s****y
发帖数: 3416 | 1 转载
http://chronicle.com/forums/index.php/topic,189815.0.html
Don't recall if it was a job talk or a conference one, but when the
presenter was finished, a hand went up in the audience, and roughly here is
how the Q & A went from there (NOT word-for-word to keep things anonymous):
Presenter (P): "You in the back."
Audience Member (AM): "I am not sure if you cited XY accurately. Could you
clarify, please?"
P: "I cited XY right, did you read the paper?"
AM: "I think I know that study, and I am not sure you cited them correctly,
but please do clarify, as I may be wrong."
P: "I read the study, and I am right. Who are you to question me?"
AM: "I am XY, the person who wrote that article." | j*****n
发帖数: 82 | 2 Most likely a conference talk. If it were a job talk, the candidate failed
already in the first half of the Q & A -- how could you not recognize the
person working in the same field as you in that department, especially given
you cited his/her work?
is
,
【在 s****y 的大作中提到】
: 转载
: http://chronicle.com/forums/index.php/topic,189815.0.html
: Don't recall if it was a job talk or a conference one, but when the
: presenter was finished, a hand went up in the audience, and roughly here is
: how the Q & A went from there (NOT word-for-word to keep things anonymous):
: Presenter (P): "You in the back."
: Audience Member (AM): "I am not sure if you cited XY accurately. Could you
: clarify, please?"
: P: "I cited XY right, did you read the paper?"
: AM: "I think I know that study, and I am not sure you cited them correctly,
|
|
