PRL审稿换了6个referee了 - Physics版 - 未名存档

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档，一周内的贴子最多显示50字，超过一周显示500字访问原贴

Physics版 - PRL审稿换了6个referee了

相关主题
● PRL在editors 手里9天了，什么情况？
● 多灾多难的文章
● 请问PRL审稿状态中editor concludes response unlikely是什么意思呢？
● 初次投PRL
● prl状态求助，query to referee
● 请问三个审稿人， PRL编辑只送给我们两个报告，请问是什么原因？
● PRL 稿件状态
● 这篇PRL是怎么回事？都好几天了
● Help for PRL MS status
● 到底几个审稿人?

相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: referee话题: review话题: received话题: request话题: sent

进入Physics版参与讨论

1

(共1页)

l*****z 发帖数: 442	1 SENT RECEIVED DESCRIPTION 02Aug11 Review request to referee; response not yet received 02Aug11 Review request to referee; response not yet received 28Jul11 29Jul11 Reminder to referee; response received 15Jul11 27Jul11 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) 12Jul11 14Jul11 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) 14Jul11 Review request to referee; response not yet received 12Jul11 13Jul11 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) 13Jul11 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 13Jul11 Right to publish signature received 12Jul11 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 08Jul11 Corr. to author (paper long; short version NOT required now) 08Jul11 Acknowledgment sent to author 05Jul11 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 头一次遇到这么多referee不审的。
V***V 发帖数: 23	2 你牛啊，把referee都震住了，不敢说话。
l*****z 发帖数: 442	3 我怀疑可能是这文章可能比较marginal，他们都不知道怎么下结论。
p*******g 发帖数: 2976	4 你太牛了。。。没人敢惹。
t****a 发帖数: 3544	5 是不是教授都放假了，去享受生活了【在 l*****z 的大作中提到】 : SENT RECEIVED DESCRIPTION : 02Aug11 Review request to referee; response not yet received : 02Aug11 Review request to referee; response not yet received : 28Jul11 29Jul11 Reminder to referee; response received : 15Jul11 27Jul11 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) : 12Jul11 14Jul11 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) : 14Jul11 Review request to referee; response not yet received : 12Jul11 13Jul11 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) : 13Jul11 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author : 13Jul11 Right to publish signature received
a********n 发帖数: 50	6 题目太难了，读不懂吧
m********a 发帖数: 12601	7 其实也还好，REFEREE第二天就据了审稿我以前遇到过REFEREE等了14天以后才据掉审稿的
t******n 发帖数: 73	8 这样的REFEREE就是垃圾！【在 m********a 的大作中提到】 : 其实也还好，REFEREE第二天就据了审稿 : 我以前遇到过REFEREE等了14天以后才据掉审稿的

V***V 发帖数: 23	9 俺碰到过更jp的，过了一个月才据审，当时同时送的另一审稿人都给出意见了。【在 t******n 的大作中提到】 : 这样的REFEREE就是垃圾！
e**********n 发帖数: 359	10 不错了，每等上两个月来个 not a report 运气就不错了。

1

(共1页)

进入Physics版参与讨论

相关主题
● 到底几个审稿人?
● 大家帮我看看怎么回事？PRL二审状态（接收啦）
● prl文章送审了
● 兄弟们帮我看看这是不是意味着秒杀啊？
● prl的editor是疯了吗
● PRL 状态
● 求问PRL状态
● PRL二审意见返回给编辑，编辑query to referee
● PRB 投稿的麻烦，请教
● 该不该催？ (转载)

相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: referee话题: review话题: received话题: request话题: sent