knows what he/she is doing.
【在 g**********y 的大作中提到】
: East open 3H, South hand ->
: SAKQxx HKJ10xx DAx CJ
: How does south bid?
: A. X
: B. 3S
: C. 3NT
: if I double, most likely, north will bid a minor suit and I will be forced to
: 4S if north has a hand like:
: Sx Hxx DJxxx CQxxxxx
: Considering this, I bid 3S. North raise to 4S. Sadly, north hand is
| w****b
发帖数: 623 | 6 X is always wrong if you have only one suited hand and strong: jumping to 4S
shows this type of hands. If you double and pull, pd will think you have a
2-suited hand.
Also after your righty opened 3H, your 18 count is not that attrative...
after this
a
to
slam
【在 p*****e 的大作中提到】
: you X to show your strength first, if pard bid a minor, you bid your S suit, after this
: your pard knows you are really strong and with a suit. Then pard will start a
: slam try, provided your pard knows what he/she is doing.
|
|
