c**i
发帖数: 6973 | 1 【 以下文字转载自 ChinaNews 讨论区 】
发信人: choi (choi), 信区: ChinaNews
标 题: Hans in China's North and South Are Distinct
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sat Feb 23 14:04:22 2008)
(1) For the lay persons who don't understand biology
David Brown, Genetic Mutations Offer Insights on Human Diversity. Washington
Post, February 22, 2008, Page A05
A quote: "The Hazara of Afghanistan and Pakistan and the Uygur of
northwestern China are also close genetic relatives, despite living far
apart. On the other hand, China's dominant ethn | O****o
发帖数: 502 | 2 this is interesting
Washington
【在 c**i 的大作中提到】
: 【 以下文字转载自 ChinaNews 讨论区 】
: 发信人: choi (choi), 信区: ChinaNews
: 标 题: Hans in China's North and South Are Distinct
: 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sat Feb 23 14:04:22 2008)
: (1) For the lay persons who don't understand biology
: David Brown, Genetic Mutations Offer Insights on Human Diversity. Washington
: Post, February 22, 2008, Page A05
: A quote: "The Hazara of Afghanistan and Pakistan and the Uygur of
: northwestern China are also close genetic relatives, despite living far
: apart. On the other hand, China's dominant ethn
| O****o
发帖数: 502 | 3 where may I find the original scientific paper?
a newspaper article is nothing..
Washington
【在 c**i 的大作中提到】
: 【 以下文字转载自 ChinaNews 讨论区 】
: 发信人: choi (choi), 信区: ChinaNews
: 标 题: Hans in China's North and South Are Distinct
: 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sat Feb 23 14:04:22 2008)
: (1) For the lay persons who don't understand biology
: David Brown, Genetic Mutations Offer Insights on Human Diversity. Washington
: Post, February 22, 2008, Page A05
: A quote: "The Hazara of Afghanistan and Pakistan and the Uygur of
: northwestern China are also close genetic relatives, despite living far
: apart. On the other hand, China's dominant ethn
| O****o
发帖数: 502 | 4 1998年就被人发现了，怎么现在还有人当新鲜故事讲？haha
Washington
【在 c**i 的大作中提到】
: 【 以下文字转载自 ChinaNews 讨论区 】
: 发信人: choi (choi), 信区: ChinaNews
: 标 题: Hans in China's North and South Are Distinct
: 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sat Feb 23 14:04:22 2008)
: (1) For the lay persons who don't understand biology
: David Brown, Genetic Mutations Offer Insights on Human Diversity. Washington
: Post, February 22, 2008, Page A05
: A quote: "The Hazara of Afghanistan and Pakistan and the Uygur of
: northwestern China are also close genetic relatives, despite living far
: apart. On the other hand, China's dominant ethn
| c**i
发帖数: 6973 | 5 Yesterday I provided enough clues for others to look for whatever I referred
to. Unfortunately, Mitbbs.com does not allow me to provide you with a
direct link.
In the next posting, you said "1998年就被人发现了" without any citation. You
can decide after reading the Science paper. The rules in scientific
publications is author must point out previous relevant research. Besides,
reviewers are supposed to be experts in the field who know something even if
authors fail to say so.
In my opinion, you are mer
【在 O****o 的大作中提到】
: where may I find the original scientific paper?
: a newspaper article is nothing..
:
: Washington
| c**i
发帖数: 6973 | 6 I am not the author of the newly punlished Science paper. And it is not my
business to defend it.
I simply think you are dead wrong.
(1) I suggest you go reading the paper you recommended.
(a) J. Y. Chu et al, Genetic relationship of populations in China. Proc. Nat
. Acad. Sci. Vol. 95, Issue 20, 11763-11768, September 29, 1998.
There was an accompnaying commentary 95: 11501 which did not even mention
what you thought it said.
(2) I remind you that the paper you recommended was published in 1998
【在 c**i 的大作中提到】
: Yesterday I provided enough clues for others to look for whatever I referred
: to. Unfortunately, Mitbbs.com does not allow me to provide you with a
: direct link.
: In the next posting, you said "1998年就被人发现了" without any citation. You
: can decide after reading the Science paper. The rules in scientific
: publications is author must point out previous relevant research. Besides,
: reviewers are supposed to be experts in the field who know something even if
: authors fail to say so.
: In my opinion, you are mer
| c**i
发帖数: 6973 | 7 What does the quote mean? It says that the complete DNA sequence of a person | H****n
发帖数: 125 | 8 So, what, Han Chinese is never a race concept, rather a culture concept. | c**i
发帖数: 6973 | 9 Your definition includes a few, say, Americans (white and balck)--and
possibly former Singapore prime minister, Mr. Lee kuan-yew. Depending on how
are define the "cultural."
【在 H****n 的大作中提到】
: So, what, Han Chinese is never a race concept, rather a culture concept.
|
|
