H****t
发帖数: 2542 | 1 With all the due respect to Brees who is also my favorite player,
my MVP vote goes to Rodgers, wholeheartedly.
Rodgers is a slightly better QB. Ok, you can argue on that, but
that's what I saw. I know there is a very popular youtube video about
Brees' accuracy, but in the games, Rodgers amazed me more often.
Rodgers has more value to his team. OK, you can argue on that too,
especially after Flynn's 6TD game. But Flynn is mirage, at most,
like Matt Cassell in 2008. Can Flynn win tough games? Can Flynn
lead the team? We don't know.
Yeah, Brees is a great QB and a great leader too, with stellar stats.
But he plays in dome, plays under offense genius Sean Peyton. Take
those into considerations.
Alright, co-MVP is fair. Both men deserve. | N*****m
发帖数: 42603 | 2 I concur
【在 H****t 的大作中提到】
: With all the due respect to Brees who is also my favorite player,
: my MVP vote goes to Rodgers, wholeheartedly.
: Rodgers is a slightly better QB. Ok, you can argue on that, but
: that's what I saw. I know there is a very popular youtube video about
: Brees' accuracy, but in the games, Rodgers amazed me more often.
: Rodgers has more value to his team. OK, you can argue on that too,
: especially after Flynn's 6TD game. But Flynn is mirage, at most,
: like Matt Cassell in 2008. Can Flynn win tough games? Can Flynn
: lead the team? We don't know.
: Yeah, Brees is a great QB and a great leader too, with stellar stats.
| b**l
发帖数: 33123 | 3 我支持布雷斯，当然我有bias :) 龙哥是很牛的。
【在 H****t 的大作中提到】
: With all the due respect to Brees who is also my favorite player,
: my MVP vote goes to Rodgers, wholeheartedly.
: Rodgers is a slightly better QB. Ok, you can argue on that, but
: that's what I saw. I know there is a very popular youtube video about
: Brees' accuracy, but in the games, Rodgers amazed me more often.
: Rodgers has more value to his team. OK, you can argue on that too,
: especially after Flynn's 6TD game. But Flynn is mirage, at most,
: like Matt Cassell in 2008. Can Flynn win tough games? Can Flynn
: lead the team? We don't know.
: Yeah, Brees is a great QB and a great leader too, with stellar stats.
| p**m
发帖数: 11571 | 4 co MVP吧。我支持。
【在 H****t 的大作中提到】
: With all the due respect to Brees who is also my favorite player,
: my MVP vote goes to Rodgers, wholeheartedly.
: Rodgers is a slightly better QB. Ok, you can argue on that, but
: that's what I saw. I know there is a very popular youtube video about
: Brees' accuracy, but in the games, Rodgers amazed me more often.
: Rodgers has more value to his team. OK, you can argue on that too,
: especially after Flynn's 6TD game. But Flynn is mirage, at most,
: like Matt Cassell in 2008. Can Flynn win tough games? Can Flynn
: lead the team? We don't know.
: Yeah, Brees is a great QB and a great leader too, with stellar stats.
| l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 5 For people who use Flynn's case against Rodgers, did you know Rodgers was
preparing the game, and calling plays for Flynn in no-huddle situations in
the first half.
Not to take any credit away from Flynn's performance, but Flynn did not do
it all alone. McCarthy wanted Rodgers to stay sharp, and play the game
mentally as if he is under center. Not to mention all the things Flynn has
learned from Rodgers after these years. You can't use that against Rodgers
for Flynn trying to be Rodgers. Packers were trying to fit Flynn into the
system that was built around Rodgers, in case if Rodgers is injured, Flynn
can step in without having to change the way everyone else play.
Remember last year's game against NE, Flynn messed up the red zone
opportunity when the time was expiring. He wasn't that good in no-huddle
situations. Rodgers' guidance last Sunday was helpful to him.
I have tons of respect to Brees and supported for Co-MVP. But last week,
when Rodgers was on the sideline doing what's best for the team and staying
laser focused on the one and only goal - winning the SB, Brees for whatever
reason was piling up yards and 5 TDs, just enough to secure the passing yard
record and surpass Rodgers TD total.
Now, personally, I feel it's unfair to Rodgers as the stats are skewed
against him. I went back to support Rodgers as the one and only MVP. | H*******o
发帖数: 504 | 6 支持ar，不过麦卡锡offensive play calling不在佩顿之下吧
【在 H****t 的大作中提到】
: With all the due respect to Brees who is also my favorite player,
: my MVP vote goes to Rodgers, wholeheartedly.
: Rodgers is a slightly better QB. Ok, you can argue on that, but
: that's what I saw. I know there is a very popular youtube video about
: Brees' accuracy, but in the games, Rodgers amazed me more often.
: Rodgers has more value to his team. OK, you can argue on that too,
: especially after Flynn's 6TD game. But Flynn is mirage, at most,
: like Matt Cassell in 2008. Can Flynn win tough games? Can Flynn
: lead the team? We don't know.
