由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Military版 - 美媒:“神韵演出”广告掩盖其政治目的
相关主题
轮子V5无限的需求被挤压在有限的空间
授奖刘晓波“是个失误” (转载)法轮功吗? 中文怎么这么神奇
Falun Dafa is Good! Trump is Good!Chinese Americans for Trump这个口号,本来就是
US 'to give $1.5m to Falun Gong internet freedom group'汤姆克鲁斯说他不知道网上可以看黄片
轮子把Cisco给告了 (转载)芭蕾舞和裹小脚有什么区别????
FLG sued Chinese gov last time, now cisco's turn芭蕾舞欣赏《天鹅之死》
也说说方舟子的英文水平锁男到底承认不承认白人平均比中国人好看太多的事实
神韵晚会原来是这个东西啊普通中国人对欧美的舞蹈/音乐剧/戏剧文化知之甚少
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: falun话题: chinese话题: shen话题: yun话题: gong
进入Military版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
w*********r
发帖数: 42116
1
美国《旧金山之门》(San Francisco Gate)网站2018年12月22日发表文章指出,尽管
神韵广告铺天盖地,但实际演出内容与广告仍有很大不同。
https://news.toutiaoabc.com/newspark/view.php?app=news&act=view&nid=334567
报道内容没那么重要,看评论很有意思。
[11楼]评论人:全通[巡抚★★][个人频道][个人动态] 发送时间: 2018年12月28日 5:
58:06
这个可以自己上yelp去看评论。共党惯于颠倒黑白。
这条评论不错,就去看了一下。
https://www.yelp.com/topic/south-san-francisco-shen-yun-2018
Roast B.
Atlanta, GA
We just saw the show in San Francisco.
It was boring. Every dance was more or less the same. There wasn't any story
or Interesting theme. A lot of cultish propaganda was also thrown into the
performance. We walked out in the 2nd half and met other people walking out
also. We all felt ripped off after watching this show.
Lou S.
San Francisco, CA
I have seen it several times, loved it every time, and I am going to see it
again shortly. I thought every dance was different, with different
techniques displayed, different costumes, and different stories being
enacted through Chinese folk dancing.
There were, in fact, about 10 minutes worth of storytelling that related to
the treatment of the Falun Gong at the hands of the Chinese government. I
suppose that's what the OP means by "cultish propaganda." (Link to read
about the Falun Gong below.) I would not characterize 10 minutes out of a
two-hour show as "a lot." Nor were those 10 minutes particularly offensive.
They were more in the nature of informational in my opinion.
However, this is an art form. And not everybody likes the same kind of art.
See you at the show among the huge throngs of smiling faces! (And a few
Debbie Downers and sourpusses.)
Ruth N.
Kentfield, CA
I thought it was pretty awful. Absolutely and definitely not "
transformational" as the (seemingly endless) publicity would have you
believe. Some of the dancing was pretty, an occasional skit was amusing,
one of the musical numbers with the Chinese two-stringed instrument was very
nice, but mostly it was repetitive and schlocky. AND, definitely filled
with proselytizing of the very bizarre Falun Gong cult. Read a bit about
Falun Gong and the leader, and you will see what I mean. They are right up
there with the Scientologists with bizarre ideas. They are also homophobic
in the extreme. I don't think anyone doubts that the Chinese Communist
regime can be exceedingly repressive, but that doesn't mean the Falun Gong
movement are the heroes in this scenario. All in all, this was mostly just
tacky.
Valeriya V.
Albany, CA
We went to see Shen Yun Chinese dance in Berkeley. Their showcase looked
stunning and we decided to see the performance. Our tickets were expensive
and costed 300$. The dances were not as impressive as in the showcase. The
movements of dancers sometimes were not synchronized. There was not as much
acrobatics as in their video. The couple dances were devoted to describing
oppression of Falun Dafa followers in China. Then we listened to a song that
Darwin theory leads people to nowhere and Falun Dafa is right answer how to
live life. At the end we were shown banners that Falun Dafa is good. I
think the Shen Yun performance should be categorized as religion event that
preaches about Falun Dafa. If we knew about it we would not go.
Lou S.
San Francisco, CA
I enjoyed Shen Yun last night for the fourth time in the last five years. It
was terrific entertainment, and I look forward to seeing it again next year
and in the years to come.
Zellerbach Hall, on the Cal campus, which seats just under 2000, was filled
to capacity with excited theater-goers.
I went with four friends, all of whom thoroughly enjoyed the show. One of my
friends is a frequent theater-goer. Another is a ballet aficionado. They
both were very well entertained, and were impressed with the sophistication,
precision, and athleticism of the dancers--easily on a par with the best
ballet companies. All of my friends said they would like to see the show
again.
The costumes were intricate, varied, and colorful. The choreography and live
orchestral music was exciting, and there were many new aspects of the show
from years past.
I highly recommend Shen Yun!
Emma R.
Monrovia, CA
It is a big disappointment and paid for Chinese cult propaganda and will not
recommend it to anybody , paid 200$ for two ticket and like slot of
audience left in the middle of the performance because it becomes very
boring,cartoony and nothing of a Chinese acrobat show. I've been to Shanghai
and watch a 10$ Chinese acrobat show and it 10 times better than what they
are claiming, so do yourself a favor don't be persuaded Toby ticket for
H*****n
发帖数: 89
2
菌斑的轮子是不是表演被活摘的

