m******s
发帖数: 8493 | 1 也许把记录片和普通电影放在一起比较有些不伦不类
但是在今年看过的film里,还是这部最好(嗯,给菠菜记小勋章一枚)
导演Michael Moore其貌不扬,但是他的东东的确不同凡响
以后要找他的stupid white man和roger and me来看看
Bowling for Columbine从1999年columbine high school枪杀事件入手
讲解美国枪支问题,它不象一般记录片形式局限在这个单一的事件上
而是洋洋洒洒的展开到整个美国社会,从各个访谈中,包括对oklahoma大爆炸的嫌疑犯
到NRA的主席,事件包括了littleton枪击事件到美国最年轻的学校枪击事件
(6岁儿童因为母亲寄居在亲戚家而发现一把手枪,打死6岁同班女生)
一点点的挖掘事情背后的因由(再注:里面有采访marilyn manson的片断
这家伙穿着打扮异于常人,不过听他采访言之有物,决定开始听听他的东东
不过需要ann提供歌词),甚至做了一些非常有趣的比较,当然是对'可爱'的邻居加拿大
具体的还是大家自己看BFC去体会和发笑.
个人认为片中的一个着眼点非常好,而且非常具有普遍性,就是fea | t***u
发帖数: 230 | 2 Just saw the film at the docfilm tonight. I dare not say it's a good
movie, but it definitely is worth to be watched at least once. It's
billed as a documentary, but not entirely so. The thing is, director
Michael Moore blames the media for showing us very biased information,
but he isn't any better. The truth is probably somewhere in between.
By the way, I found the part of him bringing two victoms of Columbine
to K-mart store and try to return the bullet buried in them extremely
insensitive an
【在 m******s 的大作中提到】
: 也许把记录片和普通电影放在一起比较有些不伦不类
: 但是在今年看过的film里,还是这部最好(嗯,给菠菜记小勋章一枚)
: 导演Michael Moore其貌不扬,但是他的东东的确不同凡响
: 以后要找他的stupid white man和roger and me来看看
: Bowling for Columbine从1999年columbine high school枪杀事件入手
: 讲解美国枪支问题,它不象一般记录片形式局限在这个单一的事件上
: 而是洋洋洒洒的展开到整个美国社会,从各个访谈中,包括对oklahoma大爆炸的嫌疑犯
: 到NRA的主席,事件包括了littleton枪击事件到美国最年轻的学校枪击事件
: (6岁儿童因为母亲寄居在亲戚家而发现一把手枪,打死6岁同班女生)
: 一点点的挖掘事情背后的因由(再注:里面有采访marilyn manson的片断
| k*********r
发帖数: 758 | 3 我们这鬼地方终於也上映了, talk to her上映还没影，ft,
这电影别致在什么地方啊？后来poses了哪些interesting questions?
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: Just saw the film at the docfilm tonight. I dare not say it's a good
: movie, but it definitely is worth to be watched at least once. It's
: billed as a documentary, but not entirely so. The thing is, director
: Michael Moore blames the media for showing us very biased information,
: but he isn't any better. The truth is probably somewhere in between.
: By the way, I found the part of him bringing two victoms of Columbine
: to K-mart store and try to return the bullet buried in them extremely
: insensitive an
| d***e
发帖数: 710 | 4 you can see the clip of that cartoon
"a history of america" on the movie's website
www.bowlingforcolumbine.com
and the clips of marilyn manson and matt stones.
pretty interesting. too bad baltimore is not showing it any more.
although i haven't seen it, i think the director at least did a
good job of bringing the topic to people;s attention and make
them think.
【在 k*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我们这鬼地方终於也上映了, talk to her上映还没影，ft,
: 这电影别致在什么地方啊？后来poses了哪些interesting questions?
| m******s
发帖数: 8493 | 5 well,I totally agree with u about the part he bring the kid to kmart
at this point,he is simply use the media to humiliate kmart
and those kmart front desk ppl do looks stupid
no wonder kmart is bankrupted
and what kind of answer u want to hear?
frankly speaking,I dont there r some absolutely answer for the Qthat he raised
it is never too late to bring these Q onto the top of the table
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: Just saw the film at the docfilm tonight. I dare not say it's a good
: movie, but it definitely is worth to be watched at least once. It's
: billed as a documentary, but not entirely so. The thing is, director
: Michael Moore blames the media for showing us very biased information,
: but he isn't any better. The truth is probably somewhere in between.
: By the way, I found the part of him bringing two victoms of Columbine
: to K-mart store and try to return the bullet buried in them extremely
: insensitive an
| b********t
发帖数: 992 | 6
关于加拿大的对比非常的假，当然我也没去过TORONTO，但是这么繁华的CITY里达到那种
路不拾遗，夜不闭户不太可能叭
【在 m******s 的大作中提到】
: 也许把记录片和普通电影放在一起比较有些不伦不类
: 但是在今年看过的film里,还是这部最好(嗯,给菠菜记小勋章一枚)
: 导演Michael Moore其貌不扬,但是他的东东的确不同凡响
: 以后要找他的stupid white man和roger and me来看看
: Bowling for Columbine从1999年columbine high school枪杀事件入手
: 讲解美国枪支问题,它不象一般记录片形式局限在这个单一的事件上
: 而是洋洋洒洒的展开到整个美国社会,从各个访谈中,包括对oklahoma大爆炸的嫌疑犯
: 到NRA的主席,事件包括了littleton枪击事件到美国最年轻的学校枪击事件
: (6岁儿童因为母亲寄居在亲戚家而发现一把手枪,打死6岁同班女生)
: 一点点的挖掘事情背后的因由(再注:里面有采访marilyn manson的片断
| t***u
发帖数: 230 | 7 Doc is always refreshing, and especially hard to find in large-scale
release, so I think this one is worth checking out. Don't see it for
the movie aspect though, because his editing is just plainly amateurish.
