由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Immigration版 - 请问NIW和EB2的区别
相关主题
急,公司律师的决定请问现在办 EB2 到底要多少年啊?
求助:一个人可以同时file两份485吗?EB1b 求建议
EB1和EB2的485处理进度不一样?跪求EB1B和NIW的问题
求教-PERM/NIW/EB1B请问自己弄NIW还有必要公司走PERM么
急问:请帮我看看我申EB1b是不是risk太大了?谢了先eb1的485的pending 180天 在有排期的情况下怎么算?
EB1B rejected, PERM/NIW approved. EB1A TSC Filed, no response求教: 公司律师申请NIW & 自己个人找律师申请EB1B 可以同时进行嘛?
我的EB1A经验未来12个月EB2排期的展望和分析
讲点要公司律师办Eb1b不办Perm的经验[合集] 未来12个月EB2排期的展望和分析
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: niw话题: perm话题: pd话题: eb1b话题: eb2
进入Immigration版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
l****i
发帖数: 76
1
公司default办EB2,我contact了版上律师,觉得可以办NIW
请问一下,NIW除了可以随时换工作之外,和EB2还有什么区别么?时间方面?过程方面
?成功率方面?
多谢多谢!
e******r
发帖数: 9977
2
niw在时间方面和eb2基本没区别,成功率和个人背景有关,不像perm基本百分百。
当然了,niw要求不高。对想要跳槽的人来说,niw挺合适的

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 公司default办EB2,我contact了版上律师,觉得可以办NIW
: 请问一下,NIW除了可以随时换工作之外,和EB2还有什么区别么?时间方面?过程方面
: ?成功率方面?
: 多谢多谢!

p*******l
发帖数: 2495
3
If you think you are eligible for NIW, why not try to convince your company
to sponsor EB1B?

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 公司default办EB2,我contact了版上律师,觉得可以办NIW
: 请问一下,NIW除了可以随时换工作之外,和EB2还有什么区别么?时间方面?过程方面
: ?成功率方面?
: 多谢多谢!

l****i
发帖数: 76
4
律师说我办EB1B比较risky,而NIW would be fine...虽然我看了requirement觉得叶挺
玄...

company

【在 p*******l 的大作中提到】
: If you think you are eligible for NIW, why not try to convince your company
: to sponsor EB1B?

l****i
发帖数: 76
5
请问NIW和EB2可以同时process么?thanks!

【在 e******r 的大作中提到】
: niw在时间方面和eb2基本没区别,成功率和个人背景有关,不像perm基本百分百。
: 当然了,niw要求不高。对想要跳槽的人来说,niw挺合适的

p*******l
发帖数: 2495
6
The approval rate for Eb1B is higher than NIW. More than 90% of the Eb1B
petitions are approved. If your company will sponsor, why not try?

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 律师说我办EB1B比较risky,而NIW would be fine...虽然我看了requirement觉得叶挺
: 玄...
:
: company

l****i
发帖数: 76
7
公司律师default办EB2,如果要办EB1就得自己找律师,然后公司reimburse. 我联系了
4个律师evaluate,大都不建议我办EB1B。至于NIW,也是只有一个律师提起...

【在 p*******l 的大作中提到】
: The approval rate for Eb1B is higher than NIW. More than 90% of the Eb1B
: petitions are approved. If your company will sponsor, why not try?

p*******l
发帖数: 2495
8
I see. If you can get your NIW approved, NIW generally is quicker than PERM
(i.e., you might get an earlier PD), and there are only two steps: 140+485
For PERM, you have to get the prevailing wage, post the ad, get the PERM
approved (this process can take a long time) and when PERM is approved, 140+
485.
However, if the lawyer is good, PERM should easily get approved (although
many people get audited too). NIW might be riskier comparing with PERM.
Many company lawyers would suggest you to go with PERM, since the procedure
is more standardized than NIW (and may be easier for them).

