由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Investment版 - 命背不能怪社会阿
相关主题
Water Post 2/25/09YTD Showoff (10/16/09)
YTD Showoff (12/03/10)Mutual Fund YTD的计算
401k YTDYTD Showoff (08/06/10)
今天401K全部ALL IN大盘了YTD Showoff (03/31/11)
还是Index吧YTD Showoff (06/30/11)
[合集] 关于DCA的疑问where are the YTD gang?
[合集] 算了一下, 非常disappointing的DCA returnYTD Showoff (10/31/11)
财经网站MF的YTD怎么不一致?[合集] how about you indexers? still DCAing?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: dca话题: long话题: difference话题: 2007话题: today
进入Investment版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
K****D
发帖数: 30533
1
Today I looked back at my trading account record.
I made 5 deposits to the account in history:
6/18/2007
7/23/2007
8/3/2007
10/3/2007
6/24/2008
S&P was at 1531.05, 1541.57, 1433.06, 1539.59, 1314.29 respectively.
Today S&P is at 843.
你说这YTD能好么?? //sigh...
K****D
发帖数: 30533
2
My yield-to-date in my trading account is -33%.
Had I bought SPY each time after I deposited, the yield would be
-48% without dividends (yield should be worse than -43% if dividends
are added.)
So not too bad after all, hehe.

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: Today I looked back at my trading account record.
: I made 5 deposits to the account in history:
: 6/18/2007
: 7/23/2007
: 8/3/2007
: 10/3/2007
: 6/24/2008
: S&P was at 1531.05, 1541.57, 1433.06, 1539.59, 1314.29 respectively.
: Today S&P is at 843.
: 你说这YTD能好么?? //sigh...

s******d
发帖数: 323
3
good. beat the market!

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: My yield-to-date in my trading account is -33%.
: Had I bought SPY each time after I deposited, the yield would be
: -48% without dividends (yield should be worse than -43% if dividends
: are added.)
: So not too bad after all, hehe.

o***e
发帖数: 164
4
1530左右搞了一把.
1000左右又搞一把.想这1000可能是个底.
结果再次被套.
这次680左右用IRA搞了个"反弹".
结果抛得太急(730).只挣了点小钱.
现在做壁上观.

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: Today I looked back at my trading account record.
: I made 5 deposits to the account in history:
: 6/18/2007
: 7/23/2007
: 8/3/2007
: 10/3/2007
: 6/24/2008
: S&P was at 1531.05, 1541.57, 1433.06, 1539.59, 1314.29 respectively.
: Today S&P is at 843.
: 你说这YTD能好么?? //sigh...

n******n
发帖数: 12088
5
According to long-term investment theory, it doesn't matter. :)

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: Today I looked back at my trading account record.
: I made 5 deposits to the account in history:
: 6/18/2007
: 7/23/2007
: 8/3/2007
: 10/3/2007
: 6/24/2008
: S&P was at 1531.05, 1541.57, 1433.06, 1539.59, 1314.29 respectively.
: Today S&P is at 843.
: 你说这YTD能好么?? //sigh...

i******l
发帖数: 828
6
肯尼小弟,你对我老句乐布感兴趣么?
我老对你的投资表示一下古力。。

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: Today I looked back at my trading account record.
: I made 5 deposits to the account in history:
: 6/18/2007
: 7/23/2007
: 8/3/2007
: 10/3/2007
: 6/24/2008
: S&P was at 1531.05, 1541.57, 1433.06, 1539.59, 1314.29 respectively.
: Today S&P is at 843.
: 你说这YTD能好么?? //sigh...

b****e
发帖数: 460
7
I think it does matter at which price to chip in.

【在 n******n 的大作中提到】
: According to long-term investment theory, it doesn't matter. :)
m**********r
发帖数: 887
8
刚开始投资就碰到这个大危机,真的感觉很幸运。
n******n
发帖数: 12088
9
I remember there's some empirical study showing that assuming one lucky one
always buy on local dip while the unlucky one always on local top, the long-
term return doesn't make big difference.

【在 b****e 的大作中提到】
: I think it does matter at which price to chip in.
n******n
发帖数: 12088
10
I remember there's some empirical study showing that assuming one lucky one
always buy on local dip while the unlucky one always on local top, the long-
term return doesn't make big difference.

【在 b****e 的大作中提到】
: I think it does matter at which price to chip in.
相关主题
[合集] 关于DCA的疑问YTD Showoff (10/16/09)
[合集] 算了一下, 非常disappointing的DCA returnMutual Fund YTD的计算
财经网站MF的YTD怎么不一致?YTD Showoff (08/06/10)
进入Investment版参与讨论
K****D
发帖数: 30533
11
how come? It looks so counter-intuitive.

one
long-

【在 n******n 的大作中提到】
: I remember there's some empirical study showing that assuming one lucky one
: always buy on local dip while the unlucky one always on local top, the long-
: term return doesn't make big difference.

l******n
发帖数: 641
12
the 1-2% difference is at least more than the difference in the management f
ees of MF. how come it's no use at all?

one
long-

【在 n******n 的大作中提到】
: I remember there's some empirical study showing that assuming one lucky one
: always buy on local dip while the unlucky one always on local top, the long-
: term return doesn't make big difference.

n******n
发帖数: 12088
13
I think this is DCA's basis: market timing is invalid.

