boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Physics版 - referee 的回信, 对我转专业的回复
相关主题
和REFEREE 讨论工作和转行的事情会有什么后果 (转载)
和REFEREE 讨论转行, 得到如下回复, 是啥意思
需要推荐审一些文章
Review request to referee; report received 是什么呢?
prl的editor是疯了吗
看看某学霸怎么回REVIEWER的
referee are unable to report
PRL审稿经历证明
PRL 状态
PNAS 投稿问题 (转载)
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: your话题: best话题: sorry话题: more话题: anonymous
进入Physics版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
t**j
发帖数: 198
1
他最后说Sorry that I cannot be any more helpful.
Best wishes,
your anonymous reviewer.
是啥意思
Dear ,
I checked your publication record and found a new paper online .
Apparently this is a new area for you, different from what you were
doing in graduate school and
from the topic of the paper I was reviewing; if you are interested in
it and would like to continue
doing similar things, you probably should look for research or
teaching positions at some places
where there is an emphasis on THIS theory.
On the other hand, you seem to be a young person, so if you feel like
you are interested in some
other field more, it is certainly not too late to
study for another degree.
I have no way of figuring out whether or not you are going to be more
successful and happier
in this new endeavor than you are now in your current position, and
whether it will be as you put it
"conductive to your original goals", whatever they are.
Sorry that I cannot be any more helpful.
Best wishes,
your anonymous reviewer.
***
C********n
发帖数: 6682
2
婉拒

【在 t**j 的大作中提到】
: 他最后说Sorry that I cannot be any more helpful.
: Best wishes,
: your anonymous reviewer.
: 是啥意思
: Dear ,
: I checked your publication record and found a new paper online .
: Apparently this is a new area for you, different from what you were
: doing in graduate school and
: from the topic of the paper I was reviewing; if you are interested in
: it and would like to continue

t**j
发帖数: 198
3
婉拒啥
拒绝暴露身份吗
k**l
发帖数: 1937
4
白痴太多啊,

【在 t**j 的大作中提到】
: 他最后说Sorry that I cannot be any more helpful.
: Best wishes,
: your anonymous reviewer.
: 是啥意思
: Dear ,
: I checked your publication record and found a new paper online .
: Apparently this is a new area for you, different from what you were
: doing in graduate school and
: from the topic of the paper I was reviewing; if you are interested in
: it and would like to continue

e********y
发帖数: 935
5
你看不懂英文么

【在 t**j 的大作中提到】
: 他最后说Sorry that I cannot be any more helpful.
: Best wishes,
: your anonymous reviewer.
: 是啥意思
: Dear ,
: I checked your publication record and found a new paper online .
: Apparently this is a new area for you, different from what you were
: doing in graduate school and
: from the topic of the paper I was reviewing; if you are interested in
: it and would like to continue

1 (共1页)
进入Physics版参与讨论
相关主题
PNAS 投稿问题 (转载)
一篇普通prb article, 三个referees?
请教一下网络刊物采访Arxiv上的稿子
大家帮我看看怎么回事?PRL二审状态(接收啦)
求一篇文章,谢谢!
郁闷中。。。
投PRE一般多长时间会有回应阿。
message received (not a report)什么意思?
一篇在审 的文章
组织一下每周末的物理讨论吧。
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: your话题: best话题: sorry话题: more话题: anonymous