由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
GunsAndGears版 - 有人用9mm的rifle 吗
相关主题
Carbine对于家防的意义?Mp5怎么样? 乌兹怎么样? 怎么没见班上有讨论的?
谁有PS90?!哪位看出来95改
Barrel length and Gas Length~~~~MechTech这个卡宾转换部件很简洁啊
讨论:手枪口径SBR有无存在的意义AR-15枪管前面的导气管位置
Gun stores in NJJason Falla: Carbine's for Duty Carry, Which One and Why?
新手准备进一个92FS,问几个问题anybody has this one?
Beretta CX4 9mm 怎么样?有没有人玩过SIG ACP?
南加军区的训练逐渐步上正轨~~~CS里面的经典枪械,有大侠收藏真枪吗?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: 9mm话题: ar话题: pistol话题: rifle话题: carbines
进入GunsAndGears版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
P******9
发帖数: 183
1
今天在枪店range 租了一把ruger 9mm carbine, 比ruger 10/22感觉好多了。请问有人
用9mm rifle吗?
SHTF时只用一种子弹不是很好吗?
H****r
发帖数: 16240
2
我当年P89没卖掉的时候
倒是想买一支PC9,通用弹匣
但这东西也要六百多块钱
想想不如上AR了

【在 P******9 的大作中提到】
: 今天在枪店range 租了一把ruger 9mm carbine, 比ruger 10/22感觉好多了。请问有人
: 用9mm rifle吗?
: SHTF时只用一种子弹不是很好吗?

b******o
发帖数: 5644
3
如果你有伯来他,直接上他家的就好了,连弹夹都是通用的。
n****e
发帖数: 6292
4
keltec原本只卖两百多,现在涨到300多了。可以通用glock sig beretta等的弹夹
9mm比5.45贵
P******9
发帖数: 183
5
谁给科普一下比较AR,用9mm rifle的优劣?
谢了先

【在 H****r 的大作中提到】
: 我当年P89没卖掉的时候
: 倒是想买一支PC9,通用弹匣
: 但这东西也要六百多块钱
: 想想不如上AR了

g*******t
发帖数: 51
6
用9MM打不穿防弹衣啊,那要RIFLE干吗?
f****t
发帖数: 15913
7
最大的缺点是丑,而且是及丑,细脚零丁的弹匣插进宽大的机匣,就象一个细腿的人穿
了一个宽大的裤衩。

【在 P******9 的大作中提到】
: 谁给科普一下比较AR,用9mm rifle的优劣?
: 谢了先

u*1
发帖数: 907
8
劣势很多的
射程短(装药量少),连续射击后座难控制(枪重量轻),精度低(枪管短,膛线简单
),弹头动能太小,等等
好处是口径和手枪弹通用,很容易做成SBR或者pistol AR?

【在 P******9 的大作中提到】
: 谁给科普一下比较AR,用9mm rifle的优劣?
: 谢了先

a***a
发帖数: 8941
9
No, using 9mm is very easy to control, maybe easier than 223Rem
I used to shot Sten sub-machinegun, very easy to control in full auto
Lots of sub machine guns using 9mm ammo, easier to control than full-auto
rifles

【在 u*1 的大作中提到】
: 劣势很多的
: 射程短(装药量少),连续射击后座难控制(枪重量轻),精度低(枪管短,膛线简单
: ),弹头动能太小,等等
: 好处是口径和手枪弹通用,很容易做成SBR或者pistol AR?

j***n
发帖数: 3786
10
I have a 9mm AR. It is cheap and fun to shoot, but it is still a toy IMO.
相关主题
新手准备进一个92FS,问几个问题Mp5怎么样? 乌兹怎么样? 怎么没见班上有讨论的?
Beretta CX4 9mm 怎么样?哪位看出来95改
南加军区的训练逐渐步上正轨~~~MechTech这个卡宾转换部件很简洁啊
进入GunsAndGears版参与讨论
h*********2
发帖数: 2508
11
It should be more powerful than pistols of the same caliber right?
I've been looking at Beretta CX series too but many people call them 'range
gun', I wonder why? They should be more lethal than pistol and .22 rifle
right?