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 公司律师default办EB2,如果要办EB1就得自己找律师,然后公司reimburse. 我联系了
: 4个律师evaluate,大都不建议我办EB1B。至于NIW,也是只有一个律师提起...

l****i
发帖数: 76
9
Thanks for the advice!

PERM
140+
procedure

【在 p*******l 的大作中提到】
: I see. If you can get your NIW approved, NIW generally is quicker than PERM
: (i.e., you might get an earlier PD), and there are only two steps: 140+485
: For PERM, you have to get the prevailing wage, post the ad, get the PERM
: approved (this process can take a long time) and when PERM is approved, 140+
: 485.
: However, if the lawyer is good, PERM should easily get approved (although
: many people get audited too). NIW might be riskier comparing with PERM.
: Many company lawyers would suggest you to go with PERM, since the procedure
: is more standardized than NIW (and may be easier for them).

l****w
发帖数: 1281
10
NIW比较麻烦啊,写推荐信,要推荐信什么的。Perm不需要这些吧。
相关主题
EB1B rejected, PERM/NIW approved. EB1A TSC Filed, no response请问现在办 EB2 到底要多少年啊?
我的EB1A经验EB1b 求建议
讲点要公司律师办Eb1b不办Perm的经验跪求EB1B和NIW的问题
进入Immigration版参与讨论
p*******l
发帖数: 2495
11
That is true, however, you can control this part (i.e., if yourself work
hard, you might get all the letters back and 140 ready in less than 2 months
).
For PERM, it is all up to your HR and lawyer. I know some friends get PERM
finally submitted after 2 years' preparation.
I forgot to mention the job interview part. After the Ad, the company need
to interview the candidates, if they cannot screen out all of them and give
USCIS a valid reason why all other people are not qualified, they have to re
-start to post the Ad again.
And once the company gets an Audit, that can take years.
However, if the lawyer is really experienced and the company's HR is
efficient and helpful, the PERM process can be significantly shortened (
still cannot be less than 2 months I guess).

【在 l****w 的大作中提到】
: NIW比较麻烦啊,写推荐信,要推荐信什么的。Perm不需要这些吧。
p*******l
发帖数: 2495
12
http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t/EB23/31522235.html

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 请问NIW和EB2可以同时process么?thanks!
e******r
发帖数: 9977
13
赞专业~确实,考虑打广告的时间,perm比niw慢。考虑准备材料,niw比perm费事多了

PERM
140+
procedure

【在 p*******l 的大作中提到】
: I see. If you can get your NIW approved, NIW generally is quicker than PERM
: (i.e., you might get an earlier PD), and there are only two steps: 140+485
: For PERM, you have to get the prevailing wage, post the ad, get the PERM
: approved (this process can take a long time) and when PERM is approved, 140+
: 485.
: However, if the lawyer is good, PERM should easily get approved (although
: many people get audited too). NIW might be riskier comparing with PERM.
: Many company lawyers would suggest you to go with PERM, since the procedure
: is more standardized than NIW (and may be easier for them).

e********t
发帖数: 1865
14
perm process time现在一般也就三个月左右,140还可以PP的,NIW的140快的一两个月
,慢的半年一年的也有,又不能PP, 如果有博士学位,又有一两篇文章,办NIW还不如
拼一下EB1b。
p*******l
发帖数: 2495
15
There is no need to pp PERM 140. This year's EB2-PERM for this year's PD is not current,
and I guess it won't be current very soon.
When considering perm processing time, getting the prevailing wage, post the
ad, interview the candidates should also take into considerations (It took
one of my friends 2-3 years for that process before PERM submission because
of the delay of HR and also they have to redo the ad and interview part
because of some qualified candidates who applied for the job).
When considering PD, PD for PERM is the time PERM is submitted. PD for NIW is the time NIW is submitted. So the processing time for PERM or NIW 140 will not affect PD (if both cases are approved).Generally speaking, if the petitioner works very hard to get the NIW 140 done, the PD for NIW will be earlier than the PD for PERM, and submission time can be controlled by the petitioner.
The time to submit EB2 485 (PERM or NIW) depends on PD, not on whether 140 is approved. Even the 140 is still pending for NIW, if the PD is current, the petitioner can still submit 485.
I agree EB1b is better than NIW. However, LZ is hesitant about that.

