m****g
发帖数: 225 | |
p*****d
发帖数: 237 | |
D********e
发帖数: 475 | 3 I had to stop watching it after 40 minutes. There is nothing interesting
there.
【在 p*****d 的大作中提到】
: 我也刚看完，真难看呀。
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 4 One gets who s/he is from the film.
It is soul soup, not eye candy.
【在 D********e 的大作中提到】
: I had to stop watching it after 40 minutes. There is nothing interesting
: there.
|
r****y
发帖数: 26819 | 5 前边有人说过张艺谋刚开始接着原作的好本子，红了几个片子。后来没本子就彻底萎了。
要说没本子，牯岭街没有本子吧？配角能看出戏的立体感来。好的片子，配角有自己的
线索，不是为了苍白映衬主角才存在，鲜明可爱。
山楂树这片子，主角的情节在一个层次上单调重复，翻来覆去表现男主角如何心细体贴，
两个小时里，配角空间都没了。就不去跟活着比，就跟本子很差很狗血的唐山大地震比
吧，都是怀旧题材，大地震的配角比山楂树里的给人印象深，主角也比山楂树出彩。
张艺谋这一锅soul soup，比较象白开水。
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: One gets who s/he is from the film.
: It is soul soup, not eye candy.
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 6 Again, you get who you are from the film. You might want to find eye candy
from it, but it is not. And obviously it is not your soul soup. Just that
simple.
了。
比，
【在 r****y 的大作中提到】
: 前边有人说过张艺谋刚开始接着原作的好本子，红了几个片子。后来没本子就彻底萎了。
: 要说没本子，牯岭街没有本子吧？配角能看出戏的立体感来。好的片子，配角有自己的
: 线索，不是为了苍白映衬主角才存在，鲜明可爱。
: 山楂树这片子，主角的情节在一个层次上单调重复，翻来覆去表现男主角如何心细体贴，
: 两个小时里，配角空间都没了。就不去跟活着比，就跟本子很差很狗血的唐山大地震比
: 吧，都是怀旧题材，大地震的配角比山楂树里的给人印象深，主角也比山楂树出彩。
: 张艺谋这一锅soul soup，比较象白开水。
|
h*********n
发帖数: 5789 | 7 嗯，心灵鸡汤，这个词“读者”上面比较流行
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: One gets who s/he is from the film.
: It is soul soup, not eye candy.
|
r****y
发帖数: 26819 | 8 这几句泛泛的话用来评价什么片子都可以。
比如：烂片只不过不是大多数人的soul soup罢了。大多数人也许想从烂片里找eye
candy。就这么简单，所以，没有烂片。
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: Again, you get who you are from the film. You might want to find eye candy
: from it, but it is not. And obviously it is not your soul soup. Just that
: simple.
:
: 了。
: 比，
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 9 没有烂片 is as correct as "all are 烂片". As I said, one only gets who s/he
is from a film. This film is just not your type.
【在 r****y 的大作中提到】
: 这几句泛泛的话用来评价什么片子都可以。
: 比如：烂片只不过不是大多数人的soul soup罢了。大多数人也许想从烂片里找eye
: candy。就这么简单，所以，没有烂片。
|
h*********n
发帖数: 5789 | 10 you know, I don't like shit at all, but some ppl does
he
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: 没有烂片 is as correct as "all are 烂片". As I said, one only gets who s/he
: is from a film. This film is just not your type.
|
|
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 11 Well, the truth is your favorite food might be shit in others' eyes as well.
The whole point is to take all comments on a film as individual, personal
feelings. One's feeling means little for others. No one should force others
to hate or love a film.
【在 h*********n 的大作中提到】
: you know, I don't like shit at all, but some ppl does
:
: he
|
h*********n
发帖数: 5789 | 12 then why you forced me to love your "soul soup"?
well.
others
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: Well, the truth is your favorite food might be shit in others' eyes as well.
: The whole point is to take all comments on a film as individual, personal
: feelings. One's feeling means little for others. No one should force others
: to hate or love a film.
|
r****y
发帖数: 26819 | 13 评论看过的电影，不是踩别人的尾巴。不是我那杯茶，照样可以说理由。如果正好说中
了你那杯，别介意，不是针对你。可以一起说理由，别以茶取人。不是非要和你喝同一杯
才能说话。
he
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: 没有烂片 is as correct as "all are 烂片". As I said, one only gets who s/he
: is from a film. This film is just not your type.
