M******k
发帖数: 27573 | |
l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 2 White was justing running his route, and looking away from the defender. He
did not run into the defender on purpose. So I don't think it is a foul on
White. If both had fell, I would think it could be defensive pass
interference. |
s*****r
发帖数: 477 | 3 这肯定是个犯规，因为white有明显的推人动作，wilson并不在他的route上
如果call了进攻PI或者illegal contact，就罚出飞狗区了
He
【在 l*x 的大作中提到】
: White was justing running his route, and looking away from the defender. He
: did not run into the defender on purpose. So I don't think it is a foul on
: White. If both had fell, I would think it could be defensive pass
: interference.
|
l*x
发帖数: 14021 | 4 Maybe you are right. I didn't have a chance to watch the replay in slow
motion. That was just my first reaction.
Same thing happened last year in the Cardinal and Packers' play off game.
Fizgerad ran right over Woodson for an easy TD, and that was no flag.
I mean, the league favors the offence, so in this close situation, I am not
surprised that was no call.
I do think the catch around the mid field should not have been a catch.
【在 s*****r 的大作中提到】
: 这肯定是个犯规，因为white有明显的推人动作，wilson并不在他的route上
: 如果call了进攻PI或者illegal contact，就罚出飞狗区了
:
: He
|
s*****r
发帖数: 477 | 5 several key decisions by referee are questionable.
unfortunately, they are all against guest team, which makes me feel like it
is
as dirty as NBA
not
【在 l*x 的大作中提到】
: Maybe you are right. I didn't have a chance to watch the replay in slow
: motion. That was just my first reaction.
: Same thing happened last year in the Cardinal and Packers' play off game.
: Fizgerad ran right over Woodson for an easy TD, and that was no flag.
: I mean, the league favors the offence, so in this close situation, I am not
: surprised that was no call.
: I do think the catch around the mid field should not have been a catch.
|
a******n
发帖数: 4290 | 6
it
NFL里面，很多黑哨是不上电视的，比如OL line的holding。人头那么杂，场地那么大
，动作那么快。除了裁判，很多holding根本就看不出来。
这一点不像NBA, 就那么大的场地，任何黑哨都一清二楚。
【在 s*****r 的大作中提到】
: several key decisions by referee are questionable.
: unfortunately, they are all against guest team, which makes me feel like it
: is
: as dirty as NBA
:
: not
|
s*****r
发帖数: 477 | 7 falcon这场比赛一共就一个penalty，5yard
只能说他们控制penalty很成功
【在 a******n 的大作中提到】
:
: it
: NFL里面，很多黑哨是不上电视的，比如OL line的holding。人头那么杂，场地那么大
: ，动作那么快。除了裁判，很多holding根本就看不出来。
: 这一点不像NBA, 就那么大的场地，任何黑哨都一清二楚。
|
x****m
发帖数: 130 | 8 我觉得white没有故意要推。他只是本能的shake off。对方CB太弱了不经contact。另
外奇怪的是为什么这个时候还要single coverage。 |
a****y
发帖数: 2548 | 9 White为什么不会故意推？眼看就没有时间了，推开防守队员，拿到球就踢地，加上自己
主场，多半是有意推了一把。
不过没有仔细回放那个防守队员倒地的镜头，倒是踢地后防守队员对着裁判拼命说话，
那意思是这么明显的犯规也不吹。
NFL的确是越来越像NBA了。
【在 x****m 的大作中提到】
: 我觉得white没有故意要推。他只是本能的shake off。对方CB太弱了不经contact。另
: 外奇怪的是为什么这个时候还要single coverage。
|
z*i
发帖数: 58873 | 10 主场最后一个drive, 除了是牛仔这种破鼓乱人捶的球队，一般都不会吹的。
核心问题是那个时候居然对落地白不double coverage，实在不能理解。
自己
【在 a****y 的大作中提到】
: White为什么不会故意推？眼看就没有时间了，推开防守队员，拿到球就踢地，加上自己
: 主场，多半是有意推了一把。
: 不过没有仔细回放那个防守队员倒地的镜头，倒是踢地后防守队员对着裁判拼命说话，
: 那意思是这么明显的犯规也不吹。
: NFL的确是越来越像NBA了。
|