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: how come? It looks so counter-intuitive.
:
: one
: long-

K****D
发帖数: 30533
14
Although I agree with the conclusion, but I disagree with the
proof.
DCA thinks "market timing is invalid" because DCA thinks "nobody
can time the market with more than 55% accuracy", not because
"if someone time the market with 100% accuracy, it still doesn't
make any difference."

【在 n******n 的大作中提到】
: I think this is DCA's basis: market timing is invalid.
n******n
发帖数: 12088
15
Well, you think you can always buy on top?
If not, in long run, your "unlucky" buy will be compensated with lucky ones
later. So I said at the very beginning, it doesn't matter for long-term.

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: Although I agree with the conclusion, but I disagree with the
: proof.
: DCA thinks "market timing is invalid" because DCA thinks "nobody
: can time the market with more than 55% accuracy", not because
: "if someone time the market with 100% accuracy, it still doesn't
: make any difference."

K****D
发帖数: 30533
16
Again, I agree with your conclusion. I am just having trouble
contemplating your post stating:
"I remember there's some empirical study showing that assuming
one lucky one always buy on local dip while the unlucky one always
on local top, the long term return doesn't make big difference."

ones

【在 n******n 的大作中提到】
: Well, you think you can always buy on top?
: If not, in long run, your "unlucky" buy will be compensated with lucky ones
: later. So I said at the very beginning, it doesn't matter for long-term.

n******n
发帖数: 12088
17
I think it just means local variance in shor-term is small compared to long-
term.
But my memory could be wrong...

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: Again, I agree with your conclusion. I am just having trouble
: contemplating your post stating:
: "I remember there's some empirical study showing that assuming
: one lucky one always buy on local dip while the unlucky one always
: on local top, the long term return doesn't make big difference."
:
: ones

K****D
发帖数: 30533
18
I think that depends on how many times you contribute leh.
If doing that all the time throughout 30 years, there is no way
that difference can be neglected.
Maybe your example was talking about doing DCA for 1 year, then
hold for 30 years. Then it makes sense.

long-

【在 n******n 的大作中提到】
: I think it just means local variance in shor-term is small compared to long-
: term.
: But my memory could be wrong...

K****D
发帖数: 30533
19

Wait, even that doesn't make sense either. The only way to work
is DCA with bad luck for 1 year, then DCA for another 29 years
with normal luck.

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: I think that depends on how many times you contribute leh.
: If doing that all the time throughout 30 years, there is no way
: that difference can be neglected.
: Maybe your example was talking about doing DCA for 1 year, then
: hold for 30 years. Then it makes sense.
:
: long-

o***e
发帖数: 164
20
我想他的说法是对的.
过去,一个月内有10%波动都是少见的.
而且一投进去就不动了.
如果每月投资,差别是不大.
现在不一样了,几天就可能10%的变化.
这一个多月下来,超过20%的增长.这在过去
是一年的变化.
这是个充满惊奇的世代!

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: I think that depends on how many times you contribute leh.
: If doing that all the time throughout 30 years, there is no way
: that difference can be neglected.
: Maybe your example was talking about doing DCA for 1 year, then
: hold for 30 years. Then it makes sense.
:
: long-

相关主题
YTD Showoff (03/31/11)YTD Showoff (10/31/11)
YTD Showoff (06/30/11)[合集] how about you indexers? still DCAing?
where are the YTD gang?//sigh, just realized sth about dividend.
进入Investment版参与讨论
b****e
发帖数: 460
21
一个疯狂的市场有助于大牛挣钱

【在 o***e 的大作中提到】
: 我想他的说法是对的.
: 过去,一个月内有10%波动都是少见的.
: 而且一投进去就不动了.
: 如果每月投资,差别是不大.
: 现在不一样了,几天就可能10%的变化.
: 这一个多月下来,超过20%的增长.这在过去
: 是一年的变化.
: 这是个充满惊奇的世代!

K****D
发帖数: 30533
22
偶觉得是有助于赚了钱之后成为大牛。
疯狂的市场是很适合出几个运气好的赌棍的,呵呵。

【在 b****e 的大作中提到】
: 一个疯狂的市场有助于大牛挣钱
b****e
发帖数: 460
23
也是

【在 K****D 的大作中提到】
: 偶觉得是有助于赚了钱之后成为大牛。
: 疯狂的市场是很适合出几个运气好的赌棍的,呵呵。

1 (共1页)
进入Investment版参与讨论
相关主题
[合集] how about you indexers? still DCAing?还是Index吧
//sigh, just realized sth about dividend.[合集] 关于DCA的疑问
I am sad to find out...[合集] 算了一下, 非常disappointing的DCA return
请问现在是rollover 401K的时候吗?财经网站MF的YTD怎么不一致?
Water Post 2/25/09YTD Showoff (10/16/09)
YTD Showoff (12/03/10)Mutual Fund YTD的计算
401k YTDYTD Showoff (08/06/10)
今天401K全部ALL IN大盘了YTD Showoff (03/31/11)
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: dca话题: long话题: difference话题: 2007话题: today