j****e
发帖数: 245 | 1 In honor of IssieStevens. :-)
It might be important to distinguish whether someone is unwilling vs. unable
to conduct him/herself in a certain way.
In addition, it is my "killjoy" opinion that it is NOT professional NOR
ethical to provide any diagnostic label to anyone without at least a
firsthand clinical interview. Maybe it is too serious a position to take on
a BBS board. Yet it is my position as a psychologist in training. :-) Thus I
reserve any comments regarding diagonstic issues.
On a fu |
r******s
发帖数: 2155 | 2 zan
unable
on
I
【在 j****e 的大作中提到】
: In honor of IssieStevens. :-)
: It might be important to distinguish whether someone is unwilling vs. unable
: to conduct him/herself in a certain way.
: In addition, it is my "killjoy" opinion that it is NOT professional NOR
: ethical to provide any diagnostic label to anyone without at least a
: firsthand clinical interview. Maybe it is too serious a position to take on
: a BBS board. Yet it is my position as a psychologist in training. :-) Thus I
: reserve any comments regarding diagonstic issues.
: On a fu
|
h*i
发帖数: 3446 | 3 Please forgive me for what I am about to say, but it has to be said.
First, this is a BBS board where people freely express their opinions.
Anyone's making or not making a "diagnosis" carries ZERO weight whatsoever
on the state of affair. Therefore, there's nothing about professionalism or
ethics to speak about. Your opinion is just as good as the next person who
makes a post. It's kinda silly to take one's own opinion too seriously just
because one is a psychologist in the real life.
Second,
【在 j****e 的大作中提到】
: In honor of IssieStevens. :-)
: It might be important to distinguish whether someone is unwilling vs. unable
: to conduct him/herself in a certain way.
: In addition, it is my "killjoy" opinion that it is NOT professional NOR
: ethical to provide any diagnostic label to anyone without at least a
: firsthand clinical interview. Maybe it is too serious a position to take on
: a BBS board. Yet it is my position as a psychologist in training. :-) Thus I
: reserve any comments regarding diagonstic issues.
: On a fu
|
I**********s
发帖数: 1573 | 4 O thanks! I was just asking questions, definitely not trying to lable him. I
'm just very interested in Cho's case coz I think it should be a good case
study for the mental health profession.
unable
on
I
【在 j****e 的大作中提到】
: In honor of IssieStevens. :-)
: It might be important to distinguish whether someone is unwilling vs. unable
: to conduct him/herself in a certain way.
: In addition, it is my "killjoy" opinion that it is NOT professional NOR
: ethical to provide any diagnostic label to anyone without at least a
: firsthand clinical interview. Maybe it is too serious a position to take on
: a BBS board. Yet it is my position as a psychologist in training. :-) Thus I
: reserve any comments regarding diagonstic issues.
: On a fu
|
j****e
发帖数: 245 | 5
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ None taken. It is just a
personal position I am taking. There is no implication to others. :-)
【在 h*i 的大作中提到】
: Please forgive me for what I am about to say, but it has to be said.
: First, this is a BBS board where people freely express their opinions.
: Anyone's making or not making a "diagnosis" carries ZERO weight whatsoever
: on the state of affair. Therefore, there's nothing about professionalism or
: ethics to speak about. Your opinion is just as good as the next person who
: makes a post. It's kinda silly to take one's own opinion too seriously just
: because one is a psychologist in the real life.
: Second,
|
j****e
发帖数: 245 | 6 someone interested in psychology. It surely is a fascinating field.
I |
