h****t
发帖数: 632 | 1 Storming the Palace in Political Science
Scholars join revolt against the domination of mathematical approaches to
the discipline
By D.W. MILLER
San Francisco
The revolution was scheduled to begin at 10 p.m. in Continental Parlor 2,
but some people came early.
By 10:15, the population of the small, windowless conference room at the San
Francisco Hilton |
k***g
发帖数: 7244 | 2 呵呵，主要是 APSR 的问题啊，其他的 Journal 象 Int'l Organization, World
Politics 什么的balance的挺好的呀。我觉得过分 mathematicization 的是美国政治
，国际关系的 mathematicization 还不够，呵呵。
San
【在 h****t 的大作中提到】
: Storming the Palace in Political Science
: Scholars join revolt against the domination of mathematical approaches to
: the discipline
: By D.W. MILLER
: San Francisco
: The revolution was scheduled to begin at 10 p.m. in Continental Parlor 2,
: but some people came early.
: By 10:15, the population of the small, windowless conference room at the San
: Francisco Hilton
|
w***t
发帖数: 404 | 3 其实就是搞政治斗争。最近几十年没看出那一派对现实政治提出了有力的解释。基本是
都是自吹自擂。
将
【在 h****t 的大作中提到】
: Storming the Palace in Political Science
: Scholars join revolt against the domination of mathematical approaches to
: the discipline
: By D.W. MILLER
: San Francisco
: The revolution was scheduled to begin at 10 p.m. in Continental Parlor 2,
: but some people came early.
: By 10:15, the population of the small, windowless conference room at the San
: Francisco Hilton
|
h****t
发帖数: 632 | 4 此言不虚.如果要balance的话,光搞这样的运动可能还不够,需要有人用非数学的方法将
政治学的的发展和新方向推进,或者对一些重大问题提出令人信服的解释.
该运动2000发起,01年也有些动静，但不知近况如何了。
http://chronicle.com/colloquylive/2001/09/perestroika/
The Perestroika Movement in Political Science
Wednesday, September 19 at 1 p.m. U.S. Eastern time, 5 p.m. Greenwich Mean
Time
Has the "Perestroika" movement of dissident political scientists made
significant progress in overhauling the discipline? Do scholars with
mathematical approaches continue to dominate political science at the
dep |
w***t
发帖数: 404 | 5 看job market， 搞game theory和stats的有优势，特别是top 20的学校。
治
【在 k***g 的大作中提到】
: 呵呵，主要是 APSR 的问题啊，其他的 Journal 象 Int'l Organization, World
: Politics 什么的balance的挺好的呀。我觉得过分 mathematicization 的是美国政治
: ，国际关系的 mathematicization 还不够，呵呵。
:
: San
|
s******1
发帖数: 239 | 6 2000年发起的运动？好像从出版物和方法训练等方面，已经有比较多的平衡了吧？
San
【在 h****t 的大作中提到】
: Storming the Palace in Political Science
: Scholars join revolt against the domination of mathematical approaches to
: the discipline
: By D.W. MILLER
: San Francisco
: The revolution was scheduled to begin at 10 p.m. in Continental Parlor 2,
: but some people came early.
: By 10:15, the population of the small, windowless conference room at the San
: Francisco Hilton
|
a******o
发帖数: 1197 | 7 搞自己最comfortable的，任何方法做到极致都是牛比的
刊
【在 s******1 的大作中提到】
: 2000年发起的运动？好像从出版物和方法训练等方面，已经有比较多的平衡了吧？
:
: San
|