【在 j***n 的大作中提到】
: I have a 9mm AR. It is cheap and fun to shoot, but it is still a toy IMO.
a***a
发帖数: 8941
12
Yes, you can think it as a semi-auot version sub-machine gun

range

【在 h*********2 的大作中提到】
: It should be more powerful than pistols of the same caliber right?
: I've been looking at Beretta CX series too but many people call them 'range
: gun', I wonder why? They should be more lethal than pistol and .22 rifle
: right?

j***n
发帖数: 3786
13
think about it. when you carry a pistol and a rifle.
why you need a pistol caliber rifle? it is range gun for fun only. im
selling my toys all the time, but will never sell my duty weapons which is a
Custom AR+P226 X5 Tac

range

【在 h*********2 的大作中提到】
: It should be more powerful than pistols of the same caliber right?
: I've been looking at Beretta CX series too but many people call them 'range
: gun', I wonder why? They should be more lethal than pistol and .22 rifle
: right?

p******a
发帖数: 413
14
9mm的sub machine gun还是很牛的,大家仿佛都忘记了MP5这种武器在Urban CQB上的重
要性
j***n
发帖数: 3786
15
yup, sub machine gun... semi auto 9mm is not so effective...

【在 p******a 的大作中提到】
: 9mm的sub machine gun还是很牛的,大家仿佛都忘记了MP5这种武器在Urban CQB上的重
: 要性

h*********2
发帖数: 2508
16

a
But in close range pistol ammo is equally lethal right? like the other guys
said, MP5 and a bunch of other SMGs all use pistol caliber. Last time when I
was on Ellis Island the guards were using MP5. Same with Buckingham Palace
guards.
I can see a point is that SMGs are shorter than a 'range gun' like the CX4,
is that why it's considered a toy (big size small power)?

【在 j***n 的大作中提到】
: think about it. when you carry a pistol and a rifle.
: why you need a pistol caliber rifle? it is range gun for fun only. im
: selling my toys all the time, but will never sell my duty weapons which is a
: Custom AR+P226 X5 Tac
:
: range

f*******t
发帖数: 157
17
How long have you been on duty? Longer than these guys?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler_%26_Koch_MP5#Users

a

【在 j***n 的大作中提到】
: think about it. when you carry a pistol and a rifle.
: why you need a pistol caliber rifle? it is range gun for fun only. im
: selling my toys all the time, but will never sell my duty weapons which is a
: Custom AR+P226 X5 Tac
:
: range

p******a
发帖数: 413
18

您说的这个duty和他说的那个duty不是一回事儿

【在 f*******t 的大作中提到】
: How long have you been on duty? Longer than these guys?
: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler_%26_Koch_MP5#Users
:
: a

f*******t
发帖数: 157
19
duty weapon是条子常用术语,一般老百姓不on duty,所以不这么说

【在 p******a 的大作中提到】
:
: 您说的这个duty和他说的那个duty不是一回事儿

S**********s
发帖数: 4534
20
I wanted a .45ACP carbine for myself too! Why? because I can shoot it on the
pistol range for fun.
more and more agencies have switched over to carbines and SBRs over the
years.
sub guns are still being used because of old training doctrines, abundance
of ammunition and existing units in the arsenal and such. They also have a
natural advantage at suppressed shooting compared to high velocity small
caliber rifle.
Since we don't have half a million of 9mm rounds stockpiled in the garage,
no dozens of SMGs sitting in the gun-rack, nor do most of us have access to
full-auto supressed SMGs, i'd say go straight to a rifle if you mean
business.
SMG was a good idea for a time, when the only low-recoil cartridges suitable
for full-auto fire were the pistol rounds.
nowadays every bank robber and gun-free-zone massacring nut job armed
themselves with full body armors and full power rifles, 9mm pea shooters
just ain't gonna cut it no more.

