c******a 发帖数: 725 | 1 I just checked my case status, and it is shown that my eb-1b 140 has
been approved. This is my timeline:
2010-3-8, paper filed 140 + pp to NSC
2010-3-14, RFE was sent out
About two or three weeks later, the denial notice was received. The IO
number is 438.
2010-4-6, efile 140 + pp to TSC
2010-4-16, the approval notice was sent out.
My background is:
Economics PhD,
an assistant professor in a state university,
7 English papers + 5 citations
10 journal review
7 recommendation letters, all independ |
t******6 发帖数: 1657 | |
p*******g 发帖数: 2976 | |
A*********r 发帖数: 8271 | |
A*********r 发帖数: 8271 | |
b*********s 发帖数: 13 | |
c******a 发帖数: 725 | 7 social science.
【在 A*********r 的大作中提到】 : 经济算理科吧。
|
J********i 发帖数: 50662 | 8 赞,AP一般都没问题
I just checked my case status, and it is shown that my eb-1b 140 has
been approved. This is my timeline:
2010-3-8, paper filed 140 + pp to NSC
2010-3-14, RFE was sent out
About two or three weeks later, the denial notice was received. The IO
number is 438.
2010-4-6, efile 140 + pp to TSC
2010-4-16, the approval notice was sent out.
My background is:
Economics PhD,
an assistant professor in a Midwest state university,
7 English papers + 5 citations
10 journal review
7 recommendation l
【在 c******a 的大作中提到】 : I just checked my case status, and it is shown that my eb-1b 140 has : been approved. This is my timeline: : 2010-3-8, paper filed 140 + pp to NSC : 2010-3-14, RFE was sent out : About two or three weeks later, the denial notice was received. The IO : number is 438. : 2010-4-6, efile 140 + pp to TSC : 2010-4-16, the approval notice was sent out. : My background is: : Economics PhD,
|
l******5 发帖数: 3030 | 9 LZ应当将题目改成: 一个重要的实例, TSC比NSC容易多了。
【在 c******a 的大作中提到】 : I just checked my case status, and it is shown that my eb-1b 140 has : been approved. This is my timeline: : 2010-3-8, paper filed 140 + pp to NSC : 2010-3-14, RFE was sent out : About two or three weeks later, the denial notice was received. The IO : number is 438. : 2010-4-6, efile 140 + pp to TSC : 2010-4-16, the approval notice was sent out. : My background is: : Economics PhD,
|
y****c 发帖数: 875 | 10 恭喜恭喜!!有个问题请问LZ,你帖子里说的updated petition letter是你回复NSC
RFE用的吗?是不是尽管你说了那么多不应该将你的citation和别的领域的citation做
比较的话,但NSC的IO仍然deny了你的申请?他们为什么这么不讲道理? |
|
|
g********e 发帖数: 862 | 11 我还知道一个同专业的, 文章没楼主多,引用也没提, 审稿也没楼主多, 连RFE都没
收到, 很快就过了。所以强调专业特点很重要。 不是每个专业的文章和引用都象理工
科那么容易的。
【在 l******5 的大作中提到】 : LZ应当将题目改成: 一个重要的实例, TSC比NSC容易多了。
|
j****e 发帖数: 919 | 12 GXGX! thanks for sharing |
d***t 发帖数: 1020 | |
c******a 发帖数: 725 | 14 不是,是为TSC准备的petition letter。当时递交NSC RFE的petition letter和材料的时候,
有些仓促,再加上对比自己和其他学校AP的publications的时候选用的标准不太合理,交上去没两天
就拒了。后来我参考NSC据信修改了petition letter,加上RFE时新要到的reference
letters,才又重新efile的。
【在 y****c 的大作中提到】 : 恭喜恭喜!!有个问题请问LZ,你帖子里说的updated petition letter是你回复NSC : RFE用的吗?是不是尽管你说了那么多不应该将你的citation和别的领域的citation做 : 比较的话,但NSC的IO仍然deny了你的申请?他们为什么这么不讲道理?
|
c******a 发帖数: 725 | 15 是的,这也正是我申请的punch line,希望对大家有用。当然,运气成分可能也有的,
不过这个就不在我掌控之中了。还要感谢学校管移民的美国老太太,6月份就退休了,还是很配合我,
NSC被拒后马上让我试试efile TSC。
所以强调专业特点很重要。 不是每个专业的文章和引用都象理工
【在 g********e 的大作中提到】 : 我还知道一个同专业的, 文章没楼主多,引用也没提, 审稿也没楼主多, 连RFE都没 : 收到, 很快就过了。所以强调专业特点很重要。 不是每个专业的文章和引用都象理工 : 科那么容易的。
|
d********1 发帖数: 8969 | 16 GXGX!
