由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
ME版 - 审稿发现作者赤裸裸的整段整段抄袭怎么办
相关主题
版上有Sigma Xi的会员吗请教review paper
美国老板还是中国老板?审稿机会 Journal: Atomization and Sprays Review Request
Paper reviewers needed - CFD, heat transfer, combustion background求Transmission tomography 方面的高手review 文章
[转载] 感觉学ME的去monster用处不大一个会议的审稿机会
Looking for reviewers for an international ME conference想申请给MEMS方面的杂志review的机会
Looking for reviewers for an ASME international conferenceAsking for conference paper reviewer (wind and current energy)
Looking for reviewers for an ASME international conference有没有想要审稿机会的朋友
Need help for Paper ReviewingLooking for reviewer for IMECE2011
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: reviewer话题: contents话题: 抄袭话题: paragraph话题: 整段
进入ME版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
b***y
发帖数: 392
1
我还浪费近10个小时来审稿,当然第一遍看就打算据了,写的奇差。长长的据稿意见都
写完了,最后帮原作者推荐最密切相关文献时,发现稿件摘要70%抄袭,介绍部分则完
全抄袭另一杂志文章。打算在原来的评审意见前面加上这几行语句,是不是有些过分呢?
大家说说这种情况该怎么办?
This technical writing is by far the worst the reviewer has ever read or
reviewed. Reading through it is torturing, puzzling and time wasting,
especially when the reviewer find out that the author had borrowed contents
sentence by sentence, paragraph by paragraph from another journal paper,
which is listed below. The reviewer is appalled with the author's attitude
j****x
发帖数: 943
2
ju.
t**o
发帖数: 6659
3
第一句话就好了 然后锯掉 个人意见

呢?
contents
the "

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: 我还浪费近10个小时来审稿,当然第一遍看就打算据了,写的奇差。长长的据稿意见都
: 写完了,最后帮原作者推荐最密切相关文献时,发现稿件摘要70%抄袭,介绍部分则完
: 全抄袭另一杂志文章。打算在原来的评审意见前面加上这几行语句,是不是有些过分呢?
: 大家说说这种情况该怎么办?
: This technical writing is by far the worst the reviewer has ever read or
: reviewed. Reading through it is torturing, puzzling and time wasting,
: especially when the reviewer find out that the author had borrowed contents
: sentence by sentence, paragraph by paragraph from another journal paper,
: which is listed below. The reviewer is appalled with the author's attitude

b***p
发帖数: 1398
4
10 min max
c****z
发帖数: 613
5
这个有点儿过了吧?
据之

呢?
contents

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: 我还浪费近10个小时来审稿,当然第一遍看就打算据了,写的奇差。长长的据稿意见都
: 写完了,最后帮原作者推荐最密切相关文献时,发现稿件摘要70%抄袭,介绍部分则完
: 全抄袭另一杂志文章。打算在原来的评审意见前面加上这几行语句,是不是有些过分呢?
: 大家说说这种情况该怎么办?
: This technical writing is by far the worst the reviewer has ever read or
: reviewed. Reading through it is torturing, puzzling and time wasting,
: especially when the reviewer find out that the author had borrowed contents
: sentence by sentence, paragraph by paragraph from another journal paper,
: which is listed below. The reviewer is appalled with the author's attitude

J****i
发帖数: 470
6
这就是为什么需要reviewer的地方。扒粪的干活。

呢?
contents

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: 我还浪费近10个小时来审稿,当然第一遍看就打算据了,写的奇差。长长的据稿意见都
: 写完了,最后帮原作者推荐最密切相关文献时,发现稿件摘要70%抄袭,介绍部分则完
: 全抄袭另一杂志文章。打算在原来的评审意见前面加上这几行语句,是不是有些过分呢?
: 大家说说这种情况该怎么办?
: This technical writing is by far the worst the reviewer has ever read or
: reviewed. Reading through it is torturing, puzzling and time wasting,
: especially when the reviewer find out that the author had borrowed contents
: sentence by sentence, paragraph by paragraph from another journal paper,
: which is listed below. The reviewer is appalled with the author's attitude

1 (共1页)
进入ME版参与讨论
相关主题
Looking for reviewer for IMECE2011Looking for reviewers for an international ME conference
Journal rejection letterLooking for reviewers for an ASME international conference
有没有想要审稿的朋友?Looking for reviewers for an ASME international conference
thermal fluid area reviewer needed for IMECE2012Need help for Paper Reviewing
版上有Sigma Xi的会员吗请教review paper
美国老板还是中国老板?审稿机会 Journal: Atomization and Sprays Review Request
Paper reviewers needed - CFD, heat transfer, combustion background求Transmission tomography 方面的高手review 文章
[转载] 感觉学ME的去monster用处不大一个会议的审稿机会
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: reviewer话题: contents话题: 抄袭话题: paragraph话题: 整段