w******y
发帖数: 8040 | 1 声称我们虽然是少数民族, "属于"(打引号你懂得)该议案被照顾的对象
但我们更尊重所有美国人不分种族不分肤色的整体公平
所以我们要反对这个只照顾少数民族的议案, 即使我们作为少数民族是被照顾对象 |
t****u
发帖数: 8614 | 2 Good point!
还要考虑反对SCA5，实际上并不政治正确。而且如果华裔这么个政治上微小族群反对，
正好可以被政客用来当棋子，做利益交换。
【在 w******y 的大作中提到】
: 声称我们虽然是少数民族, "属于"(打引号你懂得)该议案被照顾的对象
: 但我们更尊重所有美国人不分种族不分肤色的整体公平
: 所以我们要反对这个只照顾少数民族的议案, 即使我们作为少数民族是被照顾对象
|
r****n
发帖数: 639 | 3 不觉得这么说有意思。
还有，为什么反对sca5 就政治不正确了？政治正不正确谁说了算？现有的法案都这么
多年了，就因为有人反对就忽然政治不正确了？
【在 t****u 的大作中提到】
: Good point!
: 还要考虑反对SCA5，实际上并不政治正确。而且如果华裔这么个政治上微小族群反对，
: 正好可以被政客用来当棋子，做利益交换。
|
w******x
发帖数: 2769 | 4 没有用, Asian不是underrepresented minorities |
l******u
发帖数: 1630 | 5 Then we should totally sue NBA NFL and American movie industry for the same
reason.
If you are stupid and you cant get in the college, doesn't mean the school
should lower the bar to let you in because your skin color.
If you are not strong and tough enough to fight the NFL games, doesn't mean
the league should lower the bar to let you in because your skin color.
【在 w******x 的大作中提到】
: 没有用, Asian不是underrepresented minorities
|
w******x
发帖数: 2769 | 6 Lol, I like your creativity!
same
mean
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 8.6
【在 l******u 的大作中提到】
: Then we should totally sue NBA NFL and American movie industry for the same
: reason.
: If you are stupid and you cant get in the college, doesn't mean the school
: should lower the bar to let you in because your skin color.
: If you are not strong and tough enough to fight the NFL games, doesn't mean
: the league should lower the bar to let you in because your skin color.
|
s*******e
发帖数: 4188 | 7 Without disagreeing with your view point, I just want to point out your
analogy is flawed. NBA etc are private industry. They are free to find the
best talent to maximize their profit. Higher education is a public resource
meant to provide equal opportunity to all people.
same
mean
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.8
【在 l******u 的大作中提到】
: Then we should totally sue NBA NFL and American movie industry for the same
: reason.
: If you are stupid and you cant get in the college, doesn't mean the school
: should lower the bar to let you in because your skin color.
: If you are not strong and tough enough to fight the NFL games, doesn't mean
: the league should lower the bar to let you in because your skin color.
|
p**m
发帖数: 3876 | 8 只有government entities还有federal contractor需要遵守AA，比如大军火商，为了
AA都不得不提拔少数族裔，女性进入管理层。
resource
【在 s*******e 的大作中提到】
: Without disagreeing with your view point, I just want to point out your
: analogy is flawed. NBA etc are private industry. They are free to find the
: best talent to maximize their profit. Higher education is a public resource
: meant to provide equal opportunity to all people.
:
: same
: mean
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.8
|
T******g
发帖数: 21328 | 9 well, public school is indeed open to every one. however there used to be
many factors when a school decide if extend an admission to an applicant.
unfortunately skin color will be one among them soon. too bad you call that
equal opportunity
resource
【在 s*******e 的大作中提到】
: Without disagreeing with your view point, I just want to point out your
: analogy is flawed. NBA etc are private industry. They are free to find the
: best talent to maximize their profit. Higher education is a public resource
: meant to provide equal opportunity to all people.
:
: same
: mean
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.8
|
d***e
发帖数: 1215 | 10 AA有没有意义，我觉得是有的，弱势群体是需要特别的帮助，就算主体民族也很有可能
在某些方面属于弱势群体，也需要帮助。
但是AA用错了地方，真正该用AA的地方是中小学。真要想打破阶层促进融合要先从打破
学区界限做起。
并且AA对族群划分也很不合理，真要合理AA,就该把犹太人划分出来，asian中也要把除
中日韩印外的各弱势民族单独划分出来。实际上AA最吃亏的不是华人，而是那些不幸跟
划分在asian的弱势亚洲人。 |
Q****r
发帖数: 7340 | 11 赞博爱
要不你自我灭绝给社会省点粮食？
【在 d***e 的大作中提到】
: AA有没有意义，我觉得是有的，弱势群体是需要特别的帮助，就算主体民族也很有可能
: 在某些方面属于弱势群体，也需要帮助。
: 但是AA用错了地方，真正该用AA的地方是中小学。真要想打破阶层促进融合要先从打破
: 学区界限做起。
: 并且AA对族群划分也很不合理，真要合理AA,就该把犹太人划分出来，asian中也要把除
: 中日韩印外的各弱势民族单独划分出来。实际上AA最吃亏的不是华人，而是那些不幸跟
: 划分在asian的弱势亚洲人。
|
