由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
USANews版 - European Media Calls George W. Bush Visionary
相关主题
Ennahdha Founder Attacked at “Tolerance in Islam” ConferenceWould Obama Retaliate against a Nuclear Attack?
Jeb看来是厚道人Michelle Obama and the Muslim Brotherhood
政治问题很复杂,不幸是一般有效的solution只能黑白'Democratic' Arab Spring Becoming an Islamist Arab Winter
独裁者的财富为何最后化为泡影?(一)Pakistani Textbooks Teach Discrimination Against Non-Muslims, Says U.S. Commission
我来自伊朗,让我告诉你sharia law有多可怕!Deconstructing Islam's Template of Perfection
索马里伊斯兰武装处死2个在自己家看世界杯足球赛的平民Hamas High School in Florida?
荷兰反伊斯兰议员Geert Wilder在国会演讲中向首相喊话爱一个贱Man需要理由吗?
Ann Barnhardt Fights Totalitarian Islam and Its Useful IdiotsHow Honest of a Cross-Section Is "All-American Muslim?"
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: bush话题: george话题: islamic话题: regimes话题: people
进入USANews版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
l****z
发帖数: 29846
1
by Rachel Marsden
02/20/2011
A new article in Der Spiegel magazine—the German equivalent of Time or
Newsweek—applauds George W. Bush for his vision of democracy in the Middle
East, and credits him for the fact that authoritarian regimes in the region
are being kicked to the curb.
"Painful as it may be to admit, it was the despised former U.S. President
George W. Bush who believed in the democratization of the Muslim world and
incurred the scorn and mockery of the Left for his conviction," says the
piece by Jan Fleischhauer.
Hear that? That's the sound of bowls full of Whole Foods organic granola
smashing to the ground. Before we get carried away and cause people to dive
off bridges as a result of having to think of George W. Bush as a Nobel
Peace Prize candidate, let's consider some reasons presented by various
sources so far as to why Bush may not, in fact, be responsible for the
tsunami of change we're currently witnessing in Islamic nations.
1. The wave of change started in Africa, with the people of the Ivory Coast
elections in December 2010 refusing to allow permanent fixture President
Laurent Gbagbo to stay in power after losing democratic elections to rival
Alassane Ouattara. The people rioted until he left, during which the UN
reported hundreds of arrests, dozens of murders, and significant torture by
Gbagbo's men. This was arguably the spark that ignited the whole region:
Just a democratic election in which someone refused to rightfully vacate his
seat. Days later, the people of nearby Tunisia seem to have decided that
their guy, Ben Ali, had been in power long enough (23 years) and wasn't
likely to leave of his own volition. So they gave him a bit of a shove.
2. George W. Bush may have said he had a vision of Islamic democracy, but
what he really meant was that it was a side-effect of avenging his dad in
the wake of the Gulf War. Kind of like when so-called do-gooders volunteer
to be candy stripers in hospitals, not because they enjoy giving of
themselves to people suffering, but rather because they like that sweet
discount they get on the cafeteria food.
3. Bush didn't "show a man how to fish." He reached into the swamp, pulled
out the shark with his bare hands, and hanged it in a secure facility north
of Baghdad. You're not supposed to do that. You're supposed to wait until
the locals figure it out. But would the other Islamic countries living
under authoritarianism have figured it out on their own—or was Iraq an
icebreaker?
4. Bush didn't invade Saudia Arabia. Or Iran. Or strap himself onto the
back of a rocket and take care of business himself like in Dr. Strangelove.
So he clearly didn't do enough!
5. War doesn't create peace. Naive kids in floppy blue hats traipsing
around in conflict zones create peace and change. Through joy and smiles,
silly.
6. The Internet did it. (LOLZ!) Keyboard warriors making FaceBook pages/
groups and Twittering viciously caused real-world dictators with guns,
weapons, and armies to capitulate. (LMAO!)
Theories abound, but there was only one man in recent memory who actively
leveled the field, in the legitimate opening provided by the September 11
attacks, to give the seed of democracy a chance in both the Islamic nations
of Afghanistan and Iraq. And he did it for one very clear reason from Day 1
, and which he still repeats: To provide a beacon of democracy in the
Middle East, an example for others to follow. Maybe that hope is indeed
playing a factor in the collapse of the regimes we're currently witnessing.
Or maybe it's just a total coincidence that the interests of the average
person in the region are now directly aligned with Bush's vision and actions
, for which he has been—and is still—horribly maligned. If people are
willing to credit silly Internet entries of 140 characters each for such
massive change, then perhaps we can agree that it would be reasonable to
acknowledge the efforts of a President whose entire mandate was focused in
part on this phenomenon coming to fruition.
One thing that Bush can no longer be criticized for is "making things worse"
in the region—unless one believes that people overthrowing authoritarian
regimes on their own is a bad development. What ends up replacing these
governments is another issue—but the opportunity is now there for them to
not blow. Nor do I care to hear a peep from current or former EU leaders
who profited from exclusive trade relationships with these dictatorial
regimes (Chirac—good luck in your corruption trial this year), while either
sitting on their hands during Bush's active efforts or criticizing his
vision outright.
Then there are those who take it a step further and accept flights and
vacations provided by this same type of paper tiger dictator in Egypt (
former French Prime Minister Francois Fillon) and Tunisia (French Foreign
Affairs Minister Michele Alliot-Marie and her junior government minister
husband, Who F. Cares), apparently not noticing or caring that crawling into
the dumpster might in fact result in being taken out to the dump along with
the trash.
Much like George W. Bush, I suppose I can still dream.
1 (共1页)
进入USANews版参与讨论
相关主题
How Honest of a Cross-Section Is "All-American Muslim?"我来自伊朗,让我告诉你sharia law有多可怕!
Islamism at UCLA Law School索马里伊斯兰武装处死2个在自己家看世界杯足球赛的平民
埃及被民主害惨了?荷兰反伊斯兰议员Geert Wilder在国会演讲中向首相喊话
马来西亚伊斯兰政府警告:情人节与伊斯兰信仰不合,可能会引来安拉的烈怒Ann Barnhardt Fights Totalitarian Islam and Its Useful Idiots
Ennahdha Founder Attacked at “Tolerance in Islam” ConferenceWould Obama Retaliate against a Nuclear Attack?
Jeb看来是厚道人Michelle Obama and the Muslim Brotherhood
政治问题很复杂,不幸是一般有效的solution只能黑白'Democratic' Arab Spring Becoming an Islamist Arab Winter
独裁者的财富为何最后化为泡影?(一)Pakistani Textbooks Teach Discrimination Against Non-Muslims, Says U.S. Commission
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: bush话题: george话题: islamic话题: regimes话题: people