: Yeah, Brees is a great QB and a great leader too, with stellar stats.
| l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 7
佩顿显然更花更复杂。这个系统里，朱不理能玩转，相当不容易。
毕竟人家是室内球队，有这个条件。
【在 H*******o 的大作中提到】
: 支持ar，不过麦卡锡offensive play calling不在佩顿之下吧
| B*****e
发帖数: 9375 | 8 Brees played 11 in-door games, had 100+ more pass attempts, had a yard-per-
attempt that's about 1 full yard less, had a TD/INT ratio that's about half
of that of Rodgers, and as for his passing yards record -- FOUR of the top 6
passing yards in the entire history of the NFL happened in 2011. Repeat, 4
of the top 6.
I think the MVP is a clear cut -- close, but clear.
【在 H****t 的大作中提到】
: With all the due respect to Brees who is also my favorite player,
: my MVP vote goes to Rodgers, wholeheartedly.
: Rodgers is a slightly better QB. Ok, you can argue on that, but
: that's what I saw. I know there is a very popular youtube video about
: Brees' accuracy, but in the games, Rodgers amazed me more often.
: Rodgers has more value to his team. OK, you can argue on that too,
: especially after Flynn's 6TD game. But Flynn is mirage, at most,
: like Matt Cassell in 2008. Can Flynn win tough games? Can Flynn
: lead the team? We don't know.
: Yeah, Brees is a great QB and a great leader too, with stellar stats.
| b**l
发帖数: 33123 | 9 这个吧，你只能说龙哥效率更高。MVP, 还是不好说。
half
6
4
【在 B*****e 的大作中提到】
: Brees played 11 in-door games, had 100+ more pass attempts, had a yard-per-
: attempt that's about 1 full yard less, had a TD/INT ratio that's about half
: of that of Rodgers, and as for his passing yards record -- FOUR of the top 6
: passing yards in the entire history of the NFL happened in 2011. Repeat, 4
: of the top 6.
: I think the MVP is a clear cut -- close, but clear.
| h**********e
发帖数: 4328 | 10 play都是rodgers叫的？
那还真是nb啊
【在 l*x 的大作中提到】
: For people who use Flynn's case against Rodgers, did you know Rodgers was
: preparing the game, and calling plays for Flynn in no-huddle situations in
: the first half.
: Not to take any credit away from Flynn's performance, but Flynn did not do
: it all alone. McCarthy wanted Rodgers to stay sharp, and play the game
: mentally as if he is under center. Not to mention all the things Flynn has
: learned from Rodgers after these years. You can't use that against Rodgers
: for Flynn trying to be Rodgers. Packers were trying to fit Flynn into the
: system that was built around Rodgers, in case if Rodgers is injured, Flynn
: can step in without having to change the way everyone else play.
| | | l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 11 only in no huddle situations in the first half.
【在 h**********e 的大作中提到】
: play都是rodgers叫的？
: 那还真是nb啊
| l*******g
发帖数: 28502 | 12 以前好像也就manning干过这事？
【在 h**********e 的大作中提到】
: play都是rodgers叫的？
: 那还真是nb啊
| R*******a
发帖数: 2463 | 13 龙哥第一次玩playoff就被校花干掉了
但从那场球开始，我就震撼于龙哥的超级实力
那时的绿湾进攻还很青涩，而龙哥过于粘球的毛病还没改
但是，稍纵即逝的机会，只要被他看到了，眼到球到no error
Defense是没法防守的
现在看来
龙哥这点是无敌的恐怖
超过这个赛季的阿汤哥，略胜老朱 | s******k
发帖数: 3716 | 14 是绿湾的OL太差，龙哥当时有点粘球但是不能算太过。
如果不是OL，他也不会快到现在这个地步
【在 R*******a 的大作中提到】
: 龙哥第一次玩playoff就被校花干掉了
: 但从那场球开始，我就震撼于龙哥的超级实力
: 那时的绿湾进攻还很青涩，而龙哥过于粘球的毛病还没改
: 但是，稍纵即逝的机会，只要被他看到了，眼到球到no error
: Defense是没法防守的
: 现在看来
: 龙哥这点是无敌的恐怖
: 超过这个赛季的阿汤哥，略胜老朱
| s******k
发帖数: 3716 | 15 龙哥的战绩更好，很多时候不需要他多扔。
如果是绿湾战绩差，你可以说效率不算什么。
【在 b**l 的大作中提到】
: 这个吧，你只能说龙哥效率更高。MVP, 还是不好说。
:
: half
: 6
: 4
| l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 16 当时龙哥粘球是教练故意练的，专门不让他学发叔。宁可被麻袋也不扔INT。
所以龙哥一直对球保护的很好，INT很少。
龙哥在这个前提下，苦练出球快，结果内功大涨，摩步也提升了。
当时发叔倚老卖老，不肯改球风，造成了分歧，才造就了龙哥。 | w******2
发帖数: 2429 | | s******k
发帖数: 3716 | 18 原来如此。发叔出球很快么？只不过是宁愿年吨也不麻袋吧？
【在 l*x 的大作中提到】
: 当时龙哥粘球是教练故意练的，专门不让他学发叔。宁可被麻袋也不扔INT。
: 所以龙哥一直对球保护的很好，INT很少。
: 龙哥在这个前提下，苦练出球快，结果内功大涨，摩步也提升了。
: 当时发叔倚老卖老，不肯改球风，造成了分歧，才造就了龙哥。
|
|
