D*********Y
发帖数: 3382 | 1 The IO admitted authority and review. Here is my plan to response the RFE
for contribution. Thanks for the information provided by MITBBS. I hope my
post could help the others too.
Suggestions and comments are appreciated.
1. lack geographic information for citations and letters didn't address how
my work affect the specific authors.
response:
1. the map of authors' distribution
2. tables about the top 20 countries and institutions that have cited my
work.
3. highlight the comments from the recommendation letters about how my work
influenced their study. (I requested for two extra recommendation letters
from original references)
4. list of top 20 authors who cited my work and list the comments
I also provided extra citations from goole scholar
summary
2. My work should attract national or international attention
response:
1. re-emphasize response to question1
2. detail my most recent published paper with referee report along with
editor letter
3. detail my paper published as rapid communication with the introduction of
rapid communication
4. detail my two papers highlighted as editor's suggestion along with an
estimation about how difficult to be selected as editor's suggestion and
cite a recommendation letters' statement, in which the professor said he had
only one editor's suggestion in his career while I had 2 in 18 months
5. list the papers and journal I reviewed and list the citations of the
papers I reviewed.
6. list the comments from references
summary
3. small percentage
response:
1.re-emphasize responses to questions 1 and 2
2. publications and citations compared to top school faculty statistics
3. citations compared to filed average
4. citations compared to the top percentage
5. show the authors who cited my work and the comments on my work to
demonstrate my work's quality
6.the recommendation letter comments
summary
4. sustained acclaim
response;
1. re-emphasize the responses to questions 1, 2 and 3
2. show the chart for publications across years
3. show the chart for citations across years
4. recommendation letters
Summary |
j****t
发帖数: 1663 | 2 不错的策略！
补充一下：
对于第2点：“My work should attract national or international attention”
你可以针对每一篇文章或你的某个工作，列出引用这个工作的文章来自哪些国家和研究
所。这个与第1点中的总引用的国家分布不同，是细化你的每个重要工作/文章也得到了
广泛的关注（用每篇文章的引用分布来论证！） |
m***i
发帖数: 4637 | 3 small percentage要好好再考虑下
比如有没有被cover, comment， top rank 的文章
how
【在 D*********Y 的大作中提到】
: The IO admitted authority and review. Here is my plan to response the RFE
: for contribution. Thanks for the information provided by MITBBS. I hope my
: post could help the others too.
: Suggestions and comments are appreciated.
: 1. lack geographic information for citations and letters didn't address how
: my work affect the specific authors.
: response:
: 1. the map of authors' distribution
: 2. tables about the top 20 countries and institutions that have cited my
: work.
|
D*********Y
发帖数: 3382 | 4 请教什么叫被cover，comment？这些哪里找？
我的一些文章被journal highlight了，我放到了contribution里面了。是不是还可以
拿出来到top rank？谢谢。
【在 m***i 的大作中提到】
: small percentage要好好再考虑下
: 比如有没有被cover, comment， top rank 的文章
:
: how
|
D*********Y
发帖数: 3382 | 5 这个。。。。我的大部分引用来至非第1作者。这个单独列出来有害吧？
【在 j****t 的大作中提到】
: 不错的策略！
: 补充一下：
: 对于第2点：“My work should attract national or international attention”
: 你可以针对每一篇文章或你的某个工作，列出引用这个工作的文章来自哪些国家和研究
: 所。这个与第1点中的总引用的国家分布不同，是细化你的每个重要工作/文章也得到了
: 广泛的关注（用每篇文章的引用分布来论证！）
|
