r******i
发帖数: 1445 | 1 1. Everyone has the right to make choice on their body.
2. Doctors should not do harm to a human life, whether born or unborn.
Someone pregnant should have the choice to stop providing their body organ
to support another life (their unborn child) at any time. However, the
doctor cannot practice a procedure that is intentionally harmful to the
unborn child or decrease the probability of viability of the child.
My solution:
1. Allow "abortion" in general.
2. Ban medical procedures that does not aim to maximize the viability of the
unborn child.
3. Allow parents choose to abandon their child at the first week of birth. (
And the child will be taken care of by the society/charity.) |
c*******e
发帖数: 5818 | 2 1,2相互矛盾，因为没有具体时间！
“unborn” 在一定期限就是女人的身体，你没法分开！
是不是应该立法 “自杀”也违法。。。。。。
还有吸毒，吸烟，喝酒。。。。。 慢性自杀。。。
：1. Everyone has the right to make choice on their body.
：2. Doctors should not do harm to a human life, whether born or unborn. |
r******i
发帖数: 1445 | 3 1 and 2 does not contradict.
You cannot force a doctor to help you suicide in the US, but you can kill
yourself without other's help.
Similarly, you cannot force a doctor to kill a life inside of your body. But
you can ask a doctor to take it out without using the method of killing it.
For example, C-section is completely legal and ethical in the US.
"“unborn” 在一定期限就是女人的身体"
Completely don't agree! Once conceived, the fetal is no longer part of the
woman's body. It's a life that's living inside of a woman's body.
Is a parasite living inside of your body part of your body?
"是不是应该立法 “自杀”也违法。。。。。。"
Killing yourself is not illegal. But help others to kill themselves is
illegal in the US.
【在 c*******e 的大作中提到】
: 1,2相互矛盾，因为没有具体时间！
: “unborn” 在一定期限就是女人的身体，你没法分开！
: 是不是应该立法 “自杀”也违法。。。。。。
: 还有吸毒，吸烟，喝酒。。。。。 慢性自杀。。。
:
: ：1. Everyone has the right to make choice on their body.
: ：2. Doctors should not do harm to a human life, whether born or unborn.
|
l****b
发帖数: 400 | 4 自杀合法，给自杀的人递刀子就不好说了
【在 c*******e 的大作中提到】
: 1,2相互矛盾，因为没有具体时间！
: “unborn” 在一定期限就是女人的身体，你没法分开！
: 是不是应该立法 “自杀”也违法。。。。。。
: 还有吸毒，吸烟，喝酒。。。。。 慢性自杀。。。
:
: ：1. Everyone has the right to make choice on their body.
: ：2. Doctors should not do harm to a human life, whether born or unborn.
|
C**********1
发帖数: 1 | |
r******i
发帖数: 1445 | 6 Sure. You can abort the child yourself. Don't ask a doctor to help you doing
abortion.
【在 C**********1 的大作中提到】
: 你不想堕就不堕。但别管别人。
|
c*******e
发帖数: 5818 | 7 胡说，除非人工子宫，离开母体就不能活，
不能自主呼吸算什么生命！！
什么叫force doctor， 自己身体 付钱 找人 有问题吗？？
But
it.
【在 r******i 的大作中提到】
: 1 and 2 does not contradict.
: You cannot force a doctor to help you suicide in the US, but you can kill
: yourself without other's help.
: Similarly, you cannot force a doctor to kill a life inside of your body. But
: you can ask a doctor to take it out without using the method of killing it.
: For example, C-section is completely legal and ethical in the US.
: "“unborn” 在一定期限就是女人的身体"
: Completely don't agree! Once conceived, the fetal is no longer part of the
: woman's body. It's a life that's living inside of a woman's body.
: Is a parasite living inside of your body part of your body?
|
r******i
发帖数: 1445 | 8 "胡说，除非人工子宫，离开母体就不能活，"
I support the right of taking the unborn kid out of the womb. However, you
cannot use the procedure to kill the unborn kid, but need to be a procedure
that maximize the viability of the unborn kid. If a kid could live outside
of the womb with existing technology, they must be provided that technology.
"不能自主呼吸算什么生命！！"
There are many people that cannot live without mechanical ventilators or
life supports. Are they not living?
" 什么叫force doctor， 自己身体 付钱 找人 有问题吗？？"
Can you pay a doctor to help you suicide in US? Why not?
【在 c*******e 的大作中提到】
: 胡说，除非人工子宫，离开母体就不能活，
: 不能自主呼吸算什么生命！！
: 什么叫force doctor， 自己身体 付钱 找人 有问题吗？？
:
: But
: it.
|
m**y
发帖数: 1 | |