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 14 Did I? Didn't I say that "all are 烂片" because I know some people don't
like this one?
【在 h*********n 的大作中提到】
: then why you forced me to love your "soul soup"?
:
: well.
: others
|
h*********n
发帖数: 5789 | 15 you should learn to respect other ppl's opinion.
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: Did I? Didn't I say that "all are 烂片" because I know some people don't
: like this one?
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 16 I just feel sorry for those who just "wasted" 90 minutes on a film that they
cannot get any positive stuff. It is a real waste of time. Even from an
average film, I believe we still can get something good.
一杯
【在 r****y 的大作中提到】
: 评论看过的电影，不是踩别人的尾巴。不是我那杯茶，照样可以说理由。如果正好说中
: 了你那杯，别介意，不是针对你。可以一起说理由，别以茶取人。不是非要和你喝同一杯
: 才能说话。
:
: he
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 17 Yes. I really should have not followed someone to use that sh*t word.
【在 h*********n 的大作中提到】
: you should learn to respect other ppl's opinion.
|
r****y
发帖数: 26819 | 18 你不是反复说了每个人只能从电影里看到自己吗？别人怎么看电影，和你有啥关系？
只不过别人喝了一杯茶，觉得不是自己的那杯罢了。
难道你喝的每一杯都是你自己的那杯？只喝对胃口的茶才不叫浪费时间？呵呵
they
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: I just feel sorry for those who just "wasted" 90 minutes on a film that they
: cannot get any positive stuff. It is a real waste of time. Even from an
: average film, I believe we still can get something good.
:
: 一杯
|
h*********n
发帖数: 5789 | 19 yeah, I believe you still can get something good from shit.
they
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: I just feel sorry for those who just "wasted" 90 minutes on a film that they
: cannot get any positive stuff. It is a real waste of time. Even from an
: average film, I believe we still can get something good.
:
: 一杯
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 20 To me, if I can not get anything good but negative feelings about the
director, the actors, and the film overall, it is indeed a waste of time.
You might have different opinions. I just don't understand why people spend
time to get bad things.
【在 r****y 的大作中提到】
: 你不是反复说了每个人只能从电影里看到自己吗？别人怎么看电影，和你有啥关系？
: 只不过别人喝了一杯茶，觉得不是自己的那杯罢了。
: 难道你喝的每一杯都是你自己的那杯？只喝对胃口的茶才不叫浪费时间？呵呵
:
: they
|
|
|
B**W
发帖数: 2273 | 21 But maybe better than someone who always gets shit from whatever.
【在 h*********n 的大作中提到】
: yeah, I believe you still can get something good from shit.
:
: they
|
h*********n
发帖数: 5789 | 22 如果没有你们这些人上窜下跳的说某部电影怎么怎么好，我至于浪费两个小时吗。靠，
老子看了烂片不爽，还不能说了。什么玩意啊。
spend
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: To me, if I can not get anything good but negative feelings about the
: director, the actors, and the film overall, it is indeed a waste of time.
: You might have different opinions. I just don't understand why people spend
: time to get bad things.
|
r****y
发帖数: 26819 | 23 你不是在乎别人怎么会浪费时间看一点不喜欢的电影。你是在乎别人不喜欢的正好是你
那杯茶。既然每人看电影就是看出自己，反正不喜欢的肯定不喜欢，这杯茶喝一口还是
喝光了无关紧要。非要觉得这很重要，不好理解，慢慢理解吧。
spend
【在 B**W 的大作中提到】
: To me, if I can not get anything good but negative feelings about the
: director, the actors, and the film overall, it is indeed a waste of time.
: You might have different opinions. I just don't understand why people spend
: time to get bad things.
|
r****y
发帖数: 26819 | 24 哈哈，我打赌你换一部片子说，她就没意见了。
【在 h*********n 的大作中提到】
: 如果没有你们这些人上窜下跳的说某部电影怎么怎么好，我至于浪费两个小时吗。靠，
: 老子看了烂片不爽，还不能说了。什么玩意啊。
:
: spend
|
a******w
发帖数: 774 | |