【在 e********t 的大作中提到】
: perm process time现在一般也就三个月左右,140还可以PP的,NIW的140快的一两个月
: ,慢的半年一年的也有,又不能PP, 如果有博士学位,又有一两篇文章,办NIW还不如
: 拼一下EB1b。

l****i
发帖数: 76
16
多谢大家的回复!
考虑时间的话,看来NIW和PERM差不太多,而NIW要准备很多材料。我琢磨着要不然跟着
公司律师申PERM,然后自己再找个肯接我case的口碑好的律师拼一下EB1B.
e********t
发帖数: 1865
17
你说的是对的,但是PP140是为了万一公司裁员140没批就前功尽弃了,140批了好歹PD
能保留。就雇主自由这个角度看,NIW是比perm强,不用重复办。

is not current,
the
took
because
is the time NIW is submitted. So the processing time for PERM or NIW 140
will not affect PD (if both cases are approved).Generally speaking, if the
petitioner works very hard to get the NIW 140 done, the PD for NIW will be
earlier than the PD for PERM, and submission time can be controlled by the
petitioner.
is approved. Even the 140 is still pending for NIW, if the PD is current,
the petitioner can still submit 485.

【在 p*******l 的大作中提到】
: There is no need to pp PERM 140. This year's EB2-PERM for this year's PD is not current,
: and I guess it won't be current very soon.
: When considering perm processing time, getting the prevailing wage, post the
: ad, interview the candidates should also take into considerations (It took
: one of my friends 2-3 years for that process before PERM submission because
: of the delay of HR and also they have to redo the ad and interview part
: because of some qualified candidates who applied for the job).
: When considering PD, PD for PERM is the time PERM is submitted. PD for NIW is the time NIW is submitted. So the processing time for PERM or NIW 140 will not affect PD (if both cases are approved).Generally speaking, if the petitioner works very hard to get the NIW 140 done, the PD for NIW will be earlier than the PD for PERM, and submission time can be controlled by the petitioner.
: The time to submit EB2 485 (PERM or NIW) depends on PD, not on whether 140 is approved. Even the 140 is still pending for NIW, if the PD is current, the petitioner can still submit 485.
: I agree EB1b is better than NIW. However, LZ is hesitant about that.

D******D
发帖数: 1159
18
不是中国印度人的话EB1B 不用排期要快很多。
NIW一般来讲比eb1b要求低一点,但是要排期,不过最近排期进度很快。
可以同时申请。
不过EB1B申请一半被裁员就惨了。
p*******l
发帖数: 2495
19
考虑时间的话,看来NIW和PERM差不太多 -- I don't think so. For the people whom
I have seen, the PD for the one who submitted NIW is at least one year
earlier than the one prepared for PERM. Although theoretically the gap
should not be that large, there are too many factors that you cannot control
for PERM.
If I only can choose between PERM and NIW and I am confident about my NIW
case, I will choose NIW.

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 多谢大家的回复!
: 考虑时间的话,看来NIW和PERM差不太多,而NIW要准备很多材料。我琢磨着要不然跟着
: 公司律师申PERM,然后自己再找个肯接我case的口碑好的律师拼一下EB1B.

l****i
发帖数: 76
20
问题是我不confident about NIW...觉得还是比较risky的,所以还是EB2保底吧,现在
排期也挺快的,而且公司的律所据说是highest rating的律所之一,应该比较靠谱。
EB1B or NIW需要折腾的东西太多,等我前阵子submit的paper如果被接收了,再找找看
有没有比较靠谱的律师肯接EB1B吧(现在律师都用long shot, venture,highly risky
形容-_-#...)

whom
control

【在 p*******l 的大作中提到】
: 考虑时间的话,看来NIW和PERM差不太多 -- I don't think so. For the people whom
: I have seen, the PD for the one who submitted NIW is at least one year
: earlier than the one prepared for PERM. Although theoretically the gap
: should not be that large, there are too many factors that you cannot control
: for PERM.
: If I only can choose between PERM and NIW and I am confident about my NIW
: case, I will choose NIW.