【在 c******a 的大作中提到】 : I just checked my case status, and it is shown that my eb-1b 140 has : been approved. This is my timeline: : 2010-3-8, paper filed 140 + pp to NSC : 2010-3-14, RFE was sent out : About two or three weeks later, the denial notice was received. The IO : number is 438. : 2010-4-6, efile 140 + pp to TSC : 2010-4-16, the approval notice was sent out. : My background is: : Economics PhD,
|
d********1 发帖数: 8969 | 17 GXGX!
【在 c******a 的大作中提到】 : I just checked my case status, and it is shown that my eb-1b 140 has : been approved. This is my timeline: : 2010-3-8, paper filed 140 + pp to NSC : 2010-3-14, RFE was sent out : About two or three weeks later, the denial notice was received. The IO : number is 438. : 2010-4-6, efile 140 + pp to TSC : 2010-4-16, the approval notice was sent out. : My background is: : Economics PhD,
|
c*****n 发帖数: 949 | 18 TSC is much better than nsc!
congratulations!
【在 d********1 的大作中提到】 : GXGX!
|
k*******n 发帖数: 2399 | 19 这个已经不算很经典的实例了。。最经典的莫过于我这个例子,送到NSC RFE NIW被拒,
送到TSC 的EB1-A pp后3天批准。虽然在两次递交的材料我有不少变化,尤其是Review
次数和媒体报道。。不过我坚持认为其他条件都一样的申请者,Citation 20可能在NSC
Eb1-A一点过得希望都没有,不过在TSC材料组织得当有相当过得几率。。
【在 l******5 的大作中提到】 : LZ应当将题目改成: 一个重要的实例, TSC比NSC容易多了。
|
r****6 发帖数: 57 | 20 Congrats!!!
I am also in social science, and this is very encouraging!!!
【在 c******a 的大作中提到】 : I just checked my case status, and it is shown that my eb-1b 140 has : been approved. This is my timeline: : 2010-3-8, paper filed 140 + pp to NSC : 2010-3-14, RFE was sent out : About two or three weeks later, the denial notice was received. The IO : number is 438. : 2010-4-6, efile 140 + pp to TSC : 2010-4-16, the approval notice was sent out. : My background is: : Economics PhD,
|
|
|
n*****e 发帖数: 655 | |
w***c 发帖数: 709 | |
c******a 发帖数: 725 | 23 journal reviews, authorship, original contributions
No reward, no media report, no membership
【在 n*****e 的大作中提到】 : What did you claim?
|
L******y 发帖数: 3292 | |
l**********t 发帖数: 1212 | |
c******a 发帖数: 725 | 26 Some thoughts about efiling
This post matters most for persons who in theory should paper file eb1b 140
to NSC.
First of all, you should push your employer as much as possible to efile
eb1b-140 to TSC. As evidenced by numerous cases including mine, NSC is much
tougher than TSC in terms of the requirement for the number of citations,
reviews, and etc.
However, the petitioner may prefer paper filing for some reasons. For one
thing, efiling is technically more frustrating and demanding than paper
f |
y****c 发帖数: 875 | 27 Thank you very much for sharing, Very helpful! |
y****c 发帖数: 875 | 28 Thank you very much for sharing, Very helpful! |
m******y 发帖数: 46 | 29 恭喜!谢谢分享,希望有更多文科的同学来这里分享经验,指导我们后来人。 |
b*******d 发帖数: 192 | |
|
|
b*****w 发帖数: 56 | |
e******g 发帖数: 86 | |
j****e 发帖数: 919 | 33 nice post, thanks a lot! |