【在 w*********r 的大作中提到】
: 美国《旧金山之门》(San Francisco Gate)网站2018年12月22日发表文章指出,尽管
: 神韵广告铺天盖地,但实际演出内容与广告仍有很大不同。
: https://news.toutiaoabc.com/newspark/view.php?app=news&act=view&nid=334567
: 报道内容没那么重要,看评论很有意思。
: [11楼]评论人:全通[巡抚★★][个人频道][个人动态] 发送时间: 2018年12月28日 5:
: 58:06
: 这个可以自己上yelp去看评论。共党惯于颠倒黑白。
: 这条评论不错,就去看了一下。
: https://www.yelp.com/topic/south-san-francisco-shen-yun-2018
: Roast B.

w*********r
发帖数: 42116
3
https://www.yelp.com/topic/seattle-shen-yun-dont-waste-your-time-or-money
L F.
Seattle, WA
I feel completely tricked. I thought I was buying tickets to a cultural
Chinese version of Cirque du Soleil. Instead it was a propaganda rich
recruiting technique for a cult called Falun Gong, with banners held up that
say Falun Gong is Good.... songs about the error of evolution.... it
involved ludicrous claims and a lot of waving of scarves. The numbers all
look similar, and the expected performances (such as images used in
advertising) never materialized. We almost left at intermission but
wondered what we might miss. The best part of the night was walking down
Mercer with fellow attendees who were making up songs and singing in mockery
, and teasing about Feng Shui. The masters of ceremonies, particularly
Oliver Perrett, presented stiffly and oddly..........wish I could get last
night back and use it some other way.
John B.
Mukilteo, WA
Shen Yun - don't bother going to this production! If you have tickets for
the Seattle production, my recommendation is to resell them. Every
production is sold out, so you will definitely be able to sell your tickets.
They do incredible marketing! The brochures read beautifully, and the
expectation was for incredible dancing, amazing music and a bit of
acrobatics. But what we got was lovely dancing that after the first 30
minutes began to repeat with different costumes. Some costumes were with
long sleeves that went out to be ribbons; others where the sleeves went out
to be squares, others that came out with fans, etc. etc. etc.. Then there
are the operatic singers that came out 3 times to spread the propaganda with
subtitles interpreting their message!!
We absolutely love the arts, we love live theater, live dance and music -
that's what drew us in. Don't take the bait!
This production is billed as a glance into 5000 years of Chinese culture. It
's really a platform for this group to proselytize their beliefs, and to be
paid top dollar for their performances to spread their beliefs. I could go
on for days, but trust me - it is not worth spending money on this
production. Enjoy a wonderful evening out at true theater, or a wonderful
concert.
Christine Y.
Mill Creek, WA
Well, the Chinese government has been persecuting or at least jailing Falung
Gong practitioners (and they happen to die from mistreatment while in
custody) so in some ways it is an accurate portrayal.. I'm in no way
endorsing the show. I knew their agenda (spread awareness of Falung Gong,
highlight the corruption of Chinese government, build a bigger following,
etc) so was never interested in the show, but, they're doing what they feel
they need to do under a repressive government regime. In order to practice
qigong. I mean, come on! Communist China is scary as heck.
b********l
发帖数: 123
4
咳,这种广告要么是轮子发的,要么是轮子赞助发的,正常人要真是信了,一定是傻了。
w*********r
发帖数: 42116
5
https://www.yelp.com/events/san-jose-shen-yun-performing-arts-2
w. s.
Menlo Park, CA
I attended Shen Yun two season ago with my then five-year-old child. Be
forwarned -- Divine Entertainment, Shen Yun's parent company, is a thinly
veiled arm of the Fallon Gong group. This alone would not stop one from
attending, accept that it is a purely propagandist piece, entirely
unsuitable for young children, and they are completely untruthful and
misleading about their content in all of their advertisements. It is amazing
