d**********u
发帖数: 4124 | 1 ☆─────────────────────────────────────☆
yuanfeiwo (原非我|梨园深) 于 (Tue Jun 16 17:05:09 2009, 美东) 提到:
偶然在AJODO(American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics,就是牙齿正畸学的最好的杂志，相当于化学的JACS)上发现这样一篇文章：
Comparison of Chinese and US orthodontists' averaged evaluations of "facial attractiveness" from end-of-treatment facial photographs
第一作者是北大正畸科的一个中国人，后面的名字都是美国人，单位是美国某dental school。
只是觉得很好玩，通过患者照片对比和医生的打分，结论似乎是说美国正畸医生和中国正畸医生对facial attractiveness的判定高度一致。
Introduction:
This study continues our assessment of agreement and disagreement among 25 Chinese and 20 US orthodontists in the ranking for facial attractiveness of end-of-treatment photographs of randomly sampled growing Chinese and white orthodontic patients. Th
n aims of this article were to (1) measure the overall pattern of agreement between the mean rankings of US and Chinese orthodontists, and (2) measure the strength of agreement between the rankings of the US and Chinese orthodontists for each patient
Results: The overall agreement between the mean rankings of the US and
Chinese judges was very high.
Conclusions: These findings demonstrate that orthodontic clinicians can
reliably identify and rank subtle differences between patients, and that differences between judges and between patients can be distinguished at a high level of statistical significance, given appropriate study designs. However, the reasons clinician
e for the differences in their judgments are more difficult to investigate and
will require further study.
☆─────────────────────────────────────☆
prettyday (美丽的日子) 于 (Tue Jun 16 22:09:31 2009, 美东) 提到:
这个paper好玩的玩点在于？推翻了国人从美国人认为中国人认为的丑女漂亮得出的中
美审美不一致的结论？
就是牙齿正畸学的最好的杂志，相当于化学的JACS)上发现这样一篇文章：
facial attractiveness" from end-of-treatment facial photographs
school。
国正畸医生对facial attractiveness的判定高度一致。
Chinese and 20 US orthodontists in the ranking for facial attractiveness of
end-of-treatment photographs of randomly sampled growing Chinese and white
orthodontic patients. Th
differences between judges and between patients can be distinguished at a
high level of statistical significance, given appropriate study designs.
However, the reasons clinician
☆─────────────────────────────────────☆
handsomex (潇潇细雨) 于 (Tue Jun 16 22:29:36 2009, 美东) 提到:
赞
dental
25
of
white
☆─────────────────────────────────────☆
BenW (Ben) 于 (Thu Jun 18 11:29:40 2009, 美东) 提到:
en. such works can be outsourced to China. Chinese doctors have the same 审
美 as those in US. |
|
