x**********g
发帖数: 618 | 1 Heated discuss during lunch. Niner's fan said it was definitely holding,
Raven's fan said it's not. Who is correct? |
d*****e
发帖数: 16730 | |
l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 3 This is the explanation I tend to agree.
“I feel like its PI if Crabtree keeps his hands off Smith. Once Crabtree
stuck his hand on Smith's helmet and extended his arm, he lost his
protections under the rules, IMO.” |
w***7
发帖数: 5568 | 4 It doesn't matter. The refs wouldn't call it at that point of time anyway.
If you want to blame refs, you should blame a few no calls on Ravens'
defense offsides. One of them was actually shown in replay. It was a clear
offside. |
x**********g
发帖数: 618 | 5 I am indifference, just want to get some opinion. |
B*****s
发帖数: 508 | 6 both way calls.
If I was 49er fan, it's holding. But I am a ravens fan.
【在 x**********g 的大作中提到】
: Heated discuss during lunch. Niner's fan said it was definitely holding,
: Raven's fan said it's not. Who is correct?
|
x**********g
发帖数: 618 | 7 That's exactly what happened. As I am not a fan for both team. I am OK with
any call as long as there is a reasoning.
【在 B*****s 的大作中提到】
: both way calls.
: If I was 49er fan, it's holding. But I am a ravens fan.
|
l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 8 watch the replay again. I think it was on Crabtree's route running, or at
least he was not on the same page as CK. Instead of faking left, then
running right to the pylon, he ran into Smith, stopped and looked at CK,
then ran to where the ball went. He was already entangled with Smith and
slowed down. If he hit the route clean, he should have the separation and
the catch. All the PI and holding calls would not had been relevant. |