相关主题
请问自己弄NIW还有必要公司走PERM么未来12个月EB2排期的展望和分析
eb1的485的pending 180天 在有排期的情况下怎么算?[合集] 未来12个月EB2排期的展望和分析
求教: 公司律师申请NIW & 自己个人找律师申请EB1B 可以同时进行嘛?我估计中国人递交485的数字
进入Immigration版参与讨论
t**g
发帖数: 723
21
两个能不能一起办。
找个好老中律师,只要你有文章且有一定引用率,NIW应该没问题,就是要自己准备很
多材料比较辛苦,但好处是显而易见的:不用依靠雇主,即使被雷了,中间没工作时间
不要太长,交485的时候有对应的工作,就没问题。而且自己请的律师都比较靠谱,基
本不会出现给你搞错耽误的事,递交文件forward各种notice通知递交485都很及时。公
司的律师,就难说了。
当然这也看个人,如果你比较拖拉,比你们公司律师的效率还低,那就算了。

risky

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 问题是我不confident about NIW...觉得还是比较risky的,所以还是EB2保底吧,现在
: 排期也挺快的,而且公司的律所据说是highest rating的律所之一,应该比较靠谱。
: EB1B or NIW需要折腾的东西太多,等我前阵子submit的paper如果被接收了,再找找看
: 有没有比较靠谱的律师肯接EB1B吧(现在律师都用long shot, venture,highly risky
: 形容-_-#...)
:
: whom
: control

d*********y
发帖数: 748
22
show us your background, we will see if you are eligible to file NIW.

【在 l****i 的大作中提到】
: 公司default办EB2,我contact了版上律师,觉得可以办NIW
: 请问一下,NIW除了可以随时换工作之外,和EB2还有什么区别么?时间方面?过程方面
: ?成功率方面?
: 多谢多谢!

h*******1
发帖数: 210
23
一起办是不是要收两份钱?

【在 t**g 的大作中提到】
: 两个能不能一起办。
: 找个好老中律师,只要你有文章且有一定引用率,NIW应该没问题,就是要自己准备很
: 多材料比较辛苦,但好处是显而易见的:不用依靠雇主,即使被雷了,中间没工作时间
: 不要太长,交485的时候有对应的工作,就没问题。而且自己请的律师都比较靠谱,基
: 本不会出现给你搞错耽误的事,递交文件forward各种notice通知递交485都很及时。公
: 司的律师,就难说了。
: 当然这也看个人,如果你比较拖拉,比你们公司律师的效率还低,那就算了。
:
: risky

1 (共1页)
进入Immigration版参与讨论
相关主题
[合集] 未来12个月EB2排期的展望和分析急问:请帮我看看我申EB1b是不是risk太大了?谢了先
我估计中国人递交485的数字EB1B rejected, PERM/NIW approved. EB1A TSC Filed, no response
求意见EB1B+EB2我的EB1A经验
EB1申请如果被拒,在申诉期间可以维持在美的合法身份么?讲点要公司律师办Eb1b不办Perm的经验
急,公司律师的决定请问现在办 EB2 到底要多少年啊?
求助:一个人可以同时file两份485吗?EB1b 求建议
EB1和EB2的485处理进度不一样?跪求EB1B和NIW的问题
求教-PERM/NIW/EB1B请问自己弄NIW还有必要公司走PERM么
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: niw话题: perm话题: pd话题: eb1b话题: eb2