Some facts are a lot more interesting then the message he's selling.
Question is interesting too, though not a huge surprise to non-american
people.
【在 k*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我们这鬼地方终於也上映了, talk to her上映还没影，ft,
: 这电影别致在什么地方啊？后来poses了哪些interesting questions?
| d***e
发帖数: 710 | 8 tharu, what is wrong with this post of yours?
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: Doc is always refreshing, and especially hard to find in large-scale
: release, so I think this one is worth checking out. Don't see it for
: the movie aspect though, because his editing is just plainly amateurish.
: Some facts are a lot more interesting then the message he's selling.
: Question is interesting too, though not a huge surprise to non-american
: people.
| d***e
发帖数: 710 | 9 i'm not sure if i understood the kmart part as you guys did, but didn't
a lady come out in the end and told them that kmart won't be selling any
amunitions starting 90 days from then? i think that's a very useful thing
to start with.
i guess i was looking forward too much to this movie and have seen and
heard too much about it to feel satisfied in the end. I felt that Michael
Moore was consciously or unconsciously steering people away from some
major questions and focusing on some secondary iss
【在 m******s 的大作中提到】
: well,I totally agree with u about the part he bring the kid to kmart
: at this point,he is simply use the media to humiliate kmart
: and those kmart front desk ppl do looks stupid
: no wonder kmart is bankrupted
: and what kind of answer u want to hear?
: frankly speaking,I dont there r some absolutely answer for the Qthat he raised
: it is never too late to bring these Q onto the top of the table
| t***u
发帖数: 230 | 10 Well, the three things I have against this doc are:
1. Editing, editing, editing!
Please, Michael Moore, edit your film; don't just show us some random
meaningless shots. String them together, control your pace, and make them
more powerful.
2. Michael Moore is unbelievably rude sometimes.
Especially when he was interviewing Charles Heston. Not that I like
Charles Heston, I mean, he's just a pretty face with a huge ego. Say,
which one of you would ever put your own name on every piece of furnitur
【在 d***e 的大作中提到】
: i'm not sure if i understood the kmart part as you guys did, but didn't
: a lady come out in the end and told them that kmart won't be selling any
: amunitions starting 90 days from then? i think that's a very useful thing
: to start with.
: i guess i was looking forward too much to this movie and have seen and
: heard too much about it to feel satisfied in the end. I felt that Michael
: Moore was consciously or unconsciously steering people away from some
: major questions and focusing on some secondary iss
| d***e
发帖数: 710 | 11 nod, i agree that he definitely could have been more thoughtful and less
rude (and they were pointless rudeness). he should have gotten a sociologist
on his team. and a statistician, hoho.
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: Well, the three things I have against this doc are:
: 1. Editing, editing, editing!
: Please, Michael Moore, edit your film; don't just show us some random
: meaningless shots. String them together, control your pace, and make them
: more powerful.
: 2. Michael Moore is unbelievably rude sometimes.
: Especially when he was interviewing Charles Heston. Not that I like
: Charles Heston, I mean, he's just a pretty face with a huge ego. Say,
: which one of you would ever put your own name on every piece of furnitur
| g*******a
发帖数: 1383 | 12 As a proud member of NRA, i'm always disgusted by these fags who are blaming
the NRA or gun stores for the violation happened. these guys are fucking
idiots, or helpless wimps.
i'm was in Kmart, i'll tell the sorry-ass bastard to put the bullet into the
original package and show me the receipt, and i'll only give him a store
credit in the same dept. hahahahaha...i bet he'll be MAD, hahahaha
commited
raised
【在 d***e 的大作中提到】
: i'm not sure if i understood the kmart part as you guys did, but didn't
: a lady come out in the end and told them that kmart won't be selling any
: amunitions starting 90 days from then? i think that's a very useful thing
: to start with.
: i guess i was looking forward too much to this movie and have seen and
: heard too much about it to feel satisfied in the end. I felt that Michael
: Moore was consciously or unconsciously steering people away from some
: major questions and focusing on some secondary iss
| d***e
发帖数: 710 | 13 in fact before i watched this movie i didn't know that you can easily
get a gun in these other safer countries
especially canada.7million guns in 10 million families. why don't they have
gun homicides? don't know about european countries, i doubt guns are as
prevalent there as in north america coz people are more urban. don't u think
having less guns to begin with can be helpful. like there are murders in china
but rarely involves gun. and there's a long way to go before we have high
school shoo
【在 g*******a 的大作中提到】
: As a proud member of NRA, i'm always disgusted by these fags who are blaming
: the NRA or gun stores for the violation happened. these guys are fucking
: idiots, or helpless wimps.
: i'm was in Kmart, i'll tell the sorry-ass bastard to put the bullet into the
: original package and show me the receipt, and i'll only give him a store
: credit in the same dept. hahahahaha...i bet he'll be MAD, hahahaha
:
: commited
: raised
|
|
