j**********k
发帖数: 296 | 1 按说data quality差些无所谓，但这篇真算是极品了。editor该被fire掉，天雷滚滚的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能看出一堆问题。
RETRACTED: VMA21 Deficiency Causes an Autophagic Myopathy by Compromising V-
ATPase Activity and Lysosomal Acidification
Reason: Our paper reported the identification of mutations in the
gene VMA21 in patients with X-linked Myopathy with Excessive Autophagy (XMEA
) and characterized the molecular mechanisms underlying the disease
phenotype. Many of the figure panels in the paper summ |
b******n
发帖数: 4225 | 2 第一作者疑似三哥（姐）
的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能
看出一堆问题。
V-
XMEA
【在 j**********k 的大作中提到】
: 按说data quality差些无所谓，但这篇真算是极品了。editor该被fire掉，天雷滚滚的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能看出一堆问题。
: RETRACTED: VMA21 Deficiency Causes an Autophagic Myopathy by Compromising V-
: ATPase Activity and Lysosomal Acidification
: Reason: Our paper reported the identification of mutations in the
: gene VMA21 in patients with X-linked Myopathy with Excessive Autophagy (XMEA
: ) and characterized the molecular mechanisms underlying the disease
: phenotype. Many of the figure panels in the paper summ
|
p****n
发帖数: 9263 | 3 肯定是三哥（姐），疑似名门之后
【在 b******n 的大作中提到】
: 第一作者疑似三哥（姐）
:
: 的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能
: 看出一堆问题。
: V-
: XMEA
|
H*********1
发帖数: 56 | 4 能具体说说啥错误吗？
的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能
看出一堆问题。
V-
XMEA
【在 j**********k 的大作中提到】
: 按说data quality差些无所谓，但这篇真算是极品了。editor该被fire掉，天雷滚滚的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能看出一堆问题。
: RETRACTED: VMA21 Deficiency Causes an Autophagic Myopathy by Compromising V-
: ATPase Activity and Lysosomal Acidification
: Reason: Our paper reported the identification of mutations in the
: gene VMA21 in patients with X-linked Myopathy with Excessive Autophagy (XMEA
: ) and characterized the molecular mechanisms underlying the disease
: phenotype. Many of the figure panels in the paper summ
|
C*********m
发帖数: 213 | 5 还有一篇同期的preview,是不是也要retract?
http://www.cell.com/abstract/S0092-8674(09)00387-0
的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能
看出一堆问题。
V-
XMEA
【在 j**********k 的大作中提到】
: 按说data quality差些无所谓，但这篇真算是极品了。editor该被fire掉，天雷滚滚的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能看出一堆问题。
: RETRACTED: VMA21 Deficiency Causes an Autophagic Myopathy by Compromising V-
: ATPase Activity and Lysosomal Acidification
: Reason: Our paper reported the identification of mutations in the
: gene VMA21 in patients with X-linked Myopathy with Excessive Autophagy (XMEA
: ) and characterized the molecular mechanisms underlying the disease
: phenotype. Many of the figure panels in the paper summ
|
P****d
发帖数: 564 | 6 Hoho, Retracted Cell, 以为Cell出了新的子刊。 |
w******y
发帖数: 8040 | 7 "While we stand by the validity of our conclusions, we believe that
the most responsible course of action is to retract our paper."
perfect excuse for 大牛实验室前瞻性作假啊
的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能
看出一堆问题。
V-
XMEA
【在 j**********k 的大作中提到】
: 按说data quality差些无所谓，但这篇真算是极品了。editor该被fire掉，天雷滚滚的谬误竟然也可以送出去给reviewers？reviewers也是吃屎了，即使print out都该能看出一堆问题。
: RETRACTED: VMA21 Deficiency Causes an Autophagic Myopathy by Compromising V-
: ATPase Activity and Lysosomal Acidification
: Reason: Our paper reported the identification of mutations in the
: gene VMA21 in patients with X-linked Myopathy with Excessive Autophagy (XMEA
: ) and characterized the molecular mechanisms underlying the disease
: phenotype. Many of the figure panels in the paper summ
|
