l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 1 High court strikes down raisin program as unconstitutional
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court ruled Monday that a 66-year-old program
that lets the government take raisins away from farmers to help reduce
supply and boost market prices is unconstitutional.
In an 8-1 ruling, the justices said forcing raisin growers to give up part
of their annual crop without full payment is an illegal confiscation of
private property.
The court sided with California farmers Marvin and Laura Horne, who claimed
they were losing money under a 1940s-era program they call outdated and
ineffective. They were fined $695,000 for trying to get around the program.
A federal appeals court said the program was acceptable because the farmers
benefited from higher market prices and didn't lose the entire value of
their crop.
But their cause had won wide support from conservative groups opposed to
government action that infringes on private property rights. Writing for the
court, Chief Justice John Roberts said the government must pay "just
compensation" when it takes personal goods just as when it takes land away.
Roberts rejected the government's argument that the Hornes voluntarily chose
to participate in the raisin market and have the option of selling
different crops if they don't like it.
"'Let them sell wine' is probably not much more comforting to the raisin
growers than similar retorts have been to others throughout history,"
Roberts said. "Property rights cannot be so easily manipulated."
Justice Stephen Breyer agreed that the Hornes were entitled to be properly
paid for their crops, but he wrote separately to say that the case should be
sent back to a lower court to decide whether they would have been owed any
money if they had actually complied with the program rules.
Breyer's separate opinion was joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and
Elena Kagan.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor was the only dissenter. She said the program did not
deprive the Hornes of all their property rights; it just limited the amount
of potential income they could earn from it.
The program was authorized under a 1937 law that allows the U.S. Department
of Agriculture to keep prices for raisins and other crops steady by helping
to manage supply. A 1949 marketing order allowed farmers to form a Raisin
Administrative Committee that would decide how much of the raisin crop
handlers must turn over to the government each year.
These raisins would be placed into a reserve pool to be sold outside the
open market, used for the school lunch program, or given away to charities
and foreign governments. Any profits from these reserve sales would go
toward funding the committee and anything left over went back to the farmers.
The Hornes refused to participate in the program in 2003 and 2004, when
raisin production far exceeded the expected demand. They tried to get around
the regulations by packaging crops on their own instead of going through a
middleman. But the department fined them for violating the rules.
Raisin handlers, who dry the grapes until they become raisins and then
package them, were required to give up 47 percent of their crop in 2003
season, but received far less than their costs of production. Farmers gave
up 30 percent of the crop in 2004 and were paid nothing.
Raisin prices have been relatively stable recently and the committee has not
ordered farmers to put crops in reserve since 2010.
Only a small number of other crops are regulated in the same way, though
federal officials say most programs are not active.
Source URL: http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/high-court-strikes-down-raisin-program-unconstitutional | T*********I
发帖数: 10729 | | b*****e
发帖数: 53215 | 3 这女劳模看样子就不像好人
【在 T*********I 的大作中提到】
: 8-1.
: SOTOMAYOR大法官太左了。
| f**********n
发帖数: 29853 | 4 she got this job because of Obama.
【在 b*****e 的大作中提到】
: 这女劳模看样子就不像好人
| S**C
发帖数: 2964 | 5 Yes it is indeed unbelievable.
It is also unbelievable that the Congress did not repeal that law after
nearly 80 years. I cannot decide which one is more astonishing and sad.
【在 T*********I 的大作中提到】
: 8-1.
: SOTOMAYOR大法官太左了。
| l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 6 High court strikes down raisin program as unconstitutional
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court ruled Monday that a 66-year-old program
that lets the government take raisins away from farmers to help reduce
supply and boost market prices is unconstitutional.
In an 8-1 ruling, the justices said forcing raisin growers to give up part
of their annual crop without full payment is an illegal confiscation of
private property.
The court sided with California farmers Marvin and Laura Horne, who claimed
they were losing money under a 1940s-era program they call outdated and
ineffective. They were fined $695,000 for trying to get around the program.
A federal appeals court said the program was acceptable because the farmers
benefited from higher market prices and didn't lose the entire value of
their crop.
But their cause had won wide support from conservative groups opposed to
government action that infringes on private property rights. Writing for the
court, Chief Justice John Roberts said the government must pay "just
compensation" when it takes personal goods just as when it takes land away.
Roberts rejected the government's argument that the Hornes voluntarily chose
to participate in the raisin market and have the option of selling
different crops if they don't like it.
"'Let them sell wine' is probably not much more comforting to the raisin
growers than similar retorts have been to others throughout history,"
Roberts said. "Property rights cannot be so easily manipulated."
Justice Stephen Breyer agreed that the Hornes were entitled to be properly
paid for their crops, but he wrote separately to say that the case should be
sent back to a lower court to decide whether they would have been owed any
money if they had actually complied with the program rules.
Breyer's separate opinion was joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and
Elena Kagan.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor was the only dissenter. She said the program did not
deprive the Hornes of all their property rights; it just limited the amount
of potential income they could earn from it.
The program was authorized under a 1937 law that allows the U.S. Department
of Agriculture to keep prices for raisins and other crops steady by helping
to manage supply. A 1949 marketing order allowed farmers to form a Raisin
Administrative Committee that would decide how much of the raisin crop
handlers must turn over to the government each year.
These raisins would be placed into a reserve pool to be sold outside the
open market, used for the school lunch program, or given away to charities
and foreign governments. Any profits from these reserve sales would go
toward funding the committee and anything left over went back to the farmers.
The Hornes refused to participate in the program in 2003 and 2004, when
raisin production far exceeded the expected demand. They tried to get around
the regulations by packaging crops on their own instead of going through a
middleman. But the department fined them for violating the rules.
Raisin handlers, who dry the grapes until they become raisins and then
package them, were required to give up 47 percent of their crop in 2003
season, but received far less than their costs of production. Farmers gave
up 30 percent of the crop in 2004 and were paid nothing.
Raisin prices have been relatively stable recently and the committee has not
ordered farmers to put crops in reserve since 2010.
Only a small number of other crops are regulated in the same way, though
federal officials say most programs are not active.
Source URL: http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/high-court-strikes-down-raisin-program-unconstitutional | T*********I
发帖数: 10729 | | b*****e
发帖数: 53215 | 8 这女劳模看样子就不像好人
【在 T*********I 的大作中提到】
: 8-1.
: SOTOMAYOR大法官太左了。
| f**********n
发帖数: 29853 | 9 she got this job because of Obama.
【在 b*****e 的大作中提到】
: 这女劳模看样子就不像好人
| S**C
发帖数: 2964 | 10 Yes it is indeed unbelievable.
It is also unbelievable that the Congress did not repeal that law after
nearly 80 years. I cannot decide which one is more astonishing and sad.
【在 T*********I 的大作中提到】
: 8-1.
: SOTOMAYOR大法官太左了。
| N*********6
发帖数: 2302 | 11 这是你在买提Debut 的第一贴么？
【在 f**********n 的大作中提到】
: she got this job because of Obama.
|
|