to me that they have done as well as they have so far at fooling people...
including myself and my family. :(
See the following article:
Thomas C.
Palo Alto, CA
0 friends
16 reviews
I attended the San Jose performance this afternoon with my 4-year-old
daughter. I wanted to WARN PARENTS about attending this with young children
.
I was expecting this to be song and dance and lots of costumes, appropriate
for families. While there was indeed much of that, a good part of the show
was promoting Falun Gong. Several songs about religion. But more
disturbing - a dance sequence about a father, mother and little girl being
beaten up by the Chinese government and the mother being killed. I screen
all the movies my daughter watches (we worried about her watching Bambi when
she was younger because the mother got killed) - and I would have
appreciated a warning from the host/hostess who introduce each act to say "
this is not appropriate for young kids". There was a second dance sequence
near the end of the show about a man holding up a "Falun Gong is Good" sign
who also got beaten up on stage, which reminded my daughter of what she had
seen before intermission. She talked a lot about the "bad people" on the
way home (the people doing the beating up) which means it bothered her a
great deal.
I would have appreciated the show sticking to classical Chinese dance and
ethnic dances - which is what they promote - and keep the politics out of
the show. I will not be going to another one of these shows. The tickets
are expensive, you can see a lot of these performances done just as well on
Chinese television, and then you know it is really family programming.
Jaz D.
Little Rock, AR
0 friends
2 reviews
I have attended Shen Yun for the Past three years. Shen Yun is the most
beautiful show I have ever seen. I garentee this is the best show you will
ever see. It is wonderful for anybody and everybody!
Many people say that Shen Yun is very religious, I would like to tell you
about this. Shen Yun's mission is to revive the 5,000 years of Chinese
culture and history. History involves culture and also many times religion.
For example, you cannot study history without the people's religious
background because it affects the way they live. Falun Dafa is not a
religion, let me tell you that.
What I know about Falun Dafa (Also known as Falun Gong) is it is a peaceful
meditation that cultivates the mind, body, and spirit. They bace the three
principals of truthfullness, compassion, and forbearence. Today, in China,
the Chinese government tortures the people to death just because the don't
like too many people practicing this! and the Falun Dafa practitioners dont
even do anything to anyone! They just try to spread the truth that Falun
Dafa is really good, thats it. They do not force anybody to practice this if
the person doesn't want to.
Shen Yun puts Falun Dafa in this because this really is part of China's
History, which is Shen Yun's mission, to revive the 5,000 years of it's
history.
Shen Yun is the most beautiful show!! If there was an english word that is
better than the words beautiful and amazing then i'd use it! I LOVE the
costumes! They are all hand made by Shen Yun. I found out that the designer
of the movie Avatar, Robert Stromberg, saw Shen Yun and he thought he found
ideas for his next production.
Shen Yun also has the most beautiful music. It has an orchestra that
combines the classical and the Chinese Instruments hich is very unique that
no other production has ever did, and i doubt does. I love the erhu, which
is a classical Chinese intrument that has two strings-- very hard to play
but amazing!!
The backdrop, lights, music, choreography, and the costumes all tie together
, and they make the most wonderful performance humankind ever had! Five
stars! everyone should see!
w*********r
发帖数: 42116
6
有人评论说别带小孩子去看。