【在 f*******t 的大作中提到】
: How long have you been on duty? Longer than these guys?
: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler_%26_Koch_MP5#Users
:
: a

相关主题
AR-15枪管前面的导气管位置有没有人玩过SIG ACP?
Jason Falla: Carbine's for Duty Carry, Which One and Why?CS里面的经典枪械,有大侠收藏真枪吗?
anybody has this one?强大的南加军区
进入GunsAndGears版参与讨论
f*******t
发帖数: 157
21
Shot placement is the key.

the
a
to

【在 S**********s 的大作中提到】
: I wanted a .45ACP carbine for myself too! Why? because I can shoot it on the
: pistol range for fun.
: more and more agencies have switched over to carbines and SBRs over the
: years.
: sub guns are still being used because of old training doctrines, abundance
: of ammunition and existing units in the arsenal and such. They also have a
: natural advantage at suppressed shooting compared to high velocity small
: caliber rifle.
: Since we don't have half a million of 9mm rounds stockpiled in the garage,
: no dozens of SMGs sitting in the gun-rack, nor do most of us have access to

S**********s
发帖数: 4534
22
easier said than done.
otherwise North Hollywood shootout would have lasted 44 seconds.
f*******t
发帖数: 157
23
True.
Except for those in serious business, 9mm or 45acp carbines
make good home defense weapon. More fire power than pistol, less over
penetration then rifle, more controllable than rifle or shotgun.
I want a good 45ACP carbines myself, but don't know any good and affordable
ones. HK makes a ridiculously expensive one.

【在 S**********s 的大作中提到】
: easier said than done.
: otherwise North Hollywood shootout would have lasted 44 seconds.

d*******s
发帖数: 15155
24
MP5k似乎是9mm,不过不大给力啊
S**********s
发帖数: 4534
25
I agree that pistol carbines are more fire power than pistol, and home
defense doesn't require concealability.
as far as recoil, I've had the occasion of shooting full-auto Mk18s, and the
recoil was just as light as your full sized AR15, which is a breeze.
in terms of free recoil energy, .223 SBRs only produce about 1 or 2 foot-
pounds of energy more than pistol carbines weighting around 5 pounds, but
stopping power is a whole other story.

affordable

【在 f*******t 的大作中提到】
: True.
: Except for those in serious business, 9mm or 45acp carbines
: make good home defense weapon. More fire power than pistol, less over
: penetration then rifle, more controllable than rifle or shotgun.
: I want a good 45ACP carbines myself, but don't know any good and affordable
: ones. HK makes a ridiculously expensive one.

S**********s
发帖数: 4534
26
HK's plastic USC45 is retardedly overpriced, so I looked around for other .
45 semi carbines and so far this is what I got:
Beretta cx4 .45: not CA legal without bullet button and no readily available
bullet buttons;
Mechtech/hera/whatever 1911 carbine kit: not CA legal without modification;
MasterPiece Arms MPA: ugly as shit;
Hi-Point: it's a hi-point;
Kriss - overpriced;
Auto Ordnance Thompson series - cool to have, but too expensive.
AR .45 - one of the best(only) choices. I plan to buy an AR in the future
and I can use the same lower.
Just Right Carbines - Fairly new, decently priced, CA complaint version is
readily available. takes glock or 1911 magazines. only thing if anything,
that it is not compatible with AR :(
here is a review for Cx4 and JR carbine.
http://www.longislandfirearms.com/forum/m-1337111960.99969/

affordable

【在 f*******t 的大作中提到】
: True.
: Except for those in serious business, 9mm or 45acp carbines
: make good home defense weapon. More fire power than pistol, less over
: penetration then rifle, more controllable than rifle or shotgun.
: I want a good 45ACP carbines myself, but don't know any good and affordable
: ones. HK makes a ridiculously expensive one.