【在 H*****n 的大作中提到】
: 菌斑的轮子是不是表演被活摘的
b*********3
发帖数: 1709
7
终于看清了轮子的真实面目
S**********8
发帖数: 1
8
FLG followers are just stupid, they made up stories and numbers which made
them look very stupid, and all they want are targeting and taking revenge on
the people they think hurt them, they don't do anything good for the
society. Again, they are stupid!
b******s
发帖数: 2919
9
这帮左逼歧视中国文化呀。
百老汇的逼秀他们就能品出文化来
中国的秀就成了boring了
m**********s
发帖数: 518
10
中华文化的正源在神韵,这是国会拨款认证的。沙壁才去看共产官员表演的节目。
相关主题
FLG sued Chinese gov last time, now cisco's turn无限的需求被挤压在有限的空间
也说说方舟子的英文水平法轮功吗? 中文怎么这么神奇
神韵晚会原来是这个东西啊Chinese Americans for Trump这个口号,本来就是
进入Military版参与讨论
H*****n
发帖数: 89
11
鸡吧中国文化
吉林人导演出来的还不如去看刘老根大舞台二人转
你们菌斑几个傻逼轮子可以穿寿衣表演一个活摘小品

【在 b******s 的大作中提到】
: 这帮左逼歧视中国文化呀。
: 百老汇的逼秀他们就能品出文化来
: 中国的秀就成了boring了

b******s
发帖数: 2919
12
二人转太粗俗了,不能暴露给外国人看

【在 H*****n 的大作中提到】
: 鸡吧中国文化
: 吉林人导演出来的还不如去看刘老根大舞台二人转
: 你们菌斑几个傻逼轮子可以穿寿衣表演一个活摘小品

l*******s
发帖数: 83
13
所以美国真是越来越完蛋了,靠法轮功制造舆论太low,轮子是最傻逼的一群人,红痔
就一东北大忽悠。

【在 m**********s 的大作中提到】
: 中华文化的正源在神韵,这是国会拨款认证的。沙壁才去看共产官员表演的节目。
S*******l
发帖数: 4637
14
去看一次教会的圣诞节演出就明白了,老共和法轮功都是和基督教学的。
天下洗脑一大抄。
圣诞演出就整个一个西方红。三星升,圣人出。Bethlehem出了个大救星。
看的时候就感觉是白人在演东方红音乐舞蹈史诗。
l*******s
发帖数: 83
15
老共也不是宗教跟基督学个屁,现在有几个政权靠基督洗脑的,轮子就更煞笔了上不了
台面。

【在 S*******l 的大作中提到】
: 去看一次教会的圣诞节演出就明白了,老共和法轮功都是和基督教学的。
: 天下洗脑一大抄。
: 圣诞演出就整个一个西方红。三星升,圣人出。Bethlehem出了个大救星。
: 看的时候就感觉是白人在演东方红音乐舞蹈史诗。

1 (共1页)
进入Military版参与讨论
相关主题
普通中国人对欧美的舞蹈/音乐剧/戏剧文化知之甚少轮子把Cisco给告了 (转载)
vma 2017-BEST CHOREOGRAPHY: Kanye WestFLG sued Chinese gov last time, now cisco's turn
我当一回五毛吧也说说方舟子的英文水平
要发财了神韵晚会原来是这个东西啊
轮子V5无限的需求被挤压在有限的空间
授奖刘晓波“是个失误” (转载)法轮功吗? 中文怎么这么神奇
Falun Dafa is Good! Trump is Good!Chinese Americans for Trump这个口号,本来就是
US 'to give $1.5m to Falun Gong internet freedom group'汤姆克鲁斯说他不知道网上可以看黄片
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: falun话题: chinese话题: shen话题: yun话题: gong