C*******r
发帖数: 10345
27
其实357的lever action步枪不错,比手枪威力大,载弹量10发,射速只要练习一下,
不比半自动慢多少。当然要是有357或.44mag的半自动最好了。
S**********s
发帖数: 4534
28
有啊, Ruger 99/44, 半自动.44 mag.
但我想要pistol carbine不是为了追求家防或者威力, 只是好玩。
家防有霰弹和步枪, .357和.44mag都可以靠边站。
f*******t
发帖数: 157
29
Thanks. AR .45 is the best choice.
CX4 just doesn't look right.

available

【在 S**********s 的大作中提到】
: HK's plastic USC45 is retardedly overpriced, so I looked around for other .
: 45 semi carbines and so far this is what I got:
: Beretta cx4 .45: not CA legal without bullet button and no readily available
: bullet buttons;
: Mechtech/hera/whatever 1911 carbine kit: not CA legal without modification;
: MasterPiece Arms MPA: ugly as shit;
: Hi-Point: it's a hi-point;
: Kriss - overpriced;
: Auto Ordnance Thompson series - cool to have, but too expensive.
: AR .45 - one of the best(only) choices. I plan to buy an AR in the future

f*******t
发帖数: 157
30
停产了,否则值得弄一把

【在 S**********s 的大作中提到】
: 有啊, Ruger 99/44, 半自动.44 mag.
: 但我想要pistol carbine不是为了追求家防或者威力, 只是好玩。
: 家防有霰弹和步枪, .357和.44mag都可以靠边站。

相关主题
坛子里有没有对这种Recon Carbine感兴趣的?谁有PS90?!
这9mm Carbine怎么样?Barrel length and Gas Length~~~~
Carbine对于家防的意义?讨论:手枪口径SBR有无存在的意义
进入GunsAndGears版参与讨论
j***n
发帖数: 3786
31
realli..

【在 f*******t 的大作中提到】
: duty weapon是条子常用术语,一般老百姓不on duty,所以不这么说
j***n
发帖数: 3786
32
now days, most SWAT and SOPs will use SBR .223 with heavier bullet.
MP5 is in the history book now.

【在 f*******t 的大作中提到】
: How long have you been on duty? Longer than these guys?
: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler_%26_Koch_MP5#Users
:
: a

a***a
发帖数: 8941
33
我打过44Mag的杠杆枪,感觉后坐力还是挺大的,不利于速射
另外,如果考虑SHTF的时候跑路,要增加携弹量的话,我比较喜欢轻一些的弹药。
所以,像223,或者5.7x28, 或者9毫米手枪弹也行,但是45ACP太重了,一个人背不了
多少子弹的
H****r
发帖数: 16240
34
嗯,最灵活的还是AR

available

【在 S**********s 的大作中提到】
: HK's plastic USC45 is retardedly overpriced, so I looked around for other .
: 45 semi carbines and so far this is what I got:
: Beretta cx4 .45: not CA legal without bullet button and no readily available
: bullet buttons;
: Mechtech/hera/whatever 1911 carbine kit: not CA legal without modification;
: MasterPiece Arms MPA: ugly as shit;
: Hi-Point: it's a hi-point;
: Kriss - overpriced;
: Auto Ordnance Thompson series - cool to have, but too expensive.
: AR .45 - one of the best(only) choices. I plan to buy an AR in the future

H****r
发帖数: 16240
35
灰猫当年摘编过一篇:
http://www.mitbbs.com/bbsann2/sports.faq/GunsAndGears/D12762159
里面就有Ruger 44 Carbine实战例子
反正现在AR的模块很多
这些东西慢慢都被淘汰了

【在 S**********s 的大作中提到】
: 有啊, Ruger 99/44, 半自动.44 mag.
: 但我想要pistol carbine不是为了追求家防或者威力, 只是好玩。
: 家防有霰弹和步枪, .357和.44mag都可以靠边站。

1 (共1页)
进入GunsAndGears版参与讨论
相关主题
CS里面的经典枪械,有大侠收藏真枪吗?Gun stores in NJ
强大的南加军区新手准备进一个92FS,问几个问题
坛子里有没有对这种Recon Carbine感兴趣的?Beretta CX4 9mm 怎么样?
这9mm Carbine怎么样?南加军区的训练逐渐步上正轨~~~
Carbine对于家防的意义?Mp5怎么样? 乌兹怎么样? 怎么没见班上有讨论的?
谁有PS90?!哪位看出来95改
Barrel length and Gas Length~~~~MechTech这个卡宾转换部件很简洁啊
讨论:手枪口径SBR有无存在的意义AR-15枪管前面的导气管位置
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: 9mm话题: ar话题: pistol话题: rifle话题